SynapseLayer
Operome - StGB consolidated, half one (§171 to §177)
eleven sections · ten-rule standard · objective elements only · §184h term by name · exemptions live where the statute grants them
eleven sections · ten-rule standard · objective elements only · §184h term by name · exemptions live where the statute grants them
{Variable} input · [Computable] act / derived · «if … end if» condition · struck excluded · word-for-word dissection; the law is reconstructable from the substrate
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
Any person who grossly violates their duty of care or upbringing towards a person under the age of sixteen and thereby exposes the person in their care to the risk of suffering significant harm to their physical or mental development, leading a criminal lifestyle or engaging in prostitution shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine.
«if BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing is true»{Actor} «if {Violates} is true»{Grossly} violates their «if {DutyOfCare} is true»duty of care«end if» «if {Upbringing} is true»or upbringing«end if»«end if» towards {Person} «if [PersonUnder16] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit16} «end if» and thereby «if {Exposes} is true»exposes {Person} «if {InCare} is true»in their care «end if» to the {Risk} «end if» of «if {SuffersHarm} is true»suffering {Significant} harm to {Person}'s «if {PhysicalDevelopment} is true»physical development«end if» «if {MentalDevelopment} is true»or mental development«end if»«end if» «if {Leads} is true», leading {CriminalLifestyle} «end if» «if {Engages} is true»or engaging in {Prostitution} «end if» shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[GrossViolation] = Violates is true and Grossly is true and (DutyOfCare is true or Upbringing is true)
[PersonUnder16] = PersonAge < AgeLimit16
[HarmRisk] = SuffersHarm is true and Significant is true and (PhysicalDevelopment is true or MentalDevelopment is true)
[RiskOutcome] = HarmRisk is true or Leads is true or Engages is true
[Endangerment] = Exposes is true and InCare is true and RiskOutcome is true
[BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing] = GrossViolation is true and PersonUnder16 is true and Endangerment is true
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BCU-R01 | act | Actor | Violates is true | |
| BCU-R02 | act | Actor | Exposes is true | |
| BCU-R03 | act | Actor | SuffersHarm is true | |
| BCU-R04 | act | Actor | Leads is true | |
| BCU-R05 | act | Actor | Engages is true | |
| BCU-R06 | condition | None | InCare is true | |
| BCU-R07 | condition | None | Grossly is true | |
| BCU-R08 | condition | None | Significant is true | |
| BCU-R09 | condition | None | DutyOfCare is true | |
| BCU-R10 | condition | None | Upbringing is true | |
| BCU-R11 | condition | None | PhysicalDevelopment is true | |
| BCU-R12 | condition | None | MentalDevelopment is true | |
| BCU-R90 | condition | None | the person is under the age of sixteen | PersonUnder16 is true |
| BCU-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} violates a duty | Merkmal | {Violates} | BCU-R01 | is true |
| {Actor} exposes {Person} to a risk | Merkmal | {Exposes} | BCU-R02 | is true |
| {Person} suffers harm | Merkmal | {SuffersHarm} | BCU-R03 | is true |
| {Person} leads a way of life | Merkmal | {Leads} | BCU-R04 | is true |
| {Person} engages in an activity | Merkmal | {Engages} | BCU-R05 | is true |
| {Person} is in {Actor}'s care | Merkmal | {InCare} | BCU-R06 | is true |
| the violation is gross | Merkmal | {Grossly} | BCU-R07 | is true |
| the harm is significant | Merkmal | {Significant} | BCU-R08 | is true |
| the duty of care is at issue | Merkmal | {DutyOfCare} | BCU-R09 | is true |
| the duty of upbringing is at issue | Merkmal | {Upbringing} | BCU-R10 | is true |
| the harm is to {Person}'s physical development | Merkmal | {PhysicalDevelopment} | BCU-R11 | is true |
| the harm is to {Person}'s mental development | Merkmal | {MentalDevelopment} | BCU-R12 | is true |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AgeLimit16} | Number | – | Session | sixteen years |
| {CriminalLifestyle} | Party | – | Session | a criminal lifestyle |
| {DutyOfCare} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the duty of care is at issue |
| {Engages} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} engages in an activity |
| {Exposes} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} exposes {Person} to a risk |
| {Grossly} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the violation is gross |
| {InCare} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is in {Actor}'s care |
| {Leads} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} leads a way of life |
| {MentalDevelopment} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the harm is to {Person}'s mental development |
| {Person} | Party | – | Session | the protected person |
| {PersonAge} | Number | – | Session | the age of {Person} in years |
| {PhysicalDevelopment} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the harm is to {Person}'s physical development |
| {Prostitution} | Party | – | Session | prostitution |
| {Risk} | Party | – | Session | a risk |
| {Significant} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the harm is significant |
| {SuffersHarm} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} suffers harm |
| {Upbringing} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the duty of upbringing is at issue |
| {Violates} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} violates a duty |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: ({Actor} violates a duty and the violation is gross and (the duty of care is at issue or the duty of upbringing is at issue)) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit16) and ({Actor} exposes {Person} to a risk and {Person} is in {Actor}'s care and (({Person} suffers harm and the harm is significant and (the harm is to {Person}'s physical development or the harm is to {Person}'s mental development)) or {Person} leads a way of life or {Person} engages in an activity)).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [GrossViolation] | Violates, Grossly, DutyOfCare, Upbringing | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [PersonUnder16] | PersonAge, AgeLimit16 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [HarmRisk] | SuffersHarm, Significant, PhysicalDevelopment, MentalDevelopment | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [RiskOutcome] | HarmRisk, Leads, Engages | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Endangerment] | Exposes, InCare, RiskOutcome | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing] | GrossViolation, PersonUnder16, Endangerment | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (BCU-P0) | [BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AgeLimit16}
├─ {CriminalLifestyle}
├─ {DutyOfCare}
├─ {Engages}
├─ {Exposes}
├─ {Grossly}
├─ {InCare}
├─ {Leads}
├─ {MentalDevelopment}
├─ {Person}
├─ {PersonAge}
├─ {PhysicalDevelopment}
├─ {Prostitution}
├─ {Risk}
├─ {Significant}
├─ {SuffersHarm}
├─ {Upbringing}
├─ {Violates}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [GrossViolation] = Violates is true and Grossly is true and (DutyOfCare is true or Upbringing is true)
├─ [PersonUnder16] = PersonAge < AgeLimit16
├─ [HarmRisk] = SuffersHarm is true and Significant is true and (PhysicalDevelopment is true or MentalDevelopment is true)
├─ [RiskOutcome] = HarmRisk is true or Leads is true or Engages is true
├─ [Endangerment] = Exposes is true and InCare is true and RiskOutcome is true
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing] = GrossViolation is true and PersonUnder16 is true and Endangerment is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing] depends on [GrossViolation], [PersonUnder16], [HarmRisk], [RiskOutcome], [Endangerment]; none refer back to [BreachOfDutyOfCareOrUpbringing]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q2 | Session | {AgeLimit16} | Element/Datum: sixteen years.? | Number |
| Q3 | Session | {CriminalLifestyle} | Element/Datum: a criminal lifestyle.? | Party |
| Q4 | Session | {DutyOfCare} | Element/Datum: the duty of care is at issue.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {Engages} | Element/Datum: {Person} engages in an activity.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {Exposes} | Element/Datum: {Actor} exposes {Person} to a risk.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {Grossly} | Element/Datum: the violation is gross.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {InCare} | Element/Datum: {Person} is in {Actor}'s care.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {Leads} | Element/Datum: {Person} leads a way of life.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {MentalDevelopment} | Element/Datum: the harm is to {Person}'s mental development.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {Person} | Element/Datum: the protected person.? | Party |
| Q12 | Session | {PersonAge} | Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.? | Number |
| Q13 | Session | {PhysicalDevelopment} | Element/Datum: the harm is to {Person}'s physical development.? | Boolean |
| Q14 | Session | {Prostitution} | Element/Datum: prostitution.? | Party |
| Q15 | Session | {Risk} | Element/Datum: a risk.? | Party |
| Q16 | Session | {Significant} | Element/Datum: the harm is significant.? | Boolean |
| Q17 | Session | {SuffersHarm} | Element/Datum: {Person} suffers harm.? | Boolean |
| Q18 | Session | {Upbringing} | Element/Datum: the duty of upbringing is at issue.? | Boolean |
| Q19 | Session | {Violates} | Element/Datum: {Actor} violates a duty.? | Boolean |
Flags
Verb and object separated {Violates} is the span; the duty objects sit inside it (rule 1).
Coordinated objects carry logic {DutyOfCare} or {Upbringing}, and {PhysicalDevelopment} or {MentalDevelopment}, are Boolean object variables whose disjunction lives in the GrossViolation and HarmRisk computables. No connective is decorative (rule 10).
Single objects are references {Risk}, {CriminalLifestyle}, {Prostitution}, {Person} stand alone with no coordination, so they remain reference variables (rule 3).
Qualifiers as variables {Grossly} and {Significant} gate the violation and the harm in the logic (rule 4).
Nested relational rule “in their care” is {InCare} nested inside the {Exposes} span (rule 5).
One span per verb, connectives bound Suffering harm is a single {SuffersHarm} span; the outcome connectives are folded into the {Leads} and {Engages} spans, the disjunction carried by RiskOutcome (rule 2, 7).
Strike Penalty struck in the markup only (rule 9).
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) Any person who has sexual intercourse with a biological descendant shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (2) Any person who has sexual intercourse with a biological ascendant shall be punished with imprisonment for up to two years or a fine; this shall also apply where the family relationship has ceased to exist. Biological siblings who have sexual intercourse with one another shall likewise be punished. (3) Descendants and siblings shall not be punished under this provision if they were under the age of eighteen at the time of the offence.
«if [Leg1] is true or [Leg2] is true or [LegSiblings] is true and not [AgeExemption] is true»(1) {Actor} «if {HasSexualIntercourse} is true»has sexual intercourse with «end if» «if {IsBiologicalDescendant} is true»a {BiologicalDescendant} «end if» shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (2) {Actor} «if {HasSexualIntercourse} is true»has sexual intercourse with «end if» «if {IsBiologicalAscendant} is true»a {BiologicalAscendant}«if {FamilyRelationshipCeased} is true», including where the family relationship has ceased to exist «end if»«end if» shall be punished with imprisonment for up to two years or a fine. «if {AreBiologicalSiblings} is true»{Actor} and a {Sibling} are biological siblings «end if» who «if {HasSexualIntercourse} is true»have sexual intercourse with one another «end if» shall likewise be punished. «end if» (3) «if {ExemptDescendant} is true»a descendant «end if» «if {ExemptSibling} is true»or a sibling «end if» who was «if {ActorUnder18} is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» at the time of the offence is not punished under this provision.
Annexes
Computables
[Leg2] = HasSexualIntercourse is true and IsBiologicalAscendant is true
[ActorUnder18] = ActorAge < AgeLimit18
[ExemptDescendant] = IsBiologicalAscendant is true and ActorUnder18 is true
[ExemptSibling] = AreBiologicalSiblings is true and ActorUnder18 is true
[AgeExemption] = ExemptDescendant is true or ExemptSibling is true
[Leg1] = HasSexualIntercourse is true and IsBiologicalDescendant is true
[LegSiblings] = HasSexualIntercourse is true and AreBiologicalSiblings is true
[SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives] = (Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or LegSiblings is true) and not AgeExemption
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SIR-R01 | act | Actor | HasSexualIntercourse is true | |
| SIR-R02 | condition | None | biological descendant of the actor | IsBiologicalDescendant is true |
| SIR-R03 | condition | None | biological ascendant of the actor | IsBiologicalAscendant is true |
| SIR-R04 | condition | None | being biological siblings | AreBiologicalSiblings is true |
| SIR-R05 | condition | None | the family relationship has ceased to exist (non-defeating) | FamilyRelationshipCeased is true |
| SIR-R90 | condition | None | the actor was under eighteen at the time of the offence | ActorUnder18 is true |
| SIR-R91 | condition | None | descendant offender exemption | ExemptDescendant is true |
| SIR-R92 | condition | None | sibling offender exemption | ExemptSibling is true |
| SIR-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| has sexual intercourse | Merkmal (verb, all legs) | {HasSexualIntercourse} | SIR-R01 | is true |
| with a biological descendant | status, leg 1 (actor is the ascendant) | {IsBiologicalDescendant} | SIR-R02 | is true |
| with a biological ascendant | status, leg 2 (actor is the descendant) | {IsBiologicalAscendant} | SIR-R03 | is true |
| biological siblings | status, leg 3 | {AreBiologicalSiblings} | SIR-R04 | is true |
| relationship has ceased | clarifier, nested in leg 2 (non-defeating) | {FamilyRelationshipCeased} | SIR-R05 | does not defeat leg 2 |
| descendant under eighteen | exemption class | [ExemptDescendant] | SIR-R91 | negates liability |
| sibling under eighteen | exemption class | [ExemptSibling] | SIR-R92 | negates liability |
| ascendant offender | not exempt | — | — | liable regardless of age |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {ActorAge} | Number | – | Session | the age of {Actor} in years |
| {AgeLimit18} | Number | – | Session | eighteen years |
| {AreBiologicalSiblings} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological sibling |
| {BiologicalAscendant} | Party | – | Session | a biological ascendant of {Actor} |
| {BiologicalDescendant} | Party | – | Session | a biological descendant of {Actor} |
| {FamilyRelationshipCeased} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the family relationship has ceased to exist |
| {HasSexualIntercourse} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} has sexual intercourse |
| {IsBiologicalAscendant} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological ascendant |
| {IsBiologicalDescendant} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological descendant |
| {Sibling} | Party | – | Session | a biological sibling of {Actor} |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: (({Actor} has sexual intercourse and the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological descendant) or ({Actor} has sexual intercourse and the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological ascendant) or ({Actor} has sexual intercourse and the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological sibling)) and not AgeExemption.
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [Leg2] | HasSexualIntercourse, IsBiologicalAscendant | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ActorUnder18] | ActorAge, AgeLimit18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ExemptDescendant] | IsBiologicalAscendant, ActorUnder18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ExemptSibling] | AreBiologicalSiblings, ActorUnder18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [AgeExemption] | ExemptDescendant, ExemptSibling | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg1] | HasSexualIntercourse, IsBiologicalDescendant | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [LegSiblings] | HasSexualIntercourse, AreBiologicalSiblings | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives] | Leg1, Leg2, LegSiblings, AgeExemption | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (SIR-P0) | [SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Actor}
├─ {ActorAge}
├─ {AgeLimit18}
├─ {AreBiologicalSiblings}
├─ {BiologicalAscendant}
├─ {BiologicalDescendant}
├─ {FamilyRelationshipCeased}
├─ {HasSexualIntercourse}
├─ {IsBiologicalAscendant}
├─ {IsBiologicalDescendant}
├─ {Sibling}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [Leg2] = HasSexualIntercourse is true and IsBiologicalAscendant is true
├─ [ActorUnder18] = ActorAge < AgeLimit18
├─ [ExemptDescendant] = IsBiologicalAscendant is true and ActorUnder18 is true
├─ [ExemptSibling] = AreBiologicalSiblings is true and ActorUnder18 is true
├─ [AgeExemption] = ExemptDescendant is true or ExemptSibling is true
├─ [Leg1] = HasSexualIntercourse is true and IsBiologicalDescendant is true
├─ [LegSiblings] = HasSexualIntercourse is true and AreBiologicalSiblings is true
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives] = (Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or LegSiblings is true) and not AgeExemption
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives] depends on [Leg2], [ActorUnder18], [ExemptDescendant], [ExemptSibling], [AgeExemption], [Leg1], [LegSiblings]; none refer back to [SexualIntercourseBetweenRelatives]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q2 | Session | {ActorAge} | Element/Datum: the age of {Actor} in years.? | Number |
| Q3 | Session | {AgeLimit18} | Element/Datum: eighteen years.? | Number |
| Q4 | Session | {AreBiologicalSiblings} | Element/Datum: the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological sibling.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {BiologicalAscendant} | Element/Datum: a biological ascendant of {Actor}.? | Party |
| Q6 | Session | {BiologicalDescendant} | Element/Datum: a biological descendant of {Actor}.? | Party |
| Q7 | Session | {FamilyRelationshipCeased} | Element/Datum: the family relationship has ceased to exist.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {HasSexualIntercourse} | Element/Datum: {Actor} has sexual intercourse.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {IsBiologicalAscendant} | Element/Datum: the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological ascendant.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {IsBiologicalDescendant} | Element/Datum: the counterparty is {Actor}'s biological descendant.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {Sibling} | Element/Datum: a biological sibling of {Actor}.? | Party |
Flags
Composite Legs feed the composite directly with the exemption lifted to a top-level negation: (Leg1 or Leg2 or LegSiblings) and not AgeExemption. No intermediate definition computable.
Legs are the alternatives Paragraphs 1, 2 and the siblings sentence are the three leg sub-spans named in the top span, so the disjunction is structural and machine-readable rather than prose (rule 7).
Cessation linked “this also applies where the family relationship has ceased” is nested inside the ascendant-status span of leg 2 as a non-defeating clarifier, not floating (rule 7).
Exemption distinguishes the classes The exemption protects a descendant offender ({IsBiologicalAscendant}, i.e. the actor is the descendant of an ascendant counterparty) and a sibling offender, each under eighteen. The ascendant offender (leg 1, {IsBiologicalDescendant}) is deliberately outside the exemption and remains liable regardless of age (rule 8).
Strikes Penalties in (1) and (2), “shall likewise be punished”, and “is not punished under this provision” in (3) are struck in the markup only (rule 9, the last two per the annotations).
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) Any person who commits sexual acts 1. on a person under the age of eighteen who has been entrusted to them for upbringing or guidance in the conduct of their life, 2. on a person under the age of eighteen who is subordinate to them within the framework of a training, service or employment relationship, by abusing a dependency associated with that training, service or employment relationship, or 3. against a person under the age of eighteen who is his or her biological or legal descendant or that of his or her spouse, civil partner or a person with whom he or she lives in a marriage-like or civil partnership-like relationship, performs such acts on the ward, or has the ward perform them on the actor, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. A person who, under the conditions set out in the first sentence, causes the ward to perform sexual acts on or in front of a third person, or to allow a third person to perform such acts on them, shall be punished in the same way. (2) A person who, in a designated institution, is entrusted with the upbringing, education or supervision of persons under the age of eighteen, and who commits sexual acts 1. on a person under the age of sixteen who has a legal relationship with that institution serving the purpose of their upbringing, education or guidance, or has the acts performed on them, or 2. by exploiting their position, on a person under the age of eighteen who is in a legal relationship with that institution. A person shall likewise be punished who, under the conditions set out in the first sentence, causes the person under their care to perform sexual acts on or in front of a third person, or to allow a third person to perform such acts on them. (3) Any person who, under the conditions set out in paragraph 1 or 2 1. performs sexual acts in front of the ward in order to sexually arouse themselves or the ward, or 2. instructs the ward to perform sexual acts in his presence, shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or to a fine. (4) An attempt is punishable. (5) In the cases referred to in paragraph 1, first sentence, number 1; paragraph 2, first sentence, number 1; or paragraph 3 in conjunction with paragraph 1 or 2, the court may refrain from imposing a penalty under this provision if the wrongfulness of the act is minor.
«if AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare is true»(1) {Actor} «if {Commits} is true»commits «end if» [SexualActs] 1. on {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» who «if {HasBeenEntrusted} is true»has been entrusted to {Actor} for «if {Upbringing} is true»upbringing «end if» «if {GuidanceInConductOfLife} is true»or guidance in the conduct of their life «end if» «end if», 2. on {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» who «if {IsSubordinate} is true»is subordinate to {Actor} within the framework of «if {TrainingRelationship} is true»a training relationship «end if» «if {ServiceRelationship} is true», a service relationship «end if» «if {EmploymentRelationship} is true»or an employment relationship «end if» «end if», «if {Abuses} is true»by abusing a {Dependency} associated with that relationship «end if», or 3. on {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» who «if {DescendantOfActorBiological} is true»is {Actor}'s biological descendant «end if» «if {DescendantOfActorLegal} is true»or legal descendant «end if» «if {DescendantOfSpouse} is true»or that of {Actor}'s {Spouse} «end if» «if {DescendantOfCivilPartner} is true»or {CivilPartner} «end if» «if {DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant} is true»or {MarriageLikeCohabitant} «end if» «if {DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} is true»or {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} «end if», «if {PerformsOnWard} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {HasWardPerformOnActor} is true»or has {Person} perform [SexualActs] on {Actor} «end if» shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. A person who, «if [Sentence1Conditions] is true»under the conditions set out in the first sentence «end if», «if {Causes} is true»causes «end if» {Person} to «if {WardPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson} is true»or in front of {ThirdPerson} «end if», or «if {WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} is true»to allow {ThirdPerson} to perform [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if», shall be punished in the same way. (2) A person who «if {Entrusted} is true»is entrusted in a «if {Designated} is true»designated «end if» {Institution} with the «if {Upbringing} is true»upbringing «end if» «if {Education} is true», education «end if» «if {Supervision} is true»or supervision «end if» of persons «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» «end if», and «if {Commits} is true»commits «end if» [SexualActs] 1. on {Person} «if [PersonUnder16] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit16} «end if» who «if {WardInstLegalRelationship} is true»has a legal relationship with that {Institution} serving the purpose of their «if {Upbringing} is true»upbringing «end if» «if {Education} is true», education «end if» «if {Supervision} is true»or guidance «end if» «end if», «if {PerformsOnWard} is true»performing [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {HasWardPerformOnActor} is true»or having {Person} perform [SexualActs] on {Actor} «end if», or 2. «if {Exploits} is true»by exploiting that position «end if», on {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» who «if {WardInstLegalRelationship} is true»is in a legal relationship with that {Institution} «end if». A person, «if [Para2Role] is true»under the conditions set out in the first sentence «end if», «if {Causes} is true»causes «end if» {Person} to «if {WardPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson} is true»or in front of {ThirdPerson} «end if», or «if {WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} is true»to allow {ThirdPerson} to perform [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if», shall likewise be punished. (3) Any person who, «if [Para1Or2Conditions] is true»under the conditions set out in paragraph 1 or 2 «end if» 1. «if {PerformsInFrontOfWard} is true»performs [SexualActs] in front of {Person} «end if» in order to sexually arouse themselves or the ward, or 2. «if {InstructsWardToPerformInPresence} is true»instructs {Person} to perform [SexualActs] in {Actor}'s presence «end if», shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or to a fine. (4) An attempt is punishable. (5) In the cases referred to in paragraph 1, first sentence, number 1; paragraph 2, first sentence, number 1; or paragraph 3 in conjunction with paragraph 1 or 2, the court may refrain from imposing a penalty under this provision if the wrongfulness of the act is minor.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[PersonUnder16] = PersonAge < AgeLimit16
[InstitutionalPurpose] = Upbringing is true or Education is true or Supervision is true
[PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18
[Para2Role] = Entrusted is true and Designated is true and InstitutionalPurpose is true and PersonUnder18 is true
[ThirdPersonConduct] = WardPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson is true or WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true
[Para2Extension] = Para2Role is true and Causes is true and ThirdPersonConduct is true
[WardInstRelationship] = WardInstLegalRelationship is true and InstitutionalPurpose is true
[Para2SubLeg1] = Para2Role is true and WardInstRelationship is true and PersonUnder16 is true and (PerformsOnWard is true or HasWardPerformOnActor is true)
[Para2SubLeg2] = Para2Role is true and WardInstRelationship is true and PersonUnder18 is true and Exploits is true and (PerformsOnWard is true or HasWardPerformOnActor is true)
[Para2] = SexualActs is true and (Para2SubLeg1 is true or Para2SubLeg2 is true or Para2Extension is true)
[Leg3] = (DescendantOfActorBiological is true or DescendantOfActorLegal is true or DescendantOfSpouse is true or DescendantOfCivilPartner is true or DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant is true or DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant is true) and PersonUnder18 is true
[Leg1] = HasBeenEntrusted is true and (Upbringing is true or GuidanceInConductOfLife is true) and PersonUnder18 is true
[Leg2] = IsSubordinate is true and (TrainingRelationship is true or ServiceRelationship is true or EmploymentRelationship is true) and Abuses is true and PersonUnder18 is true
[Sentence1Conditions] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or Leg3 is true
[Sentence1Conduct] = Commits is true and (PerformsOnWard is true or HasWardPerformOnActor is true)
[Para1Sentence1] = SexualActs is true and Sentence1Conditions is true and Sentence1Conduct is true
[Para1Sentence2] = SexualActs is true and Sentence1Conditions is true and Causes is true and ThirdPersonConduct is true
[Para1] = Para1Sentence1 is true or Para1Sentence2 is true
[Para3Modality] = PerformsInFrontOfWard is true or InstructsWardToPerformInPresence is true
[Para1Or2Conditions] = Sentence1Conditions is true or Para2Role is true
[Para3] = SexualActs is true and Para1Or2Conditions is true and Para3Modality is true
[AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true or Para3 is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SXP-R01 | act | Actor | Commits is true | |
| SXP-R02 | act | Actor | PerformsOnWard is true | |
| SXP-R03 | act | Actor | HasWardPerformOnActor is true | |
| SXP-R04 | condition | None | HasBeenEntrusted is true | |
| SXP-R05 | condition | None | Upbringing is true | |
| SXP-R06 | condition | None | GuidanceInConductOfLife is true | |
| SXP-R07 | condition | None | IsSubordinate is true | |
| SXP-R08 | condition | None | TrainingRelationship is true | |
| SXP-R09 | condition | None | ServiceRelationship is true | |
| SXP-R10 | condition | None | EmploymentRelationship is true | |
| SXP-R11 | act | Actor | Abuses is true | |
| SXP-R12 | condition | None | DescendantOfActorBiological is true | |
| SXP-R13 | condition | None | DescendantOfActorLegal is true | |
| SXP-R14 | condition | None | DescendantOfSpouse is true | |
| SXP-R15 | condition | None | DescendantOfCivilPartner is true | |
| SXP-R16 | condition | None | DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant is true | |
| SXP-R17 | condition | None | DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant is true | |
| SXP-R18 | act | Actor | Causes is true | |
| SXP-R19 | act | Actor | WardPerformsOnThirdPerson is true | |
| SXP-R20 | act | Actor | WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson is true | |
| SXP-R21 | act | Actor | WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true | |
| SXP-R22 | act | Actor | Entrusted is true | |
| SXP-R23 | condition | None | Designated is true | |
| SXP-R24 | condition | None | Education is true | |
| SXP-R25 | condition | None | Supervision is true | |
| SXP-R26 | condition | None | WardInstLegalRelationship is true | |
| SXP-R27 | act | Actor | Exploits is true | |
| SXP-R28 | act | Actor | PerformsInFrontOfWard is true | |
| SXP-R29 | act | Actor | InstructsWardToPerformInPresence is true | |
| SXP-R90 | condition | None | the person is under the age of eighteen | PersonUnder18 is true |
| SXP-R91 | condition | None | the person is under the age of sixteen | PersonUnder16 is true |
| SXP-R92 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| SXP-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} commits | Merkmal | {Commits} | SXP-R01 | is true |
| {Actor} performs the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {PerformsOnWard} | SXP-R02 | is true |
| {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {HasWardPerformOnActor} | SXP-R03 | is true |
| {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} | Merkmal | {HasBeenEntrusted} | SXP-R04 | is true |
| upbringing | Merkmal | {Upbringing} | SXP-R05 | is true |
| guidance in the conduct of life | Merkmal | {GuidanceInConductOfLife} | SXP-R06 | is true |
| {Person} is subordinate to {Actor} | Merkmal | {IsSubordinate} | SXP-R07 | is true |
| within the framework of a training relationship | Merkmal | {TrainingRelationship} | SXP-R08 | is true |
| within the framework of a service relationship | Merkmal | {ServiceRelationship} | SXP-R09 | is true |
| within the framework of an employment relationship | Merkmal | {EmploymentRelationship} | SXP-R10 | is true |
| {Actor} abuses a {Dependency} associated with that relationship | Merkmal | {Abuses} | SXP-R11 | is true |
| {Person} is {Actor}'s biological descendant | Merkmal | {DescendantOfActorBiological} | SXP-R12 | is true |
| {Person} is {Actor}'s legal descendant | Merkmal | {DescendantOfActorLegal} | SXP-R13 | is true |
| {Person} is a descendant of {Spouse} | Merkmal | {DescendantOfSpouse} | SXP-R14 | is true |
| {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartner} | Merkmal | {DescendantOfCivilPartner} | SXP-R15 | is true |
| {Person} is a descendant of {MarriageLikeCohabitant} | Merkmal | {DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant} | SXP-R16 | is true |
| {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} | Merkmal | {DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} | SXP-R17 | is true |
| {Actor} causes {Person} | Merkmal | {Causes} | SXP-R18 | is true |
| {Person} performs the act on {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {WardPerformsOnThirdPerson} | SXP-R19 | is true |
| {Person} performs the act in front of {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson} | SXP-R20 | is true |
| {Person} allows {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} | SXP-R21 | is true |
| {Actor} is entrusted | Merkmal | {Entrusted} | SXP-R22 | is true |
| the institution is designated | Merkmal | {Designated} | SXP-R23 | is true |
| education | Merkmal | {Education} | SXP-R24 | is true |
| supervision in the conduct of life | Merkmal | {Supervision} | SXP-R25 | is true |
| {Person} has a legal relationship with that {Institution} | Merkmal | {WardInstLegalRelationship} | SXP-R26 | is true |
| {Actor} exploits that position | Merkmal | {Exploits} | SXP-R27 | is true |
| {Actor} performs the act in front of {Person} | Merkmal | {PerformsInFrontOfWard} | SXP-R28 | is true |
| {Actor} instructs {Person} to perform the act in {Actor}'s presence | Merkmal | {InstructsWardToPerformInPresence} | SXP-R29 | is true |
| special intent (§174(3) no.1) | subjective | — excluded — | — | struck |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Abuses} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} abuses a {Dependency} associated with that relationship |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AgeLimit16} | Number | – | Session | sixteen years |
| {AgeLimit18} | Number | – | Session | eighteen years |
| {Causes} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} causes {Person} |
| {CivilPartner} | Party | – | Session | {Actor}'s civil partner |
| {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} | Party | – | Session | a person with whom {Actor} lives in a civil-partnership-like relationship |
| {Commits} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} commits |
| {Dependency} | Party | – | Session | a dependency |
| {DescendantOfActorBiological} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is {Actor}'s biological descendant |
| {DescendantOfActorLegal} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is {Actor}'s legal descendant |
| {DescendantOfCivilPartner} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartner} |
| {DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} |
| {DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is a descendant of {MarriageLikeCohabitant} |
| {DescendantOfSpouse} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is a descendant of {Spouse} |
| {Designated} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the institution is designated |
| {Education} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | education |
| {EmploymentRelationship} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | within the framework of an employment relationship |
| {Entrusted} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} is entrusted |
| {Exploits} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} exploits that position |
| {GuidanceInConductOfLife} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | guidance in the conduct of life |
| {HasBeenEntrusted} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} |
| {HasWardPerformOnActor} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} |
| {Institution} | Party | – | Session | a designated institution |
| {InstructsWardToPerformInPresence} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} instructs {Person} to perform the act in {Actor}'s presence |
| {IsSubordinate} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is subordinate to {Actor} |
| {MarriageLikeCohabitant} | Party | – | Session | a person with whom {Actor} lives in a marriage-like relationship |
| {PerformsInFrontOfWard} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act in front of {Person} |
| {PerformsOnWard} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act on {Person} |
| {Person} | Party | – | Session | the protected person (the ward) |
| {PersonAge} | Number | – | Session | the age of {Person} in years |
| {ServiceRelationship} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | within the framework of a service relationship |
| {Spouse} | Party | – | Session | {Actor}'s spouse |
| {Supervision} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | supervision in the conduct of life |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third person |
| {TrainingRelationship} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | within the framework of a training relationship |
| {Upbringing} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | upbringing |
| {WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} allows {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person} |
| {WardInstLegalRelationship} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} has a legal relationship with that {Institution} |
| {WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} performs the act in front of {ThirdPerson} |
| {WardPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} performs the act on {ThirdPerson} |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (({Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} and (upbringing or guidance in the conduct of life) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) or ({Person} is subordinate to {Actor} and (within the framework of a training relationship or within the framework of a service relationship or within the framework of an employment relationship) and {Actor} abuses a {Dependency} associated with that relationship and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) or (({Person} is {Actor}'s biological descendant or {Person} is {Actor}'s legal descendant or {Person} is a descendant of {Spouse} or {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartner} or {Person} is a descendant of {MarriageLikeCohabitant} or {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant}) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18))) and ({Actor} commits and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}))) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (({Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} and (upbringing or guidance in the conduct of life) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) or ({Person} is subordinate to {Actor} and (within the framework of a training relationship or within the framework of a service relationship or within the framework of an employment relationship) and {Actor} abuses a {Dependency} associated with that relationship and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) or (({Person} is {Actor}'s biological descendant or {Person} is {Actor}'s legal descendant or {Person} is a descendant of {Spouse} or {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartner} or {Person} is a descendant of {MarriageLikeCohabitant} or {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant}) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18))) and {Actor} causes {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on {ThirdPerson} or {Person} performs the act in front of {ThirdPerson} or {Person} allows {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}))) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and ((({Actor} is entrusted and the institution is designated and (upbringing or education or supervision in the conduct of life) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) and ({Person} has a legal relationship with that {Institution} and (upbringing or education or supervision in the conduct of life)) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit16) and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor})) or (({Actor} is entrusted and the institution is designated and (upbringing or education or supervision in the conduct of life) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) and ({Person} has a legal relationship with that {Institution} and (upbringing or education or supervision in the conduct of life)) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and {Actor} exploits that position and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor})) or (({Actor} is entrusted and the institution is designated and (upbringing or education or supervision in the conduct of life) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) and {Actor} causes {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on {ThirdPerson} or {Person} performs the act in front of {ThirdPerson} or {Person} allows {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person})))) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and ((({Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} and (upbringing or guidance in the conduct of life) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) or ({Person} is subordinate to {Actor} and (within the framework of a training relationship or within the framework of a service relationship or within the framework of an employment relationship) and {Actor} abuses a {Dependency} associated with that relationship and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18)) or (({Person} is {Actor}'s biological descendant or {Person} is {Actor}'s legal descendant or {Person} is a descendant of {Spouse} or {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartner} or {Person} is a descendant of {MarriageLikeCohabitant} or {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant}) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18))) or ({Actor} is entrusted and the institution is designated and (upbringing or education or supervision in the conduct of life) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18))) and ({Actor} performs the act in front of {Person} or {Actor} instructs {Person} to perform the act in {Actor}'s presence)).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [PersonUnder16] | PersonAge, AgeLimit16 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [InstitutionalPurpose] | Upbringing, Education, Supervision | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [PersonUnder18] | PersonAge, AgeLimit18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Role] | Entrusted, Designated, InstitutionalPurpose, PersonUnder18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ThirdPersonConduct] | WardPerformsOnThirdPerson, WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson, WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Extension] | Para2Role, Causes, ThirdPersonConduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [WardInstRelationship] | WardInstLegalRelationship, InstitutionalPurpose | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2SubLeg1] | Para2Role, WardInstRelationship, PersonUnder16, PerformsOnWard, HasWardPerformOnActor | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2SubLeg2] | Para2Role, WardInstRelationship, PersonUnder18, Exploits, PerformsOnWard, HasWardPerformOnActor | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2] | SexualActs, Para2SubLeg1, Para2SubLeg2, Para2Extension | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg3] | DescendantOfActorBiological, DescendantOfActorLegal, DescendantOfSpouse, DescendantOfCivilPartner, DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant, DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant, PersonUnder18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg1] | HasBeenEntrusted, Upbringing, GuidanceInConductOfLife, PersonUnder18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg2] | IsSubordinate, TrainingRelationship, ServiceRelationship, EmploymentRelationship, Abuses, PersonUnder18 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Sentence1Conditions] | Leg1, Leg2, Leg3 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Sentence1Conduct] | Commits, PerformsOnWard, HasWardPerformOnActor | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1Sentence1] | SexualActs, Sentence1Conditions, Sentence1Conduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1Sentence2] | SexualActs, Sentence1Conditions, Causes, ThirdPersonConduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1] | Para1Sentence1, Para1Sentence2 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para3Modality] | PerformsInFrontOfWard, InstructsWardToPerformInPresence | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1Or2Conditions] | Sentence1Conditions, Para2Role | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para3] | SexualActs, Para1Or2Conditions, Para3Modality | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare] | Para1, Para2, Para3 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (SXP-P0) | [AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Abuses}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AgeLimit16}
├─ {AgeLimit18}
├─ {Causes}
├─ {CivilPartner}
├─ {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant}
├─ {Commits}
├─ {Dependency}
├─ {DescendantOfActorBiological}
├─ {DescendantOfActorLegal}
├─ {DescendantOfCivilPartner}
├─ {DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant}
├─ {DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant}
├─ {DescendantOfSpouse}
├─ {Designated}
├─ {Education}
├─ {EmploymentRelationship}
├─ {Entrusted}
├─ {Exploits}
├─ {GuidanceInConductOfLife}
├─ {HasBeenEntrusted}
├─ {HasWardPerformOnActor}
├─ {Institution}
├─ {InstructsWardToPerformInPresence}
├─ {IsSubordinate}
├─ {MarriageLikeCohabitant}
├─ {PerformsInFrontOfWard}
├─ {PerformsOnWard}
├─ {Person}
├─ {PersonAge}
├─ {ServiceRelationship}
├─ {Spouse}
├─ {Supervision}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
├─ {TrainingRelationship}
├─ {Upbringing}
├─ {WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform}
├─ {WardInstLegalRelationship}
├─ {WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson}
├─ {WardPerformsOnThirdPerson}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [PersonUnder16] = PersonAge < AgeLimit16
├─ [InstitutionalPurpose] = Upbringing is true or Education is true or Supervision is true
├─ [PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18
├─ [Para2Role] = Entrusted is true and Designated is true and InstitutionalPurpose is true and PersonUnder18 is true
├─ [ThirdPersonConduct] = WardPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson is true or WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true
├─ [Para2Extension] = Para2Role is true and Causes is true and ThirdPersonConduct is true
├─ [WardInstRelationship] = WardInstLegalRelationship is true and InstitutionalPurpose is true
├─ [Para2SubLeg1] = Para2Role is true and WardInstRelationship is true and PersonUnder16 is true and (PerformsOnWard is true or HasWardPerformOnActor is true)
├─ [Para2SubLeg2] = Para2Role is true and WardInstRelationship is true and PersonUnder18 is true and Exploits is true and (PerformsOnWard is true or HasWardPerformOnActor is true)
├─ [Para2] = SexualActs is true and (Para2SubLeg1 is true or Para2SubLeg2 is true or Para2Extension is true)
├─ [Leg3] = (DescendantOfActorBiological is true or DescendantOfActorLegal is true or DescendantOfSpouse is true or DescendantOfCivilPartner is true or DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant is true or DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant is true) and PersonUnder18 is true
├─ [Leg1] = HasBeenEntrusted is true and (Upbringing is true or GuidanceInConductOfLife is true) and PersonUnder18 is true
├─ [Leg2] = IsSubordinate is true and (TrainingRelationship is true or ServiceRelationship is true or EmploymentRelationship is true) and Abuses is true and PersonUnder18 is true
├─ [Sentence1Conditions] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or Leg3 is true
├─ [Sentence1Conduct] = Commits is true and (PerformsOnWard is true or HasWardPerformOnActor is true)
├─ [Para1Sentence1] = SexualActs is true and Sentence1Conditions is true and Sentence1Conduct is true
├─ [Para1Sentence2] = SexualActs is true and Sentence1Conditions is true and Causes is true and ThirdPersonConduct is true
├─ [Para1] = Para1Sentence1 is true or Para1Sentence2 is true
├─ [Para3Modality] = PerformsInFrontOfWard is true or InstructsWardToPerformInPresence is true
├─ [Para1Or2Conditions] = Sentence1Conditions is true or Para2Role is true
├─ [Para3] = SexualActs is true and Para1Or2Conditions is true and Para3Modality is true
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true or Para3 is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare] depends on [PersonUnder16], [InstitutionalPurpose], [PersonUnder18], [Para2Role], [ThirdPersonConduct], [Para2Extension], [WardInstRelationship], [Para2SubLeg1], [Para2SubLeg2], [Para2], [Leg3], [Leg1], [Leg2], [Sentence1Conditions], [Sentence1Conduct], [Para1Sentence1], [Para1Sentence2], [Para1], [Para3Modality], [Para1Or2Conditions], [Para3] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [AbuseOfPersonsUnderCare]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Abuses} | Element/Datum: {Actor} abuses a {Dependency} associated with that relationship.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q3 | Session | {AgeLimit16} | Element/Datum: sixteen years.? | Number |
| Q4 | Session | {AgeLimit18} | Element/Datum: eighteen years.? | Number |
| Q5 | Session | {Causes} | Element/Datum: {Actor} causes {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {CivilPartner} | Element/Datum: {Actor}'s civil partner.? | Party |
| Q7 | Session | {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} | Element/Datum: a person with whom {Actor} lives in a civil-partnership-like relationship.? | Party |
| Q8 | Session | {Commits} | Element/Datum: {Actor} commits.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {Dependency} | Element/Datum: a dependency.? | Party |
| Q10 | Session | {DescendantOfActorBiological} | Element/Datum: {Person} is {Actor}'s biological descendant.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {DescendantOfActorLegal} | Element/Datum: {Person} is {Actor}'s legal descendant.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {DescendantOfCivilPartner} | Element/Datum: {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartner}.? | Boolean |
| Q13 | Session | {DescendantOfCivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} | Element/Datum: {Person} is a descendant of {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant}.? | Boolean |
| Q14 | Session | {DescendantOfMarriageLikeCohabitant} | Element/Datum: {Person} is a descendant of {MarriageLikeCohabitant}.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {DescendantOfSpouse} | Element/Datum: {Person} is a descendant of {Spouse}.? | Boolean |
| Q16 | Session | {Designated} | Element/Datum: the institution is designated.? | Boolean |
| Q17 | Session | {Education} | Element/Datum: education.? | Boolean |
| Q18 | Session | {EmploymentRelationship} | Element/Datum: within the framework of an employment relationship.? | Boolean |
| Q19 | Session | {Entrusted} | Element/Datum: {Actor} is entrusted.? | Boolean |
| Q20 | Session | {Exploits} | Element/Datum: {Actor} exploits that position.? | Boolean |
| Q21 | Session | {GuidanceInConductOfLife} | Element/Datum: guidance in the conduct of life.? | Boolean |
| Q22 | Session | {HasBeenEntrusted} | Element/Datum: {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q23 | Session | {HasWardPerformOnActor} | Element/Datum: {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q24 | Session | {Institution} | Element/Datum: a designated institution.? | Party |
| Q25 | Session | {InstructsWardToPerformInPresence} | Element/Datum: {Actor} instructs {Person} to perform the act in {Actor}'s presence.? | Boolean |
| Q26 | Session | {IsSubordinate} | Element/Datum: {Person} is subordinate to {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q27 | Session | {MarriageLikeCohabitant} | Element/Datum: a person with whom {Actor} lives in a marriage-like relationship.? | Party |
| Q28 | Session | {PerformsInFrontOfWard} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act in front of {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q29 | Session | {PerformsOnWard} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q30 | Session | {Person} | Element/Datum: the protected person (the ward).? | Party |
| Q31 | Session | {PersonAge} | Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.? | Number |
| Q32 | Session | {ServiceRelationship} | Element/Datum: within the framework of a service relationship.? | Boolean |
| Q33 | Session | {Spouse} | Element/Datum: {Actor}'s spouse.? | Party |
| Q34 | Session | {Supervision} | Element/Datum: supervision in the conduct of life.? | Boolean |
| Q35 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third person.? | Party |
| Q36 | Session | {TrainingRelationship} | Element/Datum: within the framework of a training relationship.? | Boolean |
| Q37 | Session | {Upbringing} | Element/Datum: upbringing.? | Boolean |
| Q38 | Session | {WardAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} | Element/Datum: {Person} allows {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q39 | Session | {WardInstLegalRelationship} | Element/Datum: {Person} has a legal relationship with that {Institution}.? | Boolean |
| Q40 | Session | {WardPerformsInFrontOfThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act in front of {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q41 | Session | {WardPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
Flags
Ten-rule sweep Coordinated purpose objects renamed to bare object nouns ({Upbringing}, {GuidanceInConductOfLife}, {Education}, {Supervision}) and nested inside their governing spans ({HasBeenEntrusted}, {IsSubordinate}, {Entrusted}, {WardInstLegalRelationship}); connectives folded into the second and later blocks; every disjunction carried in a computable (rules 1, 2, 5, 7, 10).
Whole section Paragraphs 1 to 3 of §174: the three private-care legs and the third-person extension; the institutional variant with its under-sixteen and under-eighteen-by-exploitation sub-legs and extension; the two without-contact modalities conditioned on paragraph 1 or 2.
Translation notes The English follows the German in the source column: the dropped governing modality restored (performs on the ward, or has the ward perform on the actor), and Abkömmling rendered descendant, not child. No inline highlight (R1, R2).
Every verb a rule {Commits}, {HasBeenEntrusted}, {IsSubordinate}, {Abuses}, {Causes}, {Entrusted}, {Exploits}, {PerformsInFrontOfWard}, {InstructsWardToPerformInPresence} are rules; objects are separate variables (R4, R5).
Age “under” is the computable [PersonUnder18] / [PersonUnder16]; the limits are {AgeLimit18} and {AgeLimit16}; the comparison is in the computable Definition, not glossed in the markup (R3). The limit is referenced in each leg as the text repeats it (R10).
Dependency “by abusing a dependency associated with that relationship” is {Abuses} (action) over {Dependency} (object), the association referring back to the leg-2 relationship (R8).
Relations as variables {Spouse}, {CivilPartner}, {MarriageLikeCohabitant}, {CivilPartnershipLikeCohabitant} are variables; the descendant relation is the rule (R5).
Cross-references [Sentence1Conditions], [Para2Role] and [Para1Or2Conditions] carry “the conditions of the first sentence” and “of paragraph 1 or 2” (R9).
Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, named by the term) for every “sexual acts” and “such acts” (R7, R11). Strikes (penalties, intent, (4), (5)) live in the markup only; the source column is clean (R1).
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) Any person who commits sexual acts on a prisoner or a person detained by order of the authorities who has been entrusted to him for education, training, supervision or care, or allows such acts to be performed on him or her by the prisoner or person in custody, or causes the prisoner or person in custody to perform or tolerate sexual acts on or by a third person, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) A person who abuses a person admitted to an institution for sick or vulnerable persons and entrusted to him for supervision or care by exploiting that person’s illness or vulnerability to perform sexual acts on them or have them performed on him, or by causing that person to perform or tolerate sexual acts on or by a third person, shall be punished in the same manner. (3) An attempt is punishable.
«if AbuseOfPersonInCustody is true»(1) {Actor} «if {Commits} is true»commits «end if» [SexualActs] on «if {IsPrisoner} is true»a prisoner «end if» «if {IsDetainedByAuthorities} is true»or a person detained by order of the authorities «end if» who «if {HasBeenEntrusted} is true»has been entrusted to {Actor} for «if {Education} is true»education «end if» «if {Training} is true», training «end if» «if {Supervision} is true», supervision «end if» «if {Care} is true»or care «end if» «end if», or «if {AllowsVictimToPerform} is true»allows such acts to be performed on {Actor} by {Person} «end if», or «if {Causes} is true»causes «end if» {Person} to «if {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} is true»or tolerate [SexualActs] by a {ThirdPerson} «end if», shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) {Actor} «if {Abuses} is true»abuses «end if» {Person} «if {Admitted} is true»admitted to an {Institution} «if {SickPersons} is true»for sick «end if» «if {VulnerablePersons} is true»or vulnerable persons «end if» «end if» and «if {HasBeenEntrusted} is true»entrusted to {Actor} «if {Supervision} is true»for supervision «end if» «if {Care} is true»or care «end if» «end if» by «if {Exploits} is true»exploiting «if {Illness} is true»that person's illness «end if» «if {Vulnerability} is true»or vulnerability «end if» «end if» to «if {PerformsOnVictim} is true»perform [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {HasVictimPerformOnActor} is true»or have them performed on {Actor} «end if», or by «if {Causes} is true»causing «end if» {Person} to «if {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} is true»or tolerate [SexualActs] by a {ThirdPerson} «end if», shall be punished in the same manner. (3) An attempt is punishable.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[ThirdPersonConduct] = Causes is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
[Para2Conduct] = PerformsOnVictim is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
[EntrustmentPurpose] = Education is true or Training is true or Supervision is true or Care is true
[VictimStatus] = IsPrisoner is true or IsDetainedByAuthorities is true
[Para1Conduct] = Commits is true or AllowsVictimToPerform is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
[InstitutionDesignation] = SickPersons is true or VulnerablePersons is true
[Para2Setting] = Admitted is true and InstitutionDesignation is true and HasBeenEntrusted is true and (Supervision is true or Care is true)
[Exploitation] = Exploits is true and (Illness is true or Vulnerability is true)
[Para2] = SexualActs is true and Abuses is true and Para2Setting is true and Exploitation is true and Para2Conduct is true
[Para1Relationship] = VictimStatus is true and HasBeenEntrusted is true and EntrustmentPurpose is true
[Para1] = SexualActs is true and Para1Relationship is true and Para1Conduct is true
[AbuseOfPersonInCustody] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PIC-R01 | act | Actor | Commits is true | |
| PIC-R02 | condition | None | IsPrisoner is true | |
| PIC-R03 | condition | None | IsDetainedByAuthorities is true | |
| PIC-R04 | condition | None | HasBeenEntrusted is true | |
| PIC-R05 | condition | None | Education is true | |
| PIC-R06 | condition | None | Training is true | |
| PIC-R07 | condition | None | Supervision is true | |
| PIC-R08 | condition | None | Care is true | |
| PIC-R09 | act | Actor | AllowsVictimToPerform is true | |
| PIC-R10 | act | Actor | Causes is true | |
| PIC-R11 | condition | None | VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true | |
| PIC-R12 | condition | None | VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true | |
| PIC-R13 | act | Actor | Abuses is true | |
| PIC-R14 | condition | None | Admitted is true | |
| PIC-R15 | condition | None | SickPersons is true | |
| PIC-R16 | condition | None | VulnerablePersons is true | |
| PIC-R17 | act | Actor | Exploits is true | |
| PIC-R18 | condition | None | Illness is true | |
| PIC-R19 | condition | None | Vulnerability is true | |
| PIC-R20 | act | Actor | PerformsOnVictim is true | |
| PIC-R21 | act | Actor | HasVictimPerformOnActor is true | |
| PIC-R90 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| PIC-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not AbuseOfPersonInCustody |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} commits the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {Commits} | PIC-R01 | is true |
| {Person} is a prisoner | Merkmal | {IsPrisoner} | PIC-R02 | is true |
| {Person} is detained by order of the authorities | Merkmal | {IsDetainedByAuthorities} | PIC-R03 | is true |
| {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} | Merkmal | {HasBeenEntrusted} | PIC-R04 | is true |
| education | Merkmal | {Education} | PIC-R05 | is true |
| training | Merkmal | {Training} | PIC-R06 | is true |
| supervision | Merkmal | {Supervision} | PIC-R07 | is true |
| care | Merkmal | {Care} | PIC-R08 | is true |
| {Actor} allows the act to be performed on {Actor} by {Person} | Merkmal | {AllowsVictimToPerform} | PIC-R09 | is true |
| {Actor} causes {Person} | Merkmal | {Causes} | PIC-R10 | is true |
| {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | PIC-R11 | is true |
| {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | PIC-R12 | is true |
| {Actor} abuses {Person} | Merkmal | {Abuses} | PIC-R13 | is true |
| {Person} is admitted to the {Institution} | Merkmal | {Admitted} | PIC-R14 | is true |
| the {Institution} is for sick persons | Merkmal | {SickPersons} | PIC-R15 | is true |
| the {Institution} is for vulnerable persons | Merkmal | {VulnerablePersons} | PIC-R16 | is true |
| {Actor} exploits | Merkmal | {Exploits} | PIC-R17 | is true |
| {Person}'s illness | Merkmal | {Illness} | PIC-R18 | is true |
| {Person}'s vulnerability | Merkmal | {Vulnerability} | PIC-R19 | is true |
| {Actor} performs the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {PerformsOnVictim} | PIC-R20 | is true |
| {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | PIC-R21 | is true |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Abuses} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} abuses {Person} |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {Admitted} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is admitted to the {Institution} |
| {AllowsVictimToPerform} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} allows the act to be performed on {Actor} by {Person} |
| {Care} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | care |
| {Causes} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} causes {Person} |
| {Commits} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} commits the act on {Person} |
| {Education} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | education |
| {Exploits} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} exploits |
| {HasBeenEntrusted} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} |
| {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} |
| {Illness} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person}'s illness |
| {Institution} | Party | – | Session | an institution |
| {IsDetainedByAuthorities} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is detained by order of the authorities |
| {IsPrisoner} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is a prisoner |
| {PerformsOnVictim} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act on {Person} |
| {Person} | Party | – | Session | the protected person (the victim) |
| {SickPersons} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the {Institution} is for sick persons |
| {Supervision} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | supervision |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third person |
| {Training} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | training |
| {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} |
| {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} |
| {Vulnerability} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person}'s vulnerability |
| {VulnerablePersons} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the {Institution} is for vulnerable persons |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (({Person} is a prisoner or {Person} is detained by order of the authorities) and {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} and (education or training or supervision or care)) and ({Actor} commits the act on {Person} or {Actor} allows the act to be performed on {Actor} by {Person} or ({Actor} causes {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson})))) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and {Actor} abuses {Person} and ({Person} is admitted to the {Institution} and (the {Institution} is for sick persons or the {Institution} is for vulnerable persons) and {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor} and (supervision or care)) and ({Actor} exploits and ({Person}'s illness or {Person}'s vulnerability)) and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} or ({Actor} causes {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson})))).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [ThirdPersonConduct] | Causes, VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson, VictimToleratesByThirdPerson | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Conduct] | PerformsOnVictim, HasVictimPerformOnActor, ThirdPersonConduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [EntrustmentPurpose] | Education, Training, Supervision, Care | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [VictimStatus] | IsPrisoner, IsDetainedByAuthorities | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1Conduct] | Commits, AllowsVictimToPerform, ThirdPersonConduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [InstitutionDesignation] | SickPersons, VulnerablePersons | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Setting] | Admitted, InstitutionDesignation, HasBeenEntrusted, Supervision, Care | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Exploitation] | Exploits, Illness, Vulnerability | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2] | SexualActs, Abuses, Para2Setting, Exploitation, Para2Conduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1Relationship] | VictimStatus, HasBeenEntrusted, EntrustmentPurpose | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1] | SexualActs, Para1Relationship, Para1Conduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [AbuseOfPersonInCustody] | Para1, Para2 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (PIC-P0) | [AbuseOfPersonInCustody] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Abuses}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {Admitted}
├─ {AllowsVictimToPerform}
├─ {Care}
├─ {Causes}
├─ {Commits}
├─ {Education}
├─ {Exploits}
├─ {HasBeenEntrusted}
├─ {HasVictimPerformOnActor}
├─ {Illness}
├─ {Institution}
├─ {IsDetainedByAuthorities}
├─ {IsPrisoner}
├─ {PerformsOnVictim}
├─ {Person}
├─ {SickPersons}
├─ {Supervision}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
├─ {Training}
├─ {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson}
├─ {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson}
├─ {Vulnerability}
├─ {VulnerablePersons}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [ThirdPersonConduct] = Causes is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
├─ [Para2Conduct] = PerformsOnVictim is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
├─ [EntrustmentPurpose] = Education is true or Training is true or Supervision is true or Care is true
├─ [VictimStatus] = IsPrisoner is true or IsDetainedByAuthorities is true
├─ [Para1Conduct] = Commits is true or AllowsVictimToPerform is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
├─ [InstitutionDesignation] = SickPersons is true or VulnerablePersons is true
├─ [Para2Setting] = Admitted is true and InstitutionDesignation is true and HasBeenEntrusted is true and (Supervision is true or Care is true)
├─ [Exploitation] = Exploits is true and (Illness is true or Vulnerability is true)
├─ [Para2] = SexualActs is true and Abuses is true and Para2Setting is true and Exploitation is true and Para2Conduct is true
├─ [Para1Relationship] = VictimStatus is true and HasBeenEntrusted is true and EntrustmentPurpose is true
├─ [Para1] = SexualActs is true and Para1Relationship is true and Para1Conduct is true
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [AbuseOfPersonInCustody] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [AbuseOfPersonInCustody] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [AbuseOfPersonInCustody] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [AbuseOfPersonInCustody] depends on [ThirdPersonConduct], [Para2Conduct], [EntrustmentPurpose], [VictimStatus], [Para1Conduct], [InstitutionDesignation], [Para2Setting], [Exploitation], [Para2], [Para1Relationship], [Para1] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [AbuseOfPersonInCustody]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Abuses} | Element/Datum: {Actor} abuses {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q3 | Session | {Admitted} | Element/Datum: {Person} is admitted to the {Institution}.? | Boolean |
| Q4 | Session | {AllowsVictimToPerform} | Element/Datum: {Actor} allows the act to be performed on {Actor} by {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {Care} | Element/Datum: care.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {Causes} | Element/Datum: {Actor} causes {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {Commits} | Element/Datum: {Actor} commits the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {Education} | Element/Datum: education.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {Exploits} | Element/Datum: {Actor} exploits.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {HasBeenEntrusted} | Element/Datum: {Person} has been entrusted to {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | Element/Datum: {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {Illness} | Element/Datum: {Person}'s illness.? | Boolean |
| Q13 | Session | {Institution} | Element/Datum: an institution.? | Party |
| Q14 | Session | {IsDetainedByAuthorities} | Element/Datum: {Person} is detained by order of the authorities.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {IsPrisoner} | Element/Datum: {Person} is a prisoner.? | Boolean |
| Q16 | Session | {PerformsOnVictim} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q17 | Session | {Person} | Element/Datum: the protected person (the victim).? | Party |
| Q18 | Session | {SickPersons} | Element/Datum: the {Institution} is for sick persons.? | Boolean |
| Q19 | Session | {Supervision} | Element/Datum: supervision.? | Boolean |
| Q20 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third person.? | Party |
| Q21 | Session | {Training} | Element/Datum: training.? | Boolean |
| Q22 | Session | {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q23 | Session | {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q24 | Session | {Vulnerability} | Element/Datum: {Person}'s vulnerability.? | Boolean |
| Q25 | Session | {VulnerablePersons} | Element/Datum: the {Institution} is for vulnerable persons.? | Boolean |
Flags
Whole section Paragraph 1, the custody and official-detention variant with its third-person extension; paragraph 2, the institutional sick-or-vulnerable variant turning on abuse by exploitation of illness or vulnerability, with its third-person extension; attempt in (3) struck.
Ten-rule sweep Fused verb-object Booleans separated: {Exploits} now spans the coordinated objects {Illness} and {Vulnerability}; the institution's designation is the coordinated objects {SickPersons} and {VulnerablePersons} nested in the {Admitted} span; the entrustment purposes {Education}, {Training}, {Supervision}, {Care} are object variables nested in the {HasBeenEntrusted} span. Every disjunction is carried in a computable ([VictimStatus], [EntrustmentPurpose], [InstitutionDesignation], [Exploitation]); connectives are folded into the second and later blocks (rules 1, 2, 5, 7, 10).
Conduct logic note Paragraph 1's three modalities are true alternatives in [Para1Conduct]: {Commits} (performs on the victim), {AllowsVictimToPerform}, or the causes-third-person extension. The prior encoding required {Commits} alongside the other modalities, which misread the source.
Victim as variable {Person} carries the prisoner or detained person; the status alternatives {IsPrisoner} and {IsDetainedByAuthorities} are coordinated status predicates with the disjunction in [VictimStatus] (rules 3, 6, 10).
Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.
Strikes Penalties in (1) and (2) and the attempt in (3) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.
Treatment §174a is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements, consistent with the §174 precedent.
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) Any public official appointed to participate in criminal proceedings or in proceedings for the imposition of a custodial measure of reform and security or administrative detention who, by abusing the dependence created by the proceedings, performs sexual acts on the person against whom the proceedings are directed, or allows the other person to perform such acts on them, or causes that person to perform or tolerate sexual acts on or by a third person, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) An attempt is punishable.
«if AbuseOfOfficialPosition is true»(1) Any «if {IsPublicOfficial} is true»public official «end if» «if {AppointedToParticipate} is true»appointed to participate in «if {CriminalProceedings} is true»criminal proceedings «end if» «if {CustodialMeasureProceedings} is true»or in proceedings for the imposition of a custodial measure of reform and security «end if» «if {AdministrativeDetentionProceedings} is true»or administrative detention «end if» «end if» who, by «if {Abuses} is true»abusing the {Dependence} created by the proceedings «end if», «if {PerformsOnTarget} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if», or «if {AllowsTargetToPerform} is true»allows {Person} to perform [SexualActs] on {Actor} «end if», or «if {Causes} is true»causes «end if» {Person} to «if {TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {TargetToleratesByThirdPerson} is true»or tolerate [SexualActs] by a {ThirdPerson} «end if», shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) An attempt is punishable.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[ProceedingType] = CriminalProceedings is true or CustodialMeasureProceedings is true or AdministrativeDetentionProceedings is true
[ThirdPersonConduct] = Causes is true and (TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or TargetToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
[Conduct] = PerformsOnTarget is true or AllowsTargetToPerform is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
[OfficialRole] = IsPublicOfficial is true and AppointedToParticipate is true and ProceedingType is true
[AbuseOfOfficialPosition] = SexualActs is true and OfficialRole is true and Abuses is true and Conduct is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AOP-R01 | condition | None | IsPublicOfficial is true | |
| AOP-R02 | act | Actor | AppointedToParticipate is true | |
| AOP-R03 | condition | None | CriminalProceedings is true | |
| AOP-R04 | condition | None | CustodialMeasureProceedings is true | |
| AOP-R05 | condition | None | AdministrativeDetentionProceedings is true | |
| AOP-R06 | act | Actor | Abuses is true | |
| AOP-R07 | act | Actor | PerformsOnTarget is true | |
| AOP-R08 | act | Actor | AllowsTargetToPerform is true | |
| AOP-R09 | act | Actor | Causes is true | |
| AOP-R10 | condition | None | TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson is true | |
| AOP-R11 | condition | None | TargetToleratesByThirdPerson is true | |
| AOP-R90 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| AOP-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not AbuseOfOfficialPosition |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any public official who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} is a public official | Merkmal | {IsPublicOfficial} | AOP-R01 | is true |
| {Actor} is appointed to participate | Merkmal | {AppointedToParticipate} | AOP-R02 | is true |
| criminal proceedings | Merkmal | {CriminalProceedings} | AOP-R03 | is true |
| proceedings for the imposition of a custodial measure | Merkmal | {CustodialMeasureProceedings} | AOP-R04 | is true |
| proceedings for administrative detention | Merkmal | {AdministrativeDetentionProceedings} | AOP-R05 | is true |
| {Actor} abuses the {Dependence} | Merkmal | {Abuses} | AOP-R06 | is true |
| {Actor} performs the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {PerformsOnTarget} | AOP-R07 | is true |
| {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {AllowsTargetToPerform} | AOP-R08 | is true |
| {Actor} causes {Person} | Merkmal | {Causes} | AOP-R09 | is true |
| {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson} | AOP-R10 | is true |
| {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {TargetToleratesByThirdPerson} | AOP-R11 | is true |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Abuses} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} abuses the {Dependence} |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AdministrativeDetentionProceedings} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | proceedings for administrative detention |
| {AllowsTargetToPerform} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor} |
| {AppointedToParticipate} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} is appointed to participate |
| {Causes} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} causes {Person} |
| {CriminalProceedings} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | criminal proceedings |
| {CustodialMeasureProceedings} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | proceedings for the imposition of a custodial measure |
| {Dependence} | Party | – | Session | the dependence created by the proceedings |
| {IsPublicOfficial} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} is a public official |
| {PerformsOnTarget} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act on {Person} |
| {Person} | Party | – | Session | the person against whom the proceedings are directed |
| {TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} |
| {TargetToleratesByThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third person |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and ({Actor} is a public official and {Actor} is appointed to participate and (criminal proceedings or proceedings for the imposition of a custodial measure or proceedings for administrative detention)) and {Actor} abuses the {Dependence} and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor} or ({Actor} causes {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson}))).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [ProceedingType] | CriminalProceedings, CustodialMeasureProceedings, AdministrativeDetentionProceedings | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ThirdPersonConduct] | Causes, TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson, TargetToleratesByThirdPerson | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Conduct] | PerformsOnTarget, AllowsTargetToPerform, ThirdPersonConduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [OfficialRole] | IsPublicOfficial, AppointedToParticipate, ProceedingType | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [AbuseOfOfficialPosition] | SexualActs, OfficialRole, Abuses, Conduct | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (AOP-P0) | [AbuseOfOfficialPosition] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Abuses}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AdministrativeDetentionProceedings}
├─ {AllowsTargetToPerform}
├─ {AppointedToParticipate}
├─ {Causes}
├─ {CriminalProceedings}
├─ {CustodialMeasureProceedings}
├─ {Dependence}
├─ {IsPublicOfficial}
├─ {PerformsOnTarget}
├─ {Person}
├─ {TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson}
├─ {TargetToleratesByThirdPerson}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [ProceedingType] = CriminalProceedings is true or CustodialMeasureProceedings is true or AdministrativeDetentionProceedings is true
├─ [ThirdPersonConduct] = Causes is true and (TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or TargetToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
├─ [Conduct] = PerformsOnTarget is true or AllowsTargetToPerform is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
├─ [OfficialRole] = IsPublicOfficial is true and AppointedToParticipate is true and ProceedingType is true
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [AbuseOfOfficialPosition] = SexualActs is true and OfficialRole is true and Abuses is true and Conduct is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [AbuseOfOfficialPosition] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [AbuseOfOfficialPosition] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [AbuseOfOfficialPosition] depends on [ProceedingType], [ThirdPersonConduct], [Conduct], [OfficialRole] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [AbuseOfOfficialPosition]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Abuses} | Element/Datum: {Actor} abuses the {Dependence}.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q3 | Session | {AdministrativeDetentionProceedings} | Element/Datum: proceedings for administrative detention.? | Boolean |
| Q4 | Session | {AllowsTargetToPerform} | Element/Datum: {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {AppointedToParticipate} | Element/Datum: {Actor} is appointed to participate.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {Causes} | Element/Datum: {Actor} causes {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {CriminalProceedings} | Element/Datum: criminal proceedings.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {CustodialMeasureProceedings} | Element/Datum: proceedings for the imposition of a custodial measure.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {Dependence} | Element/Datum: the dependence created by the proceedings.? | Party |
| Q10 | Session | {IsPublicOfficial} | Element/Datum: {Actor} is a public official.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {PerformsOnTarget} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {Person} | Element/Datum: the person against whom the proceedings are directed.? | Party |
| Q13 | Session | {TargetPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q14 | Session | {TargetToleratesByThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third person.? | Party |
Flags
Whole section Paragraph 1, the public-official proceedings variant with its third-person extension; attempt in (2) struck.
Ten-rule sweep Fused verb-object Booleans separated: the appointment verb {AppointedToParticipate} now spans the coordinated proceeding-type objects {CriminalProceedings}, {CustodialMeasureProceedings} and {AdministrativeDetentionProceedings}, with the disjunction in [ProceedingType]; the abuse verb {Abuses} acts on the single uncoordinated object {Dependence}, which stays a reference variable (rules 1, 2, 7, 10).
Target as variable {Person} carries the person against whom the proceedings are directed (rule 3).
Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.
Strikes The penalty in (1) and the attempt in (2) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.
Treatment §174b is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements, consistent with the §174 precedent.
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) Any person who performs sexual acts on a person who is entrusted to them, on account of a mental or psychological illness or disability including addiction, or a physical illness or disability, for counselling, treatment or care, by abusing the counselling, treatment or care relationship, or has such acts performed on themselves by that person, or directs that person to perform or tolerate sexual acts on or by a third person, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) A person who, by abusing the therapeutic relationship, performs sexual acts on a person entrusted to them for psychotherapeutic treatment, or causes such acts to be performed on them, or directs that person to perform or tolerate sexual acts on or by a third person, shall be punished in the same way. (3) An attempt is punishable.
«if AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship is true»(1) {Actor} «if {PerformsOnVictim} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» who «if {Entrusted} is true»is entrusted to {Actor}, on account of «if {MentalIllness} is true»a mental illness «end if» «if {PsychologicalIllness} is true»or psychological illness «end if» «if {MentalDisability} is true»or a mental disability «end if» «if {PsychologicalDisability} is true»or psychological disability «end if» «if {Addiction} is true»including an addiction «end if» «if {PhysicalIllness} is true»or a physical illness «end if» «if {PhysicalDisability} is true»or physical disability «end if», for «if {Counselling} is true»counselling «end if» «if {Treatment} is true», treatment «end if» «if {Care} is true»or care «end if» «end if», by «if {Abuses} is true»abusing the «if {Counselling} is true»counselling «end if» «if {Treatment} is true», treatment «end if» «if {Care} is true»or care «end if» {Relationship} «end if», or «if {HasVictimPerformOnActor} is true»has [SexualActs] performed on themselves by {Person} «end if», or «if {Directs} is true»directs «end if» {Person} to «if {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} is true»or tolerate [SexualActs] by a {ThirdPerson} «end if», shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) {Actor}, by «if {Abuses} is true»abusing the «if {TherapeuticRelationship} is true»therapeutic relationship «end if» «end if», «if {PerformsOnVictim} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {Entrusted} is true»entrusted to {Actor} «if {Psychotherapy} is true»for psychotherapeutic treatment «end if» «end if», or «if {HasVictimPerformOnActor} is true»causes such acts to be performed on them «end if», or «if {Directs} is true»directs «end if» {Person} to «if {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} is true»or tolerate [SexualActs] by a {ThirdPerson} «end if», shall be punished in the same way. (3) An attempt is punishable.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[ThirdPersonConduct] = Directs is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
[EntrustmentPurpose] = Counselling is true or Treatment is true or Care is true
[EntrustmentGround] = MentalIllness is true or PsychologicalIllness is true or MentalDisability is true or PsychologicalDisability is true or Addiction is true or PhysicalIllness is true or PhysicalDisability is true
[Para1Relationship] = Entrusted is true and EntrustmentGround is true and EntrustmentPurpose is true
[RelationshipAbuse] = Abuses is true and EntrustmentPurpose is true
[Conduct] = PerformsOnVictim is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
[Para1] = SexualActs is true and Para1Relationship is true and RelationshipAbuse is true and Conduct is true
[Para2Relationship] = Entrusted is true and Psychotherapy is true
[TherapeuticAbuse] = Abuses is true and TherapeuticRelationship is true
[Para2] = SexualActs is true and Para2Relationship is true and TherapeuticAbuse is true and Conduct is true
[AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ATR-R01 | condition | None | Entrusted is true | |
| ATR-R02 | condition | None | MentalIllness is true | |
| ATR-R03 | condition | None | PsychologicalIllness is true | |
| ATR-R04 | condition | None | MentalDisability is true | |
| ATR-R05 | condition | None | PsychologicalDisability is true | |
| ATR-R06 | condition | None | Addiction is true | |
| ATR-R07 | condition | None | PhysicalIllness is true | |
| ATR-R08 | condition | None | PhysicalDisability is true | |
| ATR-R09 | condition | None | Counselling is true | |
| ATR-R10 | condition | None | Treatment is true | |
| ATR-R11 | condition | None | Care is true | |
| ATR-R12 | act | Actor | Abuses is true | |
| ATR-R13 | condition | None | TherapeuticRelationship is true | |
| ATR-R14 | condition | None | Psychotherapy is true | |
| ATR-R15 | act | Actor | PerformsOnVictim is true | |
| ATR-R16 | act | Actor | HasVictimPerformOnActor is true | |
| ATR-R17 | act | Actor | Directs is true | |
| ATR-R18 | condition | None | VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true | |
| ATR-R19 | condition | None | VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true | |
| ATR-R90 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| ATR-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Person} is entrusted to {Actor} | Merkmal | {Entrusted} | ATR-R01 | is true |
| a mental illness | Merkmal | {MentalIllness} | ATR-R02 | is true |
| a psychological illness | Merkmal | {PsychologicalIllness} | ATR-R03 | is true |
| a mental disability | Merkmal | {MentalDisability} | ATR-R04 | is true |
| a psychological disability | Merkmal | {PsychologicalDisability} | ATR-R05 | is true |
| an addiction | Merkmal | {Addiction} | ATR-R06 | is true |
| a physical illness | Merkmal | {PhysicalIllness} | ATR-R07 | is true |
| a physical disability | Merkmal | {PhysicalDisability} | ATR-R08 | is true |
| counselling | Merkmal | {Counselling} | ATR-R09 | is true |
| treatment | Merkmal | {Treatment} | ATR-R10 | is true |
| care | Merkmal | {Care} | ATR-R11 | is true |
| {Actor} abuses the {Relationship} | Merkmal | {Abuses} | ATR-R12 | is true |
| the relationship is a therapeutic relationship | Merkmal | {TherapeuticRelationship} | ATR-R13 | is true |
| psychotherapeutic treatment is the purpose of the entrustment | Merkmal | {Psychotherapy} | ATR-R14 | is true |
| {Actor} performs the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {PerformsOnVictim} | ATR-R15 | is true |
| {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | ATR-R16 | is true |
| {Actor} directs {Person} | Merkmal | {Directs} | ATR-R17 | is true |
| {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | ATR-R18 | is true |
| {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | ATR-R19 | is true |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Abuses} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} abuses the {Relationship} |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {Addiction} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an addiction |
| {Care} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | care |
| {Counselling} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | counselling |
| {Directs} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} directs {Person} |
| {Entrusted} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is entrusted to {Actor} |
| {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} |
| {MentalDisability} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a mental disability |
| {MentalIllness} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a mental illness |
| {PerformsOnVictim} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act on {Person} |
| {Person} | Party | – | Session | the entrusted person |
| {PhysicalDisability} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a physical disability |
| {PhysicalIllness} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a physical illness |
| {PsychologicalDisability} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a psychological disability |
| {PsychologicalIllness} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a psychological illness |
| {Psychotherapy} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | psychotherapeutic treatment is the purpose of the entrustment |
| {Relationship} | Party | – | Session | the relationship of entrustment |
| {TherapeuticRelationship} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the relationship is a therapeutic relationship |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third person |
| {Treatment} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | treatment |
| {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} |
| {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and ({Person} is entrusted to {Actor} and (a mental illness or a psychological illness or a mental disability or a psychological disability or an addiction or a physical illness or a physical disability) and (counselling or treatment or care)) and ({Actor} abuses the {Relationship} and (counselling or treatment or care)) and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} or ({Actor} directs {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson})))) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and ({Person} is entrusted to {Actor} and psychotherapeutic treatment is the purpose of the entrustment) and ({Actor} abuses the {Relationship} and the relationship is a therapeutic relationship) and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} or ({Actor} directs {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson})))).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [ThirdPersonConduct] | Directs, VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson, VictimToleratesByThirdPerson | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [EntrustmentPurpose] | Counselling, Treatment, Care | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [EntrustmentGround] | MentalIllness, PsychologicalIllness, MentalDisability, PsychologicalDisability, Addiction, PhysicalIllness, PhysicalDisability | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1Relationship] | Entrusted, EntrustmentGround, EntrustmentPurpose | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [RelationshipAbuse] | Abuses, EntrustmentPurpose | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Conduct] | PerformsOnVictim, HasVictimPerformOnActor, ThirdPersonConduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1] | SexualActs, Para1Relationship, RelationshipAbuse, Conduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Relationship] | Entrusted, Psychotherapy | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [TherapeuticAbuse] | Abuses, TherapeuticRelationship | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2] | SexualActs, Para2Relationship, TherapeuticAbuse, Conduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship] | Para1, Para2 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (ATR-P0) | [AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Abuses}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {Addiction}
├─ {Care}
├─ {Counselling}
├─ {Directs}
├─ {Entrusted}
├─ {HasVictimPerformOnActor}
├─ {MentalDisability}
├─ {MentalIllness}
├─ {PerformsOnVictim}
├─ {Person}
├─ {PhysicalDisability}
├─ {PhysicalIllness}
├─ {PsychologicalDisability}
├─ {PsychologicalIllness}
├─ {Psychotherapy}
├─ {Relationship}
├─ {TherapeuticRelationship}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
├─ {Treatment}
├─ {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson}
├─ {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [ThirdPersonConduct] = Directs is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
├─ [EntrustmentPurpose] = Counselling is true or Treatment is true or Care is true
├─ [EntrustmentGround] = MentalIllness is true or PsychologicalIllness is true or MentalDisability is true or PsychologicalDisability is true or Addiction is true or PhysicalIllness is true or PhysicalDisability is true
├─ [Para1Relationship] = Entrusted is true and EntrustmentGround is true and EntrustmentPurpose is true
├─ [RelationshipAbuse] = Abuses is true and EntrustmentPurpose is true
├─ [Conduct] = PerformsOnVictim is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true or ThirdPersonConduct is true
├─ [Para1] = SexualActs is true and Para1Relationship is true and RelationshipAbuse is true and Conduct is true
├─ [Para2Relationship] = Entrusted is true and Psychotherapy is true
├─ [TherapeuticAbuse] = Abuses is true and TherapeuticRelationship is true
├─ [Para2] = SexualActs is true and Para2Relationship is true and TherapeuticAbuse is true and Conduct is true
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship] depends on [ThirdPersonConduct], [EntrustmentPurpose], [EntrustmentGround], [Para1Relationship], [RelationshipAbuse], [Conduct], [Para1], [Para2Relationship], [TherapeuticAbuse], [Para2] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [AbuseOfTreatmentRelationship]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Abuses} | Element/Datum: {Actor} abuses the {Relationship}.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q3 | Session | {Addiction} | Element/Datum: an addiction.? | Boolean |
| Q4 | Session | {Care} | Element/Datum: care.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {Counselling} | Element/Datum: counselling.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {Directs} | Element/Datum: {Actor} directs {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {Entrusted} | Element/Datum: {Person} is entrusted to {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | Element/Datum: {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {MentalDisability} | Element/Datum: a mental disability.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {MentalIllness} | Element/Datum: a mental illness.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {PerformsOnVictim} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {Person} | Element/Datum: the entrusted person.? | Party |
| Q13 | Session | {PhysicalDisability} | Element/Datum: a physical disability.? | Boolean |
| Q14 | Session | {PhysicalIllness} | Element/Datum: a physical illness.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {PsychologicalDisability} | Element/Datum: a psychological disability.? | Boolean |
| Q16 | Session | {PsychologicalIllness} | Element/Datum: a psychological illness.? | Boolean |
| Q17 | Session | {Psychotherapy} | Element/Datum: psychotherapeutic treatment is the purpose of the entrustment.? | Boolean |
| Q18 | Session | {Relationship} | Element/Datum: the relationship of entrustment.? | Party |
| Q19 | Session | {TherapeuticRelationship} | Element/Datum: the relationship is a therapeutic relationship.? | Boolean |
| Q20 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third person.? | Party |
| Q21 | Session | {Treatment} | Element/Datum: treatment.? | Boolean |
| Q22 | Session | {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q23 | Session | {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
Flags
Whole section Paragraph 1, the counselling, treatment or care relationship with its grounds of entrustment and third-person extension; paragraph 2, the psychotherapeutic variant; attempt in (3) struck.
Translation notes The English of (1) follows the German in the source column: the dropped governing verb restored ({Actor} performs sexual acts on the entrusted person) and the ground of entrustment restored (on account of a mental or psychological illness or disability including addiction, or a physical illness or disability).
Ten-rule sweep Fused verb-object Booleans separated: {Entrusted} is the status rule (rule 6) spanning the seven coordinated ground objects ({MentalIllness}, {PsychologicalIllness}, {MentalDisability}, {PsychologicalDisability}, {Addiction}, {PhysicalIllness}, {PhysicalDisability}, disjunction in [EntrustmentGround]) and the three purpose objects ({Counselling}, {Treatment}, {Care}, disjunction in [EntrustmentPurpose]); {Abuses} spans the same purpose objects qualifying the {Relationship} in paragraph 1, and the {TherapeuticRelationship} object in paragraph 2 (rules 1, 2, 5, 7, 10).
Purpose variables reused {Counselling}, {Treatment} and {Care} carry the same Merkmal in the entrustment purpose and in the abused relationship; one variable each, consumed by both computables.
Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.
Strikes Penalties in (1) and (2) (including “Ebenso wird bestraft” per the marked-up source) and the attempt in (3) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.
Treatment §174c is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements, consistent with the §174 precedent.
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) A person shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of not less than one year if 1. performs sexual acts on a person under the age of fourteen (a child) or allows the child to perform such acts on them, 2. causes a child to perform sexual acts on a third person or to allow a third person to perform sexual acts on them, 3. offers a child for an act under point 1 or point 2 or promises to provide such a child. (2) In the cases referred to in paragraph 1, point 1, the court may refrain from imposing a penalty under this provision if the sexual act between the offender and the child is consensual and the difference in both age and stage of development or maturity is minor, unless the offender exploits the child’s lack of capacity for sexual self-determination.
«if SexualAbuseOfChildren is true»(1) {Actor} shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of not less than one year if 1. «if {Performs} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «if [Child] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit14} (a child) «end if» «end if» «if {AllowsChildToPerform} is true»or allows the child to perform such acts on {Actor} «end if», 2. «if {Causes} is true»causes «end if» «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» to «if {ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} is true»or to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if», 3. «if {Offers} is true»offers «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» for «if {ActUnderPoint1} is true»an act under point 1 «end if» «if {ActUnderPoint2} is true»or point 2 «end if» «end if» «if {Promises} is true»or promises to provide such a child «end if». (2) In the cases referred to in paragraph 1, point 1, the court may refrain from imposing a penalty under this provision if the sexual act between the offender and the child is consensual and the difference in both age and stage of development or maturity is minor, unless the offender exploits the child’s lack of capacity for sexual self-determination.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[OfferedAct] = ActUnderPoint1 is true or ActUnderPoint2 is true
[Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14
[Leg3] = Child is true and ((Offers is true and OfferedAct is true) or Promises is true)
[Leg1] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and (Performs is true or AllowsChildToPerform is true)
[Leg2] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and Causes is true and (ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true)
[SexualAbuseOfChildren] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or Leg3 is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAC-R01 | act | Actor | Performs is true | |
| SAC-R02 | act | Actor | AllowsChildToPerform is true | |
| SAC-R03 | act | Actor | Causes is true | |
| SAC-R04 | condition | None | ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson is true | |
| SAC-R05 | condition | None | ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true | |
| SAC-R06 | act | Actor | Offers is true | |
| SAC-R07 | condition | None | ActUnderPoint1 is true | |
| SAC-R08 | condition | None | ActUnderPoint2 is true | |
| SAC-R09 | act | Actor | Promises is true | |
| SAC-R90 | condition | None | the person is under the age of fourteen (a child) | Child is true |
| SAC-R91 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| SAC-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not SexualAbuseOfChildren |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A person ... if | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} performs the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {Performs} | SAC-R01 | is true |
| {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {AllowsChildToPerform} | SAC-R02 | is true |
| {Actor} causes {Person} | Merkmal | {Causes} | SAC-R03 | is true |
| {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson} | SAC-R04 | is true |
| {Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} | SAC-R05 | is true |
| {Actor} offers {Person} for the referenced act | Merkmal | {Offers} | SAC-R06 | is true |
| an act under point 1 | Merkmal | {ActUnderPoint1} | SAC-R07 | is true |
| an act under point 2 | Merkmal | {ActUnderPoint2} | SAC-R08 | is true |
| {Actor} promises to provide such a child | Merkmal | {Promises} | SAC-R09 | is true |
| (2) judicial discretion for consensual peer acts | subjective / judicial | — excluded — | — | struck |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {ActUnderPoint1} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an act under point 1 |
| {ActUnderPoint2} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an act under point 2 |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AgeLimit14} | Number | – | Session | fourteen years |
| {AllowsChildToPerform} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor} |
| {Causes} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} causes {Person} |
| {ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person} |
| {ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} |
| {Offers} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} offers {Person} for the referenced act |
| {Performs} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act on {Person} |
| {Person} | Party | – | Session | the protected person |
| {PersonAge} | Number | – | Session | the age of {Person} in years |
| {Promises} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} promises to provide such a child |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third person |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor})) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and {Actor} causes {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person})) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (({Actor} offers {Person} for the referenced act and (an act under point 1 or an act under point 2)) or {Actor} promises to provide such a child)).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [OfferedAct] | ActUnderPoint1, ActUnderPoint2 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Child] | PersonAge, AgeLimit14 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg3] | Child, Offers, OfferedAct, Promises | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg1] | SexualActs, Child, Performs, AllowsChildToPerform | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg2] | SexualActs, Child, Causes, ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson, ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [SexualAbuseOfChildren] | Leg1, Leg2, Leg3 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (SAC-P0) | [SexualAbuseOfChildren] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {ActUnderPoint1}
├─ {ActUnderPoint2}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AgeLimit14}
├─ {AllowsChildToPerform}
├─ {Causes}
├─ {ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform}
├─ {ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson}
├─ {Offers}
├─ {Performs}
├─ {Person}
├─ {PersonAge}
├─ {Promises}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [OfferedAct] = ActUnderPoint1 is true or ActUnderPoint2 is true
├─ [Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14
├─ [Leg3] = Child is true and ((Offers is true and OfferedAct is true) or Promises is true)
├─ [Leg1] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and (Performs is true or AllowsChildToPerform is true)
├─ [Leg2] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and Causes is true and (ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true)
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [SexualAbuseOfChildren] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or Leg3 is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [SexualAbuseOfChildren] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [SexualAbuseOfChildren] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [SexualAbuseOfChildren] depends on [OfferedAct], [Child], [Leg3], [Leg1], [Leg2] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [SexualAbuseOfChildren]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {ActUnderPoint1} | Element/Datum: an act under point 1.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {ActUnderPoint2} | Element/Datum: an act under point 2.? | Boolean |
| Q3 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q4 | Session | {AgeLimit14} | Element/Datum: fourteen years.? | Number |
| Q5 | Session | {AllowsChildToPerform} | Element/Datum: {Actor} allows {Person} to perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {Causes} | Element/Datum: {Actor} causes {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {ChildAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} | Element/Datum: {Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {ChildPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {Offers} | Element/Datum: {Actor} offers {Person} for the referenced act.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {Performs} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {Person} | Element/Datum: the protected person.? | Party |
| Q12 | Session | {PersonAge} | Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.? | Number |
| Q13 | Session | {Promises} | Element/Datum: {Actor} promises to provide such a child.? | Boolean |
| Q14 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third person.? | Party |
Flags
Scope Paragraph 1, the three legs: performing on the child or allowing the child to perform; causing third-person conduct; offering or promising to provide a child. Paragraph 2 struck entirely per the marked-up source.
Child definition authored here §176(1)(1) defines the child: a person under the age of fourteen. Encoded as the threshold rule [Child] = {PersonAge} < {AgeLimit14}, the limit a named-number variable, the comparison in the computable (encoding principles). §176a, §176b and §176e consume the same construction; pending cross-schema by-name machinery, each section restates [Child] locally and this annex records §176 as the authoring provision.
Statutory cross-references as objects “an act under point 1 or point 2” in leg 3 is encoded as the coordinated reference objects {ActUnderPoint1} and {ActUnderPoint2} inside the {Offers} span, the disjunction in [OfferedAct] (rule 10); the runtime resolves the referenced act types through [Leg1] and [Leg2].
Paragraph 2 struck The judicial discretion for consensual acts between peers close in age and maturity is struck whole per the markup: it turns on consensuality, developmental proximity and exploitation of capacity, all judgement-laden, and on a discretion (“may refrain”), not a rule.
Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.
Strikes The penalty in (1) and the whole of (2) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.
Treatment §176 is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements per the §174 precedent; the struck (2) carries the judgement-laden content.
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) A person shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of between six months and ten years if 1. performs sexual acts in the presence of a child or allows a third person to perform such acts on them in the presence of a child, 2. causes a child to perform sexual acts, provided that the act is not punishable under Section 176(1)(1) or (2), or 3. exerts influence on a child through pornographic material (Section 11(3)) or through corresponding speech. (2) A person who offers a child for an act under paragraph 1 or promises to provide one, or who conspires with another to commit such an act, shall also be punished. (3) An attempt is punishable in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, points 1 and 2. In the case of acts under paragraph 1, point 3, an attempt is punishable in cases where the completion of the act fails solely because the perpetrator mistakenly assumes that their influence relates to a child.
«if SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact is true»(1) {Actor} shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of between six months and ten years if 1. «if {Performs} is true»performs [SexualActs] «if {InPresenceOfChild} is true»in the presence of «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» «end if» «end if» «if {AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor} is true»or allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform such acts on {Actor} «if {InPresenceOfChild} is true»in the presence of «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» «end if» «end if», 2. «if {Causes} is true»causes «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» to perform [SexualActs] «end if», «if [Subsidiarity] is true»provided that the act is not punishable under «if {PunishableUnder176No1} is true»Section 176(1) point 1 «end if» «if {PunishableUnder176No2} is true»or point 2 «end if» «end if», or 3. «if {ExertsInfluence} is true»exerts influence on «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» through «if {PornographicContent} is true»pornographic material (Section 11(3)) «end if» «if {CorrespondingSpeech} is true»or through corresponding speech «end if» «end if». (2) {Actor} who «if {Offers} is true»offers «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» for «if {ActUnderPara1} is true»an act under paragraph 1 «end if» «end if» «if {Promises} is true»or promises to provide one «end if», or «if {Conspires} is true»conspires with another to commit such an act «end if», shall also be punished. (3) An attempt is punishable in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, points 1 and 2. In the case of acts under paragraph 1, point 3, an attempt is punishable in cases where the completion of the act fails solely because the perpetrator mistakenly assumes that their influence relates to a child.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14
[Subsidiarity] = not (PunishableUnder176No1 is true or PunishableUnder176No2 is true)
[Leg2] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and Causes is true and Subsidiarity is true
[InfluenceMeans] = PornographicContent is true or CorrespondingSpeech is true
[Leg1] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and InPresenceOfChild is true and (Performs is true or AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor is true)
[Leg3] = Child is true and ExertsInfluence is true and InfluenceMeans is true
[Para1] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or Leg3 is true
[Para2] = Child is true and ((Offers is true and ActUnderPara1 is true) or Promises is true or Conspires is true)
[SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SCW-R01 | act | Actor | Performs is true | |
| SCW-R02 | condition | None | InPresenceOfChild is true | |
| SCW-R03 | act | Actor | AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor is true | |
| SCW-R04 | act | Actor | Causes is true | |
| SCW-R05 | condition | None | PunishableUnder176No1 is true | |
| SCW-R06 | condition | None | PunishableUnder176No2 is true | |
| SCW-R07 | act | Actor | ExertsInfluence is true | |
| SCW-R08 | condition | None | PornographicContent is true | |
| SCW-R09 | condition | None | CorrespondingSpeech is true | |
| SCW-R10 | act | Actor | Offers is true | |
| SCW-R11 | condition | None | ActUnderPara1 is true | |
| SCW-R12 | act | Actor | Promises is true | |
| SCW-R13 | act | Actor | Conspires is true | |
| SCW-R90 | condition | None | the person is under the age of fourteen (a child) | Child is true |
| SCW-R91 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| SCW-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A person ... if | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} performs the act | Merkmal | {Performs} | SCW-R01 | is true |
| the act takes place in the presence of the child | Merkmal | {InPresenceOfChild} | SCW-R02 | is true |
| {Actor} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor} | SCW-R03 | is true |
| {Actor} causes the child to perform the act | Merkmal | {Causes} | SCW-R04 | is true |
| the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 1 | Merkmal | {PunishableUnder176No1} | SCW-R05 | is true |
| the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 2 | Merkmal | {PunishableUnder176No2} | SCW-R06 | is true |
| {Actor} exerts influence on the child | Merkmal | {ExertsInfluence} | SCW-R07 | is true |
| pornographic material within the meaning of Section 11(3) | Merkmal | {PornographicContent} | SCW-R08 | is true |
| corresponding speech | Merkmal | {CorrespondingSpeech} | SCW-R09 | is true |
| {Actor} offers the child for the referenced act | Merkmal | {Offers} | SCW-R10 | is true |
| an act under paragraph 1 | Merkmal | {ActUnderPara1} | SCW-R11 | is true |
| {Actor} promises to provide such a child | Merkmal | {Promises} | SCW-R12 | is true |
| {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act | Merkmal | {Conspires} | SCW-R13 | is true |
| (3) attempt and mistaken-child attempt | attempt | — excluded — | — | struck |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {ActUnderPara1} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an act under paragraph 1 |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AgeLimit14} | Number | – | Session | fourteen years |
| {AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Actor} |
| {Causes} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} causes the child to perform the act |
| {Conspires} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act |
| {CorrespondingSpeech} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | corresponding speech |
| {ExertsInfluence} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} exerts influence on the child |
| {InPresenceOfChild} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the act takes place in the presence of the child |
| {Offers} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} offers the child for the referenced act |
| {Performs} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act |
| {PersonAge} | Number | – | Session | the age of {Person} in years |
| {PornographicContent} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | pornographic material within the meaning of Section 11(3) |
| {Promises} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} promises to provide such a child |
| {PunishableUnder176No1} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 1 |
| {PunishableUnder176No2} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 2 |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third person |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and the act takes place in the presence of the child and ({Actor} performs the act or {Actor} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Actor})) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and {Actor} causes the child to perform the act and (not (the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 1 or the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 2))) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and {Actor} exerts influence on the child and (pornographic material within the meaning of Section 11(3) or corresponding speech))) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (({Actor} offers the child for the referenced act and an act under paragraph 1) or {Actor} promises to provide such a child or {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act)).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [Child] | PersonAge, AgeLimit14 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Subsidiarity] | PunishableUnder176No1, PunishableUnder176No2 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg2] | SexualActs, Child, Causes, Subsidiarity | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [InfluenceMeans] | PornographicContent, CorrespondingSpeech | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg1] | SexualActs, Child, InPresenceOfChild, Performs, AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg3] | Child, ExertsInfluence, InfluenceMeans | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1] | Leg1, Leg2, Leg3 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2] | Child, Offers, ActUnderPara1, Promises, Conspires | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact] | Para1, Para2 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (SCW-P0) | [SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {ActUnderPara1}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AgeLimit14}
├─ {AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor}
├─ {Causes}
├─ {Conspires}
├─ {CorrespondingSpeech}
├─ {ExertsInfluence}
├─ {InPresenceOfChild}
├─ {Offers}
├─ {Performs}
├─ {PersonAge}
├─ {PornographicContent}
├─ {Promises}
├─ {PunishableUnder176No1}
├─ {PunishableUnder176No2}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14
├─ [Subsidiarity] = not (PunishableUnder176No1 is true or PunishableUnder176No2 is true)
├─ [Leg2] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and Causes is true and Subsidiarity is true
├─ [InfluenceMeans] = PornographicContent is true or CorrespondingSpeech is true
├─ [Leg1] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and InPresenceOfChild is true and (Performs is true or AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor is true)
├─ [Leg3] = Child is true and ExertsInfluence is true and InfluenceMeans is true
├─ [Para1] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or Leg3 is true
├─ [Para2] = Child is true and ((Offers is true and ActUnderPara1 is true) or Promises is true or Conspires is true)
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact] depends on [Child], [Subsidiarity], [Leg2], [InfluenceMeans], [Leg1], [Leg3], [Para1], [Para2] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [SexualAbuseOfChildrenWithoutContact]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {ActUnderPara1} | Element/Datum: an act under paragraph 1.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q3 | Session | {AgeLimit14} | Element/Datum: fourteen years.? | Number |
| Q4 | Session | {AllowsThirdPersonToPerformOnActor} | Element/Datum: {Actor} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {Causes} | Element/Datum: {Actor} causes the child to perform the act.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {Conspires} | Element/Datum: {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {CorrespondingSpeech} | Element/Datum: corresponding speech.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {ExertsInfluence} | Element/Datum: {Actor} exerts influence on the child.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {InPresenceOfChild} | Element/Datum: the act takes place in the presence of the child.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {Offers} | Element/Datum: {Actor} offers the child for the referenced act.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {Performs} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {PersonAge} | Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.? | Number |
| Q13 | Session | {PornographicContent} | Element/Datum: pornographic material within the meaning of Section 11(3).? | Boolean |
| Q14 | Session | {Promises} | Element/Datum: {Actor} promises to provide such a child.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {PunishableUnder176No1} | Element/Datum: the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 1.? | Boolean |
| Q16 | Session | {PunishableUnder176No2} | Element/Datum: the act is punishable under Section 176(1) point 2.? | Boolean |
| Q17 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third person.? | Party |
Flags
Scope Paragraph 1, the three without-contact legs (acts in the child's presence; causing the child to perform, subsidiary to §176; influence through pornographic material or speech); paragraph 2, offering, promising or conspiring. Paragraph 3 (attempt, including the mistaken-child attempt rule) struck entirely per the marked-up source.
Presence as a nested relational rule “in the presence of a child” is the rule {InPresenceOfChild}, nested inside each of the two leg-1 conduct modalities it qualifies, with the age condition [Child] nested inside it (rules 4, 5, 7).
Subsidiarity as a negative computable “provided that the act is not punishable under Section 176(1)(1) or (2)” is [Subsidiarity] = not ({PunishableUnder176No1} or {PunishableUnder176No2}); the two referenced points are coordinated reference objects because “point 1 or point 2” cannot live in one atomic surface (rules 8, 10, 12).
Influence means as coordinated objects {ExertsInfluence} spans the means objects {PornographicContent} and {CorrespondingSpeech}; the disjunction is [InfluenceMeans] (rules 1, 2, 10).
Child definition [Child] = {PersonAge} < {AgeLimit14}, restated locally; §176 is the authoring provision (see the §176 annex).
Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.
Strikes The penalty in (1), “shall also be punished” in (2) (“Ebenso wird bestraft” in the marked-up German) and the whole of (3) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.
Treatment §176a is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements per the §174 precedent; the mistaken-child attempt rule in (3) is mental-state-dependent and is struck.
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) A person who influences a child through content (Section 11(3)) with the intention of 1. induce the child to perform sexual acts which the child is to perform on or in front of the offender or on or in front of a third person, or to allow the offender or a third person to perform such acts on the child, or 2. commit an offence under Section 184b(1), first sentence, point 3, or under Section 184b(3). (2) A person who offers a child for an act under paragraph 1 or promises to provide one, or who conspires with another to commit such an act, shall likewise be punished. (3) In the case of offences under paragraph 1, an attempt is punishable in cases where the offence is not completed solely because the offender mistakenly assumes that his or her actions relate to a child.
«if PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren is true»(1) {Actor} shall be liable who «if {ExertsInfluence} is true»influences «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» through {Content} (Section 11(3)) «end if» with the intention of 1. «if {Induce} is true»induce the child to perform [SexualActs] which the child is to perform «if {OnActor} is true»on «end if» «if {InFrontOfActor} is true»or in front of «end if» {Actor} «if {OnThirdPerson} is true»or on «end if» «if {InFrontOfThirdPerson} is true»or in front of «end if» a {ThirdPerson}, or to «if {AllowsActorPerform} is true»allow {Actor} «end if» «if {AllowsThirdPersonPerform} is true»or a {ThirdPerson} «end if» to perform such acts on the child «end if», or 2. «if {CommitReferencedOffence} is true»commit an offence under «if {Under184b1S1N3} is true»Section 184b(1), first sentence, point 3 «end if» «if {Under184b3} is true»or under Section 184b(3) «end if» «end if». (2) {Actor} who «if {Offers} is true»offers «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» for «if {ActUnderPara1} is true»an act under paragraph 1 «end if» «end if» «if {Promises} is true»or promises to provide one «end if», or «if {Conspires} is true»conspires with another to commit such an act «end if», shall likewise be punished. (3) In the case of offences under paragraph 1, an attempt is punishable in cases where the offence is not completed solely because the offender mistakenly assumes that his or her actions relate to a child.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[ReferencedOffence] = Under184b1S1N3 is true or Under184b3 is true
[Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14
[Leg2] = CommitReferencedOffence is true and ReferencedOffence is true
[Para2] = Child is true and ((Offers is true and ActUnderPara1 is true) or Promises is true or Conspires is true)
[IntendedActs] = OnActor is true or InFrontOfActor is true or OnThirdPerson is true or InFrontOfThirdPerson is true or AllowsActorPerform is true or AllowsThirdPersonPerform is true
[Leg1] = SexualActs is true and Induce is true and IntendedActs is true
[Intention] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true
[Para1] = ExertsInfluence is true and Child is true and Intention is true
[PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSA-R01 | act | Actor | ExertsInfluence is true | |
| PSA-R02 | act | Actor | Induce is true | |
| PSA-R03 | condition | None | OnActor is true | |
| PSA-R04 | condition | None | InFrontOfActor is true | |
| PSA-R05 | condition | None | OnThirdPerson is true | |
| PSA-R06 | condition | None | InFrontOfThirdPerson is true | |
| PSA-R07 | condition | None | AllowsActorPerform is true | |
| PSA-R08 | condition | None | AllowsThirdPersonPerform is true | |
| PSA-R09 | act | Actor | CommitReferencedOffence is true | |
| PSA-R10 | condition | None | Under184b1S1N3 is true | |
| PSA-R11 | condition | None | Under184b3 is true | |
| PSA-R12 | act | Actor | Offers is true | |
| PSA-R13 | condition | None | ActUnderPara1 is true | |
| PSA-R14 | act | Actor | Promises is true | |
| PSA-R15 | act | Actor | Conspires is true | |
| PSA-R90 | condition | None | the person is under the age of fourteen (a child) | Child is true |
| PSA-R91 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| PSA-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} influences the child through the {Content} | Merkmal | {ExertsInfluence} | PSA-R01 | is true |
| {Actor} intends to induce the child to perform the act | Merkmal | {Induce} | PSA-R02 | is true |
| the child is to perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {OnActor} | PSA-R03 | is true |
| the child is to perform the act in front of {Actor} | Merkmal | {InFrontOfActor} | PSA-R04 | is true |
| the child is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {OnThirdPerson} | PSA-R05 | is true |
| the child is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {InFrontOfThirdPerson} | PSA-R06 | is true |
| the child is to allow {Actor} to perform the act on the child | Merkmal | {AllowsActorPerform} | PSA-R07 | is true |
| the child is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on the child | Merkmal | {AllowsThirdPersonPerform} | PSA-R08 | is true |
| {Actor} intends to commit the referenced offence | Merkmal | {CommitReferencedOffence} | PSA-R09 | is true |
| an offence under Section 184b(1) first sentence point 3 | Merkmal | {Under184b1S1N3} | PSA-R10 | is true |
| an offence under Section 184b(3) | Merkmal | {Under184b3} | PSA-R11 | is true |
| {Actor} offers the child for the referenced act | Merkmal | {Offers} | PSA-R12 | is true |
| an act under paragraph 1 | Merkmal | {ActUnderPara1} | PSA-R13 | is true |
| {Actor} promises to provide such a child | Merkmal | {Promises} | PSA-R14 | is true |
| {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act | Merkmal | {Conspires} | PSA-R15 | is true |
| (3) mistaken-child attempt | attempt / mental | — excluded — | — | struck |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {ActUnderPara1} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an act under paragraph 1 |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AgeLimit14} | Number | – | Session | fourteen years |
| {AllowsActorPerform} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child is to allow {Actor} to perform the act on the child |
| {AllowsThirdPersonPerform} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on the child |
| {CommitReferencedOffence} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} intends to commit the referenced offence |
| {Conspires} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act |
| {Content} | Party | – | Session | content within the meaning of Section 11(3) |
| {ExertsInfluence} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} influences the child through the {Content} |
| {InFrontOfActor} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child is to perform the act in front of {Actor} |
| {InFrontOfThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson} |
| {Induce} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} intends to induce the child to perform the act |
| {Offers} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} offers the child for the referenced act |
| {OnActor} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child is to perform the act on {Actor} |
| {OnThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson} |
| {PersonAge} | Number | – | Session | the age of {Person} in years |
| {Promises} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} promises to provide such a child |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third person |
| {Under184b1S1N3} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an offence under Section 184b(1) first sentence point 3 |
| {Under184b3} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an offence under Section 184b(3) |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: ({Actor} influences the child through the {Content} and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and {Actor} intends to induce the child to perform the act and (the child is to perform the act on {Actor} or the child is to perform the act in front of {Actor} or the child is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson} or the child is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson} or the child is to allow {Actor} to perform the act on the child or the child is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on the child)) or ({Actor} intends to commit the referenced offence and (an offence under Section 184b(1) first sentence point 3 or an offence under Section 184b(3))))) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (({Actor} offers the child for the referenced act and an act under paragraph 1) or {Actor} promises to provide such a child or {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act)).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [ReferencedOffence] | Under184b1S1N3, Under184b3 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Child] | PersonAge, AgeLimit14 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg2] | CommitReferencedOffence, ReferencedOffence | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2] | Child, Offers, ActUnderPara1, Promises, Conspires | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [IntendedActs] | OnActor, InFrontOfActor, OnThirdPerson, InFrontOfThirdPerson, AllowsActorPerform, AllowsThirdPersonPerform | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Leg1] | SexualActs, Induce, IntendedActs | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Intention] | Leg1, Leg2 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1] | ExertsInfluence, Child, Intention | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren] | Para1, Para2 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (PSA-P0) | [PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {ActUnderPara1}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AgeLimit14}
├─ {AllowsActorPerform}
├─ {AllowsThirdPersonPerform}
├─ {CommitReferencedOffence}
├─ {Conspires}
├─ {Content}
├─ {ExertsInfluence}
├─ {InFrontOfActor}
├─ {InFrontOfThirdPerson}
├─ {Induce}
├─ {Offers}
├─ {OnActor}
├─ {OnThirdPerson}
├─ {PersonAge}
├─ {Promises}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
├─ {Under184b1S1N3}
├─ {Under184b3}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [ReferencedOffence] = Under184b1S1N3 is true or Under184b3 is true
├─ [Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14
├─ [Leg2] = CommitReferencedOffence is true and ReferencedOffence is true
├─ [Para2] = Child is true and ((Offers is true and ActUnderPara1 is true) or Promises is true or Conspires is true)
├─ [IntendedActs] = OnActor is true or InFrontOfActor is true or OnThirdPerson is true or InFrontOfThirdPerson is true or AllowsActorPerform is true or AllowsThirdPersonPerform is true
├─ [Leg1] = SexualActs is true and Induce is true and IntendedActs is true
├─ [Intention] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true
├─ [Para1] = ExertsInfluence is true and Child is true and Intention is true
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren] depends on [ReferencedOffence], [Child], [Leg2], [Para2], [IntendedActs], [Leg1], [Intention], [Para1] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [PreparationOfSexualAbuseOfChildren]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {ActUnderPara1} | Element/Datum: an act under paragraph 1.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q3 | Session | {AgeLimit14} | Element/Datum: fourteen years.? | Number |
| Q4 | Session | {AllowsActorPerform} | Element/Datum: the child is to allow {Actor} to perform the act on the child.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {AllowsThirdPersonPerform} | Element/Datum: the child is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on the child.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {CommitReferencedOffence} | Element/Datum: {Actor} intends to commit the referenced offence.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {Conspires} | Element/Datum: {Actor} conspires with another to commit such an act.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {Content} | Element/Datum: content within the meaning of Section 11(3).? | Party |
| Q9 | Session | {ExertsInfluence} | Element/Datum: {Actor} influences the child through the {Content}.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {InFrontOfActor} | Element/Datum: the child is to perform the act in front of {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {InFrontOfThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: the child is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {Induce} | Element/Datum: {Actor} intends to induce the child to perform the act.? | Boolean |
| Q13 | Session | {Offers} | Element/Datum: {Actor} offers the child for the referenced act.? | Boolean |
| Q14 | Session | {OnActor} | Element/Datum: the child is to perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {OnThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: the child is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q16 | Session | {PersonAge} | Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.? | Number |
| Q17 | Session | {Promises} | Element/Datum: {Actor} promises to provide such a child.? | Boolean |
| Q18 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third person.? | Party |
| Q19 | Session | {Under184b1S1N3} | Element/Datum: an offence under Section 184b(1) first sentence point 3.? | Boolean |
| Q20 | Session | {Under184b3} | Element/Datum: an offence under Section 184b(3).? | Boolean |
Flags
Scope Paragraph 1, influencing a child through content with the intention of inducing sexual acts (leg 1) or committing a §184b offence (leg 2); paragraph 2, offering, promising or conspiring. Paragraph 3 (the mistaken-child attempt rule) struck entirely per the marked-up source.
Intent element retained per the markup The grooming offence is constituted by the intention legs; the marked-up source strikes only the penalty and leaves the “with the intention of” legs live. They are encoded deterministically on the description of the intended acts ([IntendedActs], [ReferencedOffence]); whether the intention existed in fact is a mental element and escalates to a human. This departs from the §174(3) precedent (special intent struck) only because the markup keeps these legs, without which §176b is empty.
Intended-act modalities The six coordinated modalities of leg 1 ({OnActor}, {InFrontOfActor}, {OnThirdPerson}, {InFrontOfThirdPerson}, {AllowsActorPerform}, {AllowsThirdPersonPerform}) are object variables in their own blocks inside the {Induce} span, with the disjunction in [IntendedActs] (rules 1, 2, 10).
Referenced offences as objects {Under184b1S1N3} and {Under184b3} are coordinated reference objects inside the {CommitReferencedOffence} span; the disjunction is [ReferencedOffence] (rule 10).
Content as variable {Content} carries content within the meaning of Section 11(3) (rule 3).
Child definition [Child] = {PersonAge} < {AgeLimit14}, restated locally; §176 is the authoring provision.
Translation note The draft English layer renders the intention legs in the infinitive (“induce…”, “commit…”) without a finite construction and (1) lacks its penalty in the translation; the source column carries the text as published, the German governs.
Strikes The penalty fragment in (1), “shall likewise be punished” in (2) (“Ebenso wird bestraft”) and the whole of (3) struck in the markup only.
Treatment §176b is Operomise-tagged. Encoded on the objective description of the prohibited preparation; the mental elements (intention in fact, mistaken assumption) escalate.
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) Any person who disseminates or makes available to the public content (Section 11(3)) which is likely to serve as a guide to an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d, and which is intended to encourage or arouse the willingness of others to commit such an act, shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (2) The same penalty shall apply to anyone who 1. disseminates or makes available to the public content (Section 11(3)) that is capable of serving as instructions for an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d, or 2. publicly or at a gathering provides instructions for an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d, with the aim of encouraging or arousing others to commit such an act. (3) Any person who accesses, possesses, makes available to another person, or procures possession of content referred to in paragraph 1 for another person shall be liable to imprisonment for up to two years or a fine. (4) Paragraph 3 shall not apply to acts which serve exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the following: 1. state functions, 2. tasks arising from agreements with a competent public authority, or 3. official or professional duties. (5) Paragraphs 1 and 3 shall not apply to official acts carried out in the context of criminal investigations where 1. no child pornography content that depicts actual events or that has been produced using an image of a child or young person is made available to another person or to the public, distributed, or provided to another person for possession, and 2. clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or significantly impeded. (6) Objects to which an offence under paragraph 3 relates shall be seized. Section 74a shall apply.
«if InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren is true»(1) {Actor} who «if {Disseminates} is true»disseminates «end if» «if {MakesAvailableToPublic} is true»or makes available to the public «end if» {Content} (Section 11(3)) «if {SuitableAsGuide} is true»which is likely to serve as a guide to «if {ReferencedAct} is true»an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d «end if» «end if», and which is intended to «if {Encourages} is true»encourage «end if» «if {Arouses} is true»or arouse «end if» the {Willingness}, shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (2) The same penalty shall apply to {Actor} who 1. «if {Disseminates} is true»disseminates «end if» «if {MakesAvailableToPublic} is true»or makes available to the public «end if» {Content} (Section 11(3)) «if {CapableAsInstructions} is true»that is capable of serving as instructions for «if {ReferencedAct} is true»an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d «end if» «end if», or 2. «if {Publicly} is true»publicly «end if» «if {AtGathering} is true»or at a gathering «end if» «if {ProvidesInstructions} is true»provides instructions for «if {ReferencedAct} is true»an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d «end if» «end if», with the aim of «if {Encourages} is true»encouraging «end if» «if {Arouses} is true»or arousing «end if» others to commit such an act. (3) {Actor} who «if {Accesses} is true»accesses «end if» «if {Possesses} is true», possesses «end if» «if {MakesAvailableToAnother} is true», makes available to another person «end if» «if {ProcuresPossessionForAnother} is true»or procures possession for another person of «end if» «if {ContentPara1} is true»content referred to in paragraph 1 «end if», shall be liable to imprisonment for up to two years or a fine. (4) Paragraph 3 shall not apply «if [Exemption4] is true»to acts «if {ServesExclusively} is true»which serve exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the following «end if»: 1. «if {StateFunctions} is true»state functions «end if», 2. «if {AgreementTasks} is true»tasks arising from agreements with a competent public authority «end if», or 3. «if {OfficialDuties} is true»official «end if» «if {ProfessionalDuties} is true»or professional duties «end if» «end if». (5) Paragraphs 1 and 3 shall not apply «if [Exemption5] is true»to «if {OfficialActInInvestigation} is true»official acts carried out in the context of criminal investigations «end if» where 1. no child pornography content «if {DepictsActualEvents} is true»that depicts actual events «end if» «if {ProducedUsingChildImage} is true»or that has been produced using an image of a child «end if» «if {ProducedUsingYouthImage} is true»or young person «end if» is «if {CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother} is true»made available to another person «end if» «if {CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic} is true»or to the public «end if» «if {CSAMDistributed} is true», distributed «end if» «if {CSAMPossessionProvided} is true», or provided to another person for possession «end if», and 2. clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be «if {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} is true»futile «end if» «if {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} is true»or significantly impeded «end if» «end if». (6) Objects to which an offence under paragraph 3 relates shall be seized. Section 74a shall apply.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[Venue] = Publicly is true or AtGathering is true
[Para2Leg2] = ProvidesInstructions is true and Venue is true and ReferencedAct is true
[Para3Conduct] = Accesses is true or Possesses is true or MakesAvailableToAnother is true or ProcuresPossessionForAnother is true
[Para3] = Para3Conduct is true and ContentPara1 is true
[Dissemination] = Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true
[Instructions] = CapableAsInstructions is true and ReferencedAct is true
[Para2Leg1] = Dissemination is true and Instructions is true
[Destination] = Encourages is true or Arouses is true
[Para2] = (Para2Leg1 is true or Para2Leg2 is true) and Destination is true
[Guide] = SuitableAsGuide is true and ReferencedAct is true
[Para1] = Dissemination is true and Guide is true and Destination is true
[ExemptDuty] = StateFunctions is true or AgreementTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true
[RealCSAM] = DepictsActualEvents is true or ProducedUsingChildImage is true or ProducedUsingYouthImage is true
[CSAMHandling] = CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother is true or CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic is true or CSAMDistributed is true or CSAMPossessionProvided is true
[RealCSAMHandled] = RealCSAM is true and CSAMHandling is true
[InvestigativeNecessity] = ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true or ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true
[Exemption5] = OfficialActInInvestigation is true and RealCSAMHandled is false and InvestigativeNecessity is true
[Exemption4] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true
[InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren] = (Para1 is true and Exemption5 is false) or Para2 is true or (Para3 is true and Exemption4 is false and Exemption5 is false)
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ISA-R01 | act | Actor | Disseminates is true | |
| ISA-R02 | act | Actor | MakesAvailableToPublic is true | |
| ISA-R03 | condition | None | SuitableAsGuide is true | |
| ISA-R04 | condition | None | ReferencedAct is true | |
| ISA-R05 | condition | None | Encourages is true | |
| ISA-R06 | condition | None | Arouses is true | |
| ISA-R07 | condition | None | CapableAsInstructions is true | |
| ISA-R08 | act | Actor | ProvidesInstructions is true | |
| ISA-R09 | condition | None | Publicly is true | |
| ISA-R10 | condition | None | AtGathering is true | |
| ISA-R11 | act | Actor | Accesses is true | |
| ISA-R12 | act | Actor | Possesses is true | |
| ISA-R13 | act | Actor | MakesAvailableToAnother is true | |
| ISA-R14 | act | Actor | ProcuresPossessionForAnother is true | |
| ISA-R15 | condition | None | ContentPara1 is true | |
| ISA-R16 | condition | None | ServesExclusively is true | |
| ISA-R17 | condition | None | StateFunctions is true | |
| ISA-R18 | condition | None | AgreementTasks is true | |
| ISA-R19 | condition | None | OfficialDuties is true | |
| ISA-R20 | condition | None | ProfessionalDuties is true | |
| ISA-R21 | condition | None | OfficialActInInvestigation is true | |
| ISA-R22 | condition | None | DepictsActualEvents is true | |
| ISA-R23 | condition | None | ProducedUsingChildImage is true | |
| ISA-R24 | condition | None | ProducedUsingYouthImage is true | |
| ISA-R25 | condition | None | CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother is true | |
| ISA-R26 | condition | None | CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic is true | |
| ISA-R27 | condition | None | CSAMDistributed is true | |
| ISA-R28 | condition | None | CSAMPossessionProvided is true | |
| ISA-R29 | condition | None | ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true | |
| ISA-R30 | condition | None | ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true | |
| ISA-R90 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| ISA-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| {Actor} disseminates the {Content} | Merkmal | {Disseminates} | ISA-R01 | is true |
| {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public | Merkmal | {MakesAvailableToPublic} | ISA-R02 | is true |
| the {Content} is likely to serve as a guide to the referenced act | Merkmal | {SuitableAsGuide} | ISA-R03 | is true |
| an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d | Merkmal | {ReferencedAct} | ISA-R04 | is true |
| the {Content} is intended to encourage the {Willingness} | Merkmal | {Encourages} | ISA-R05 | is true |
| the {Content} is intended to arouse the {Willingness} | Merkmal | {Arouses} | ISA-R06 | is true |
| the {Content} is capable of serving as instructions for the referenced act | Merkmal | {CapableAsInstructions} | ISA-R07 | is true |
| {Actor} provides instructions for the referenced act | Merkmal | {ProvidesInstructions} | ISA-R08 | is true |
| publicly | Merkmal | {Publicly} | ISA-R09 | is true |
| at a gathering | Merkmal | {AtGathering} | ISA-R10 | is true |
| {Actor} accesses the {Content} | Merkmal | {Accesses} | ISA-R11 | is true |
| {Actor} possesses the {Content} | Merkmal | {Possesses} | ISA-R12 | is true |
| {Actor} makes the {Content} available to another person | Merkmal | {MakesAvailableToAnother} | ISA-R13 | is true |
| {Actor} procures possession of the {Content} for another person | Merkmal | {ProcuresPossessionForAnother} | ISA-R14 | is true |
| the content is content referred to in paragraph 1 | Merkmal | {ContentPara1} | ISA-R15 | is true |
| the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties | Merkmal | {ServesExclusively} | ISA-R16 | is true |
| state functions | Merkmal | {StateFunctions} | ISA-R17 | is true |
| tasks arising from agreements with a competent public authority | Merkmal | {AgreementTasks} | ISA-R18 | is true |
| official duties | Merkmal | {OfficialDuties} | ISA-R19 | is true |
| professional duties | Merkmal | {ProfessionalDuties} | ISA-R20 | is true |
| the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations | Merkmal | {OfficialActInInvestigation} | ISA-R21 | is true |
| the child pornography content depicts actual events | Merkmal | {DepictsActualEvents} | ISA-R22 | is true |
| the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a child | Merkmal | {ProducedUsingChildImage} | ISA-R23 | is true |
| the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a young person | Merkmal | {ProducedUsingYouthImage} | ISA-R24 | is true |
| such content is made available to another person | Merkmal | {CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother} | ISA-R25 | is true |
| such content is made available to the public | Merkmal | {CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic} | ISA-R26 | is true |
| such content is distributed | Merkmal | {CSAMDistributed} | ISA-R27 | is true |
| such content is provided to another person for possession | Merkmal | {CSAMPossessionProvided} | ISA-R28 | is true |
| clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile | Merkmal | {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} | ISA-R29 | is true |
| clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded | Merkmal | {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} | ISA-R30 | is true |
| (6) seizure | consequence | — excluded — | — | struck |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Accesses} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} accesses the {Content} |
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AgreementTasks} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | tasks arising from agreements with a competent public authority |
| {Arouses} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the {Content} is intended to arouse the {Willingness} |
| {AtGathering} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | at a gathering |
| {CSAMDistributed} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | such content is distributed |
| {CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | such content is made available to another person |
| {CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | such content is made available to the public |
| {CSAMPossessionProvided} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | such content is provided to another person for possession |
| {CapableAsInstructions} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the {Content} is capable of serving as instructions for the referenced act |
| {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile |
| {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded |
| {Content} | Party | – | Session | content within the meaning of Section 11(3) |
| {ContentPara1} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the content is content referred to in paragraph 1 |
| {DepictsActualEvents} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child pornography content depicts actual events |
| {Disseminates} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} disseminates the {Content} |
| {Encourages} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the {Content} is intended to encourage the {Willingness} |
| {MakesAvailableToAnother} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} makes the {Content} available to another person |
| {MakesAvailableToPublic} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public |
| {OfficialActInInvestigation} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations |
| {OfficialDuties} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | official duties |
| {Possesses} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} possesses the {Content} |
| {ProcuresPossessionForAnother} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} procures possession of the {Content} for another person |
| {ProducedUsingChildImage} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a child |
| {ProducedUsingYouthImage} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a young person |
| {ProfessionalDuties} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | professional duties |
| {ProvidesInstructions} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} provides instructions for the referenced act |
| {Publicly} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | publicly |
| {ReferencedAct} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d |
| {ServesExclusively} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties |
| {StateFunctions} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | state functions |
| {SuitableAsGuide} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the {Content} is likely to serve as a guide to the referenced act |
| {Willingness} | Party | – | Session | the willingness of others to commit such an act |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: ((({Actor} disseminates the {Content} or {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public) and (the {Content} is likely to serve as a guide to the referenced act and an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d) and (the {Content} is intended to encourage the {Willingness} or the {Content} is intended to arouse the {Willingness})) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and it is not the case that ((the child pornography content depicts actual events or the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a child or the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (such content is made available to another person or such content is made available to the public or such content is distributed or such content is provided to another person for possession)) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))) or (((({Actor} disseminates the {Content} or {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public) and (the {Content} is capable of serving as instructions for the referenced act and an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d)) or ({Actor} provides instructions for the referenced act and (publicly or at a gathering) and an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d)) and (the {Content} is intended to encourage the {Willingness} or the {Content} is intended to arouse the {Willingness})) or ((({Actor} accesses the {Content} or {Actor} possesses the {Content} or {Actor} makes the {Content} available to another person or {Actor} procures possession of the {Content} for another person) and the content is content referred to in paragraph 1) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state functions or tasks arising from agreements with a competent public authority or official duties or professional duties)) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and it is not the case that ((the child pornography content depicts actual events or the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a child or the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (such content is made available to another person or such content is made available to the public or such content is distributed or such content is provided to another person for possession)) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [Venue] | Publicly, AtGathering | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Leg2] | ProvidesInstructions, Venue, ReferencedAct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para3Conduct] | Accesses, Possesses, MakesAvailableToAnother, ProcuresPossessionForAnother | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para3] | Para3Conduct, ContentPara1 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Dissemination] | Disseminates, MakesAvailableToPublic | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Instructions] | CapableAsInstructions, ReferencedAct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Leg1] | Dissemination, Instructions | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Destination] | Encourages, Arouses | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2] | Para2Leg1, Para2Leg2, Destination | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Guide] | SuitableAsGuide, ReferencedAct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1] | Dissemination, Guide, Destination | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ExemptDuty] | StateFunctions, AgreementTasks, OfficialDuties, ProfessionalDuties | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [RealCSAM] | DepictsActualEvents, ProducedUsingChildImage, ProducedUsingYouthImage | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [CSAMHandling] | CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother, CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic, CSAMDistributed, CSAMPossessionProvided | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [RealCSAMHandled] | RealCSAM, CSAMHandling | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [InvestigativeNecessity] | ClarificationOtherwiseFutile, ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Exemption5] | OfficialActInInvestigation, RealCSAMHandled, InvestigativeNecessity | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Exemption4] | ServesExclusively, ExemptDuty | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren] | Para1, Exemption5, Para2, Para3, Exemption4, Exemption5 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (ISA-P0) | [InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Accesses}
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AgreementTasks}
├─ {Arouses}
├─ {AtGathering}
├─ {CSAMDistributed}
├─ {CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother}
├─ {CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic}
├─ {CSAMPossessionProvided}
├─ {CapableAsInstructions}
├─ {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile}
├─ {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}
├─ {Content}
├─ {ContentPara1}
├─ {DepictsActualEvents}
├─ {Disseminates}
├─ {Encourages}
├─ {MakesAvailableToAnother}
├─ {MakesAvailableToPublic}
├─ {OfficialActInInvestigation}
├─ {OfficialDuties}
├─ {Possesses}
├─ {ProcuresPossessionForAnother}
├─ {ProducedUsingChildImage}
├─ {ProducedUsingYouthImage}
├─ {ProfessionalDuties}
├─ {ProvidesInstructions}
├─ {Publicly}
├─ {ReferencedAct}
├─ {ServesExclusively}
├─ {StateFunctions}
├─ {SuitableAsGuide}
├─ {Willingness}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [Venue] = Publicly is true or AtGathering is true
├─ [Para2Leg2] = ProvidesInstructions is true and Venue is true and ReferencedAct is true
├─ [Para3Conduct] = Accesses is true or Possesses is true or MakesAvailableToAnother is true or ProcuresPossessionForAnother is true
├─ [Para3] = Para3Conduct is true and ContentPara1 is true
├─ [Dissemination] = Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true
├─ [Instructions] = CapableAsInstructions is true and ReferencedAct is true
├─ [Para2Leg1] = Dissemination is true and Instructions is true
├─ [Destination] = Encourages is true or Arouses is true
├─ [Para2] = (Para2Leg1 is true or Para2Leg2 is true) and Destination is true
├─ [Guide] = SuitableAsGuide is true and ReferencedAct is true
├─ [Para1] = Dissemination is true and Guide is true and Destination is true
├─ [ExemptDuty] = StateFunctions is true or AgreementTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true
├─ [RealCSAM] = DepictsActualEvents is true or ProducedUsingChildImage is true or ProducedUsingYouthImage is true
├─ [CSAMHandling] = CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother is true or CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic is true or CSAMDistributed is true or CSAMPossessionProvided is true
├─ [RealCSAMHandled] = RealCSAM is true and CSAMHandling is true
├─ [InvestigativeNecessity] = ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true or ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true
├─ [Exemption5] = OfficialActInInvestigation is true and RealCSAMHandled is false and InvestigativeNecessity is true
├─ [Exemption4] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren] = (Para1 is true and Exemption5 is false) or Para2 is true or (Para3 is true and Exemption4 is false and Exemption5 is false)
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren] depends on [Venue], [Para2Leg2], [Para3Conduct], [Para3], [Dissemination], [Instructions], [Para2Leg1], [Destination], [Para2], [Guide], [Para1], [ExemptDuty], [RealCSAM], [CSAMHandling], [RealCSAMHandled], [InvestigativeNecessity], [Exemption5], [Exemption4] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [InstructionsForSexualAbuseOfChildren]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Accesses} | Element/Datum: {Actor} accesses the {Content}.? | Boolean |
| Q2 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q3 | Session | {AgreementTasks} | Element/Datum: tasks arising from agreements with a competent public authority.? | Boolean |
| Q4 | Session | {Arouses} | Element/Datum: the {Content} is intended to arouse the {Willingness}.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {AtGathering} | Element/Datum: at a gathering.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {CSAMDistributed} | Element/Datum: such content is distributed.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {CSAMMadeAvailableToAnother} | Element/Datum: such content is made available to another person.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {CSAMMadeAvailableToPublic} | Element/Datum: such content is made available to the public.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {CSAMPossessionProvided} | Element/Datum: such content is provided to another person for possession.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {CapableAsInstructions} | Element/Datum: the {Content} is capable of serving as instructions for the referenced act.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} | Element/Datum: clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} | Element/Datum: clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded.? | Boolean |
| Q13 | Session | {Content} | Element/Datum: content within the meaning of Section 11(3).? | Party |
| Q14 | Session | {ContentPara1} | Element/Datum: the content is content referred to in paragraph 1.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {DepictsActualEvents} | Element/Datum: the child pornography content depicts actual events.? | Boolean |
| Q16 | Session | {Disseminates} | Element/Datum: {Actor} disseminates the {Content}.? | Boolean |
| Q17 | Session | {Encourages} | Element/Datum: the {Content} is intended to encourage the {Willingness}.? | Boolean |
| Q18 | Session | {MakesAvailableToAnother} | Element/Datum: {Actor} makes the {Content} available to another person.? | Boolean |
| Q19 | Session | {MakesAvailableToPublic} | Element/Datum: {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public.? | Boolean |
| Q20 | Session | {OfficialActInInvestigation} | Element/Datum: the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations.? | Boolean |
| Q21 | Session | {OfficialDuties} | Element/Datum: official duties.? | Boolean |
| Q22 | Session | {Possesses} | Element/Datum: {Actor} possesses the {Content}.? | Boolean |
| Q23 | Session | {ProcuresPossessionForAnother} | Element/Datum: {Actor} procures possession of the {Content} for another person.? | Boolean |
| Q24 | Session | {ProducedUsingChildImage} | Element/Datum: the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a child.? | Boolean |
| Q25 | Session | {ProducedUsingYouthImage} | Element/Datum: the child pornography content has been produced using an image of a young person.? | Boolean |
| Q26 | Session | {ProfessionalDuties} | Element/Datum: professional duties.? | Boolean |
| Q27 | Session | {ProvidesInstructions} | Element/Datum: {Actor} provides instructions for the referenced act.? | Boolean |
| Q28 | Session | {Publicly} | Element/Datum: publicly.? | Boolean |
| Q29 | Session | {ReferencedAct} | Element/Datum: an unlawful act referred to in Sections 176 to 176d.? | Boolean |
| Q30 | Session | {ServesExclusively} | Element/Datum: the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties.? | Boolean |
| Q31 | Session | {StateFunctions} | Element/Datum: state functions.? | Boolean |
| Q32 | Session | {SuitableAsGuide} | Element/Datum: the {Content} is likely to serve as a guide to the referenced act.? | Boolean |
| Q33 | Session | {Willingness} | Element/Datum: the willingness of others to commit such an act.? | Party |
Flags
Scope Paragraphs 1 to 3, the three offence variants (guide content disseminated; instruction content disseminated or instructions given publicly or at a gathering; accessing, possessing, passing on or procuring such content); paragraphs 4 and 5, the two statutory exemptions, encoded live. Paragraph 6 (seizure) struck as a pure consequence.
Exemptions as separate rules, scoped per leg (rule 8) [Exemption4] (exclusively lawful fulfilment of state functions, agreement tasks, or official or professional duties) negates paragraph 3 only; [Exemption5] (investigative official acts, no real-image child pornography handled, clarification otherwise futile or significantly impeded) negates paragraphs 1 and 3. The top composite applies each as “and not” on exactly the legs the statute names: (Para1 and not Exemption5) or Para2 or (Para3 and not Exemption4 and not Exemption5). No exemption lives inside an offence leg.
Exemption 5 decomposition Condition 1 is the conjunction of two coordinated families: the real-image properties ([RealCSAM]: {DepictsActualEvents}, {ProducedUsingChildImage}, {ProducedUsingYouthImage}) and the handling modalities ([CSAMHandling]: made available to another, made available to the public, distributed, possession provided). The statutory negative (“no such content is handled”) is [RealCSAMHandled] is false inside [Exemption5]. Condition 2 is [InvestigativeNecessity]: {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} or {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}.
Dissemination modalities reused {Disseminates} and {MakesAvailableToPublic} carry the same Merkmal in (1) and (2)1; [Dissemination] is consumed by both. {Encourages} and {Arouses} likewise carry the destination element in (1) and the closing aim of (2); [Destination] is consumed by both (one variable per Merkmal).
Statutory range as prose “Sections 176 to 176d” is a range, not a coordination of facts; it stays inside the {ReferencedAct} object surface.
Source note The markup splits the closing words of (2) (“with the aim of encouraging or arousing others to commit such an act.”) into a separate row; the source column reattaches them to (2), where the German places them.
Strikes The penalties in (1) and (3), “The same penalty shall apply” in (2) and the whole of (6) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.
Treatment §176e is Operomise-tagged: the offence turns on content properties, conduct modalities and the two exemptions, all encodable; the content-purpose elements (“intended to”, “with the aim of”) are encoded as properties of the content and the act as written, with the underlying mental finding escalating to a human.
Source (English, unofficial)
Operome markup - original text encoded
(1) Any person who, against the recognisable will of another person, performs sexual acts on that person or causes them to be performed, or directs that person to perform or tolerate sexual acts on or by a third party, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of six months to five years. (2) A person shall likewise be punished who performs sexual acts on another person or causes such acts to be performed on that person, or who directs that person to perform or tolerate sexual acts on or by a third party, if 1. the offender takes advantage of the fact that the person is unable to form or express a contrary will, 2. the offender takes advantage of the fact that the person is significantly restricted in forming or expressing their will due to their physical or mental condition, unless the offender has obtained the consent of that person, 3. the perpetrator takes advantage of a moment of surprise, 4. the perpetrator takes advantage of a situation in which the victim faces a serious risk of harm if they resist, or 5. the perpetrator has coerced the person into performing or tolerating the sexual act by threatening them with serious harm. (3) An attempt is punishable. (4) A term of imprisonment of not less than one year shall be imposed if the inability to form or express a will is due to an illness or disability of the victim. (5) A term of imprisonment of not less than one year shall be imposed if the offender 1. uses violence against the victim, 2. threatens the victim with imminent danger to life or limb, or 3. takes advantage of a situation in which the victim is defenceless against the perpetrator’s actions. (6) In particularly serious cases, a custodial sentence of not less than two years shall be imposed. A particularly serious case generally exists where 1. the offender has sexual intercourse with the victim or causes sexual intercourse to be performed on the victim, or performs or causes similar sexual acts to be performed on the victim which are particularly degrading, in particular if they involve penetration of the body (rape), or 2. the offence is committed jointly by several persons. (7) A term of imprisonment of not less than three years shall be imposed if the offender 1. carries a weapon or other dangerous instrument, 2. carries any other instrument or means intended to prevent or overcome the resistance of another person by force or the threat of force, or 3. exposes the victim to the risk of serious harm to their health. (8) A term of imprisonment of not less than five years shall be imposed if the offender 1. uses a weapon or other dangerous instrument in the commission of the offence, or 2. the victim a) was subjected to serious physical abuse during the offence, or b) put the victim in danger of death as a result of the offence. (9) In less serious cases under paragraphs 1 and 2, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of three months to three years; in less serious cases under paragraphs 4 and 5, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of six months to ten years; in less serious cases under paragraphs 7 and 8, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of one year to ten years.
«if SexualAssault is true»(1) {Actor} who, «if {AgainstRecognisableWill} is true»against the recognisable will of {Person} «end if», «if {Performs} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {HasVictimPerformOnActor} is true»or causes them to be performed «end if», or «if {Directs} is true»directs {Person} to «if {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform «end if» «if {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} is true»or tolerate «end if» [SexualActs] on or by a {ThirdPerson} «end if», shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of six months to five years. (2) {Actor} shall likewise be punished who «if {Performs} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {HasVictimPerformOnActor} is true»or causes such acts to be performed on that person «end if», or who «if {Directs} is true»directs {Person} to «if {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform «end if» «if {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} is true»or tolerate «end if» [SexualActs] on or by a {ThirdPerson} «end if», if 1. «if {Exploits} is true»takes advantage of the fact that {Person} is unable «if {UnableToFormContraryWill} is true»to form «end if» «if {UnableToExpressContraryWill} is true»or express «end if» a contrary will «end if», 2. «if {Exploits} is true»takes advantage of the fact that {Person} is {Significantly} significantly restricted in «if {RestrictedInForming} is true»forming «end if» «if {RestrictedInExpressing} is true»or expressing «end if» their will due to their «if {PhysicalCondition} is true»physical «end if» «if {MentalCondition} is true»or mental «end if» condition «end if», «if [Circ2] is true»unless «if {ConsentObtained} is true»{Actor} has obtained the consent of {Person} «end if» «end if», 3. «if {Exploits} is true»takes advantage of «if {MomentOfSurprise} is true»a moment of surprise «end if» «end if», 4. «if {Exploits} is true»takes advantage of «if {SituationOfRisk} is true»a situation in which {Person} faces a {Serious} serious risk of harm if they resist «end if» «end if», or 5. «if {Coerced} is true»has coerced {Person} «if {IntoPerforming} is true»into performing «end if» «if {IntoTolerating} is true»or tolerating «end if» the sexual act «end if» «if {ThreatensWithHarm} is true»by threatening them with {Serious} serious harm «end if». (3) An attempt is punishable. (4) A term of imprisonment of not less than one year shall be imposed if the inability to form or express a will is due to an illness or disability of the victim. (5) A term of imprisonment of not less than one year shall be imposed if the offender 1. uses violence against the victim, 2. threatens the victim with imminent danger to life or limb, or 3. takes advantage of a situation in which the victim is defenceless against the perpetrator’s actions. (6) In particularly serious cases, a custodial sentence of not less than two years shall be imposed. A particularly serious case generally exists where 1. the offender has sexual intercourse with the victim or causes sexual intercourse to be performed on the victim, or performs or causes similar sexual acts to be performed on the victim which are particularly degrading, in particular if they involve penetration of the body (rape), or 2. the offence is committed jointly by several persons. (7) A term of imprisonment of not less than three years shall be imposed if the offender 1. carries a weapon or other dangerous instrument, 2. carries any other instrument or means intended to prevent or overcome the resistance of another person by force or the threat of force, or 3. exposes the victim to the risk of serious harm to their health. (8) A term of imprisonment of not less than five years shall be imposed if the offender 1. uses a weapon or other dangerous instrument in the commission of the offence, or 2. the victim a) was subjected to serious physical abuse during the offence, or b) put the victim in danger of death as a result of the offence. (9) In less serious cases under paragraphs 1 and 2, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of three months to three years; in less serious cases under paragraphs 4 and 5, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of six months to ten years; in less serious cases under paragraphs 7 and 8, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of one year to ten years.«end if»
Annexes
Computables
[Circ1] = Exploits is true and (UnableToFormContraryWill is true or UnableToExpressContraryWill is true)
[Circ4] = Exploits is true and SituationOfRisk is true and Serious is true
[ConditionCause] = PhysicalCondition is true or MentalCondition is true
[Circ2] = Exploits is true and Significantly is true and (RestrictedInForming is true or RestrictedInExpressing is true) and ConditionCause is true and ConsentObtained is false
[ThirdPartyConduct] = Directs is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
[Conduct] = Performs is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true or ThirdPartyConduct is true
[Para1] = SexualActs is true and AgainstRecognisableWill is true and Conduct is true
[Circ3] = Exploits is true and MomentOfSurprise is true
[Circ5] = Coerced is true and (IntoPerforming is true or IntoTolerating is true) and ThreatensWithHarm is true and Serious is true
[Para2Circumstances] = Circ1 is true or Circ2 is true or Circ3 is true or Circ4 is true or Circ5 is true
[Para2] = SexualActs is true and Conduct is true and Para2Circumstances is true
[SexualAssault] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).
Business rules
| id | kind | actor | verb / predicate | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SXA-R01 | condition | None | AgainstRecognisableWill is true | |
| SXA-R02 | act | Actor | Performs is true | |
| SXA-R03 | act | Actor | HasVictimPerformOnActor is true | |
| SXA-R04 | act | Actor | Directs is true | |
| SXA-R05 | condition | None | VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true | |
| SXA-R06 | condition | None | VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true | |
| SXA-R07 | act | Actor | Exploits is true | |
| SXA-R08 | condition | None | UnableToFormContraryWill is true | |
| SXA-R09 | condition | None | UnableToExpressContraryWill is true | |
| SXA-R10 | condition | None | Significantly is true | |
| SXA-R11 | condition | None | RestrictedInForming is true | |
| SXA-R12 | condition | None | RestrictedInExpressing is true | |
| SXA-R13 | condition | None | PhysicalCondition is true | |
| SXA-R14 | condition | None | MentalCondition is true | |
| SXA-R15 | condition | None | ConsentObtained is true | |
| SXA-R16 | condition | None | MomentOfSurprise is true | |
| SXA-R17 | condition | None | SituationOfRisk is true | |
| SXA-R18 | condition | None | Serious is true | |
| SXA-R19 | act | Actor | Coerced is true | |
| SXA-R20 | condition | None | IntoPerforming is true | |
| SXA-R21 | condition | None | IntoTolerating is true | |
| SXA-R22 | act | Actor | ThreatensWithHarm is true | |
| SXA-R90 | condition | None | the act is a sexual act within section 184h | SexualActs is true |
| SXA-P0 | prohibition | Actor | not realise | not SexualAssault |
Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal
| Source phrase | Doctrinal role | Primitive | Rule | Requires |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any person who | Tätersubjekt | {Actor} | — | in scope |
| the act is against the recognisable will of {Person} | Merkmal | {AgainstRecognisableWill} | SXA-R01 | is true |
| {Actor} performs the act on {Person} | Merkmal | {Performs} | SXA-R02 | is true |
| {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} | Merkmal | {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | SXA-R03 | is true |
| {Actor} directs {Person} | Merkmal | {Directs} | SXA-R04 | is true |
| {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | SXA-R05 | is true |
| {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} | Merkmal | {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | SXA-R06 | is true |
| {Actor} takes advantage of the circumstance | Merkmal | {Exploits} | SXA-R07 | is true |
| {Person} is unable to form a contrary will | Merkmal | {UnableToFormContraryWill} | SXA-R08 | is true |
| {Person} is unable to express a contrary will | Merkmal | {UnableToExpressContraryWill} | SXA-R09 | is true |
| significantly | Merkmal | {Significantly} | SXA-R10 | is true |
| {Person} is restricted in forming their will | Merkmal | {RestrictedInForming} | SXA-R11 | is true |
| {Person} is restricted in expressing their will | Merkmal | {RestrictedInExpressing} | SXA-R12 | is true |
| {Person}'s physical condition | Merkmal | {PhysicalCondition} | SXA-R13 | is true |
| {Person}'s mental condition | Merkmal | {MentalCondition} | SXA-R14 | is true |
| {Actor} has obtained the consent of {Person} | Merkmal | {ConsentObtained} | SXA-R15 | is true |
| a moment of surprise obtains | Merkmal | {MomentOfSurprise} | SXA-R16 | is true |
| a situation obtains in which {Person} faces a risk of harm upon resistance | Merkmal | {SituationOfRisk} | SXA-R17 | is true |
| serious | Merkmal | {Serious} | SXA-R18 | is true |
| {Actor} has coerced {Person} | Merkmal | {Coerced} | SXA-R19 | is true |
| into performing the act | Merkmal | {IntoPerforming} | SXA-R20 | is true |
| into tolerating the act | Merkmal | {IntoTolerating} | SXA-R21 | is true |
| {Actor} threatens {Person} with harm | Merkmal | {ThreatensWithHarm} | SXA-R22 | is true |
| (3)-(9) attempt, aggravations and sentencing | grading / consequences | — excluded — | — | struck |
Variables appendix
| Variable | Input | Values | Cascade | Surface form (source words) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {Actor} | Reference | – | Session | any person (the actor) |
| {AgainstRecognisableWill} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | the act is against the recognisable will of {Person} |
| {Coerced} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} has coerced {Person} |
| {ConsentObtained} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} has obtained the consent of {Person} |
| {Directs} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} directs {Person} |
| {Exploits} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} takes advantage of the circumstance |
| {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} |
| {IntoPerforming} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | into performing the act |
| {IntoTolerating} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | into tolerating the act |
| {MentalCondition} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person}'s mental condition |
| {MomentOfSurprise} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a moment of surprise obtains |
| {Performs} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} performs the act on {Person} |
| {Person} | Party | – | Session | the other person (the victim) |
| {PhysicalCondition} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person}'s physical condition |
| {RestrictedInExpressing} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is restricted in expressing their will |
| {RestrictedInForming} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is restricted in forming their will |
| {Serious} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | serious |
| {Significantly} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | significantly |
| {SituationOfRisk} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | a situation obtains in which {Person} faces a risk of harm upon resistance |
| {ThirdPerson} | Party | – | Session | a third party |
| {ThreatensWithHarm} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Actor} threatens {Person} with harm |
| {UnableToExpressContraryWill} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is unable to express a contrary will |
| {UnableToFormContraryWill} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} is unable to form a contrary will |
| {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} |
| {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | Boolean | true / false / unknown | Session | {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson} |
Reconstruction from the substrate
Committed by any person (the actor) who: (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and the act is against the recognisable will of {Person} and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} or ({Actor} directs {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson})))) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor} or ({Actor} directs {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson}))) and (({Actor} takes advantage of the circumstance and ({Person} is unable to form a contrary will or {Person} is unable to express a contrary will)) or ({Actor} takes advantage of the circumstance and significantly and ({Person} is restricted in forming their will or {Person} is restricted in expressing their will) and ({Person}'s physical condition or {Person}'s mental condition) and not {Actor} has obtained the consent of {Person}) or ({Actor} takes advantage of the circumstance and a moment of surprise obtains) or ({Actor} takes advantage of the circumstance and a situation obtains in which {Person} faces a risk of harm upon resistance and serious) or ({Actor} has coerced {Person} and (into performing the act or into tolerating the act) and {Actor} threatens {Person} with harm and serious))).
Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.
Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)
| Assessment | Depends on | Invalidation | Trigger effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| [Circ1] | Exploits, UnableToFormContraryWill, UnableToExpressContraryWill | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Circ4] | Exploits, SituationOfRisk, Serious | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ConditionCause] | PhysicalCondition, MentalCondition | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Circ2] | Exploits, Significantly, RestrictedInForming, RestrictedInExpressing, ConditionCause, ConsentObtained | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [ThirdPartyConduct] | Directs, VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson, VictimToleratesByThirdPerson | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Conduct] | Performs, HasVictimPerformOnActor, ThirdPartyConduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para1] | SexualActs, AgainstRecognisableWill, Conduct | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Circ3] | Exploits, MomentOfSurprise | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Circ5] | Coerced, IntoPerforming, IntoTolerating, ThreatensWithHarm, Serious | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2Circumstances] | Circ1, Circ2, Circ3, Circ4, Circ5 | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [Para2] | SexualActs, Conduct, Para2Circumstances | false | Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite. |
| [SexualAssault] | Para1, Para2 | false | Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown. |
| prohibition (SXA-P0) | [SexualAssault] | re-derives | The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change. |
Decision tree
PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session)
├─ {Actor}
├─ {AgainstRecognisableWill}
├─ {Coerced}
├─ {ConsentObtained}
├─ {Directs}
├─ {Exploits}
├─ {HasVictimPerformOnActor}
├─ {IntoPerforming}
├─ {IntoTolerating}
├─ {MentalCondition}
├─ {MomentOfSurprise}
├─ {Performs}
├─ {Person}
├─ {PhysicalCondition}
├─ {RestrictedInExpressing}
├─ {RestrictedInForming}
├─ {Serious}
├─ {Significantly}
├─ {SituationOfRisk}
├─ {ThirdPerson}
├─ {ThreatensWithHarm}
├─ {UnableToExpressContraryWill}
├─ {UnableToFormContraryWill}
├─ {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson}
├─ {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson}
↓
PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables
├─ [Circ1] = Exploits is true and (UnableToFormContraryWill is true or UnableToExpressContraryWill is true)
├─ [Circ4] = Exploits is true and SituationOfRisk is true and Serious is true
├─ [ConditionCause] = PhysicalCondition is true or MentalCondition is true
├─ [Circ2] = Exploits is true and Significantly is true and (RestrictedInForming is true or RestrictedInExpressing is true) and ConditionCause is true and ConsentObtained is false
├─ [ThirdPartyConduct] = Directs is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimToleratesByThirdPerson is true)
├─ [Conduct] = Performs is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true or ThirdPartyConduct is true
├─ [Para1] = SexualActs is true and AgainstRecognisableWill is true and Conduct is true
├─ [Circ3] = Exploits is true and MomentOfSurprise is true
├─ [Circ5] = Coerced is true and (IntoPerforming is true or IntoTolerating is true) and ThreatensWithHarm is true and Serious is true
├─ [Para2Circumstances] = Circ1 is true or Circ2 is true or Circ3 is true or Circ4 is true or Circ5 is true
├─ [Para2] = SexualActs is true and Conduct is true and Para2Circumstances is true
├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h)
↓
PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions
└─ [SexualAssault] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true
↓
VERDICT (PrimeRule)
├─ [SexualAssault] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions)
└─ [SexualAssault] is false → not realised
Recursion / re-entry notes
No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.
Circularity check
• [SexualAssault] depends on [Circ1], [Circ4], [ConditionCause], [Circ2], [ThirdPartyConduct], [Conduct], [Para1], [Circ3], [Circ5], [Para2Circumstances], [Para2] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [SexualAssault]. No definitional cycle.
• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.
• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.
Questionnaire
| # | Cascade | Variable | Question / prompt | Input |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Session | {Actor} | Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.? | Reference |
| Q2 | Session | {AgainstRecognisableWill} | Element/Datum: the act is against the recognisable will of {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q3 | Session | {Coerced} | Element/Datum: {Actor} has coerced {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q4 | Session | {ConsentObtained} | Element/Datum: {Actor} has obtained the consent of {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q5 | Session | {Directs} | Element/Datum: {Actor} directs {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q6 | Session | {Exploits} | Element/Datum: {Actor} takes advantage of the circumstance.? | Boolean |
| Q7 | Session | {HasVictimPerformOnActor} | Element/Datum: {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}.? | Boolean |
| Q8 | Session | {IntoPerforming} | Element/Datum: into performing the act.? | Boolean |
| Q9 | Session | {IntoTolerating} | Element/Datum: into tolerating the act.? | Boolean |
| Q10 | Session | {MentalCondition} | Element/Datum: {Person}'s mental condition.? | Boolean |
| Q11 | Session | {MomentOfSurprise} | Element/Datum: a moment of surprise obtains.? | Boolean |
| Q12 | Session | {Performs} | Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act on {Person}.? | Boolean |
| Q13 | Session | {Person} | Element/Datum: the other person (the victim).? | Party |
| Q14 | Session | {PhysicalCondition} | Element/Datum: {Person}'s physical condition.? | Boolean |
| Q15 | Session | {RestrictedInExpressing} | Element/Datum: {Person} is restricted in expressing their will.? | Boolean |
| Q16 | Session | {RestrictedInForming} | Element/Datum: {Person} is restricted in forming their will.? | Boolean |
| Q17 | Session | {Serious} | Element/Datum: serious.? | Boolean |
| Q18 | Session | {Significantly} | Element/Datum: significantly.? | Boolean |
| Q19 | Session | {SituationOfRisk} | Element/Datum: a situation obtains in which {Person} faces a risk of harm upon resistance.? | Boolean |
| Q20 | Session | {ThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: a third party.? | Party |
| Q21 | Session | {ThreatensWithHarm} | Element/Datum: {Actor} threatens {Person} with harm.? | Boolean |
| Q22 | Session | {UnableToExpressContraryWill} | Element/Datum: {Person} is unable to express a contrary will.? | Boolean |
| Q23 | Session | {UnableToFormContraryWill} | Element/Datum: {Person} is unable to form a contrary will.? | Boolean |
| Q24 | Session | {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
| Q25 | Session | {VictimToleratesByThirdPerson} | Element/Datum: {Person} tolerates the act by a {ThirdPerson}.? | Boolean |
Flags
Scope Paragraph 1, the basic offence against the recognisable will; paragraph 2, the five exploitation and coercion circumstances. Paragraphs 3 to 9 (attempt, every aggravation including the rape definition in (6), and all sentencing ranges) struck entirely per the marked-up source as grading and consequences.
Translation note The draft English layer of (1) and (2) renders “von ihr vornehmen lässt” as “causes them to be performed (on that person)”, which misreads the German: the modality is having the acts performed by the person on the actor. The source column carries the English as published; the German governs; the markup binds the published words to {HasVictimPerformOnActor}, which carries the German reading.
Conduct chapeau reused Paragraph 2 repeats paragraph 1's three modalities verbatim; [Conduct] ({Performs}, {HasVictimPerformOnActor}, {Directs} over the third-party pair) is consumed by both paragraphs (one variable per Merkmal).
The five circumstances [Circ1] to [Circ5], disjoined in [Para2Circumstances]. {Exploits} is the shared verb of circumstances 1 to 4, each discriminated by its own object: the will-incapacity pair, the restriction complex, {MomentOfSurprise}, the risk situation. Circumstance 5 is {Coerced} over the coordinated objects {IntoPerforming} and {IntoTolerating}, by {ThreatensWithHarm} (rules 1, 2, 10).
Qualifiers as inline variables {Significantly} qualifies the restriction in circumstance 2; {Serious} qualifies the harm in circumstances 4 and 5 (the same statutory term, “empfindliches Übel”, one variable), following the §171 {Grossly} and {Significant} pattern (rule 4).
Proviso as a negative condition (rule 8) “unless the offender has obtained the consent of that person” in circumstance 2 is not encoded inside the leg; [Circ2] carries {ConsentObtained} is false, and the markup binds the proviso words to [Circ2] with the {ConsentObtained} block inside.
Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.
Treatment §177 is Human-awareness-tagged. The objective elements of (1) and (2) are encoded; recognisability of the contrary will, exploitation in fact and coercion in fact are heavily evaluative at the margin and the verdict escalates to a human in application.