SynapseLayer

Operome · StGB consolidated, half two (§180 to §184l)
Strafgesetzbuch · Thirteenth Title · offences against sexual self-determination · second consolidated document

{Variable} input · [Computable] act / derived · «if … end if» condition · struck excluded · word-for-word dissection; the law is reconstructable from the substrate

§180 · Promotion of sexual acts of minors

PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors · provenance StGB 180 · (1) s.1 and (2) encoded; proviso and attempt struck

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) Any person who facilitates sexual acts of a person under the age of sixteen on or in front of a third party, or sexual acts of a third party on a person under the age of sixteen, 1. through their mediation, or 2. by granting or procuring an opportunity, shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. Sentence 1, No. 2 shall not apply if the person acting is the person entitled to care for the person; this shall not apply if the person entitled to care grossly violates their duty of care by facilitating such acts. (2) Any person who instructs a person under the age of eighteen to perform sexual acts for remuneration on or in front of a third party, or to allow a third party to perform such acts on them, or who facilitates such acts through their mediation, shall be punished with imprisonment for up to five years or a fine. (3) In the case referred to in paragraph 2, an attempt is punishable.

«if PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors is true»(1) {Actor} who «if {Facilitates} is true»facilitates «if {MinorPerformsOnThird} is true»[SexualActs] of {Person} «if [PersonUnder16] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit16} «end if» on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird} is true»or in front of a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {ThirdPerformsOnMinor} is true»or [SexualActs] of a {ThirdPerson} on {Person} «if [PersonUnder16] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit16} «end if» «end if», 1. «if {Mediation} is true»through their mediation «end if», or 2. by «if {GrantsOpportunity} is true»granting «end if» «if {ProcuresOpportunity} is true»or procuring «end if» an opportunity «end if», shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. Sentence 1, No. 2 shall not apply if the person acting is the person entitled to care for the person; this shall not apply if the person entitled to care grossly violates their duty of care by facilitating such acts. (2) {Actor} who «if {Instructs} is true»instructs {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» to «if {VictimPerformsOnThird} is true»perform [SexualActs] {ForRemuneration} for remuneration on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird} is true»or in front of a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {VictimAllowsThirdToPerform} is true»or to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform such acts on {Person} «end if» «end if», or who «if {Facilitates} is true»facilitates such acts «if {Mediation} is true»through their mediation «end if» «end if», shall be punished with imprisonment for up to five years or a fine. (3) In the case referred to in paragraph 2, an attempt is punishable.«end if»

Annexes

Computables

[PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18 [Para2Acts] = VictimPerformsOnThird is true or VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird is true or VictimAllowsThirdToPerform is true [Para2] = SexualActs is true and PersonUnder18 is true and ((Instructs is true and ForRemuneration is true and Para2Acts is true) or (Facilitates is true and Mediation is true)) [FacilitatedActs] = MinorPerformsOnThird is true or MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird is true or ThirdPerformsOnMinor is true [FacilitationMeans] = Mediation is true or GrantsOpportunity is true or ProcuresOpportunity is true [PersonUnder16] = PersonAge < AgeLimit16 [Para1] = SexualActs is true and PersonUnder16 is true and Facilitates is true and FacilitatedActs is true and FacilitationMeans is true [PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true

[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
PSM-R01	act	Actor		Facilitates is true
PSM-R02	condition	None		MinorPerformsOnThird is true
PSM-R03	condition	None		MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird is true
PSM-R04	condition	None		ThirdPerformsOnMinor is true
PSM-R05	act	Actor		Mediation is true
PSM-R06	act	Actor		GrantsOpportunity is true
PSM-R07	act	Actor		ProcuresOpportunity is true
PSM-R08	act	Actor		Instructs is true
PSM-R09	condition	None		ForRemuneration is true
PSM-R10	condition	None		VictimPerformsOnThird is true
PSM-R11	condition	None		VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird is true
PSM-R12	condition	None		VictimAllowsThirdToPerform is true
PSM-R90	condition	None	the person is under the age of sixteen	PersonUnder16 is true
PSM-R91	condition	None	the person is under the age of eighteen	PersonUnder18 is true
PSM-R92	condition	None	the act is a sexual act within section 184h	SexualActs is true
PSM-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
Any person who	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
{Actor} facilitates the acts	Merkmal	{Facilitates}	PSM-R01	is true
{Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}	Merkmal	{MinorPerformsOnThird}	PSM-R02	is true
{Person} performs the act in front of a {ThirdPerson}	Merkmal	{MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird}	PSM-R03	is true
a {ThirdPerson} performs the act on {Person}	Merkmal	{ThirdPerformsOnMinor}	PSM-R04	is true
through {Actor}'s mediation	Merkmal	{Mediation}	PSM-R05	is true
{Actor} grants an opportunity	Merkmal	{GrantsOpportunity}	PSM-R06	is true
{Actor} procures an opportunity	Merkmal	{ProcuresOpportunity}	PSM-R07	is true
{Actor} instructs {Person}	Merkmal	{Instructs}	PSM-R08	is true
for remuneration	Merkmal	{ForRemuneration}	PSM-R09	is true
{Person} is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson}	Merkmal	{VictimPerformsOnThird}	PSM-R10	is true
{Person} is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson}	Merkmal	{VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird}	PSM-R11	is true
{Person} is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}	Merkmal	{VictimAllowsThirdToPerform}	PSM-R12	is true
carer proviso (1) sentences 2-3; attempt (3)	carve-out / attempt	— excluded —	—	struck

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{AgeLimit16}	Number	–	Session	sixteen years
{AgeLimit18}	Number	–	Session	eighteen years
{Facilitates}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} facilitates the acts
{ForRemuneration}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for remuneration
{GrantsOpportunity}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} grants an opportunity
{Instructs}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} instructs {Person}
{Mediation}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	through {Actor}'s mediation
{MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} performs the act in front of a {ThirdPerson}
{MinorPerformsOnThird}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}
{Person}	Party	–	Session	the minor (the protected person)
{PersonAge}	Number	–	Session	the age of {Person} in years
{ProcuresOpportunity}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} procures an opportunity
{ThirdPerformsOnMinor}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	a {ThirdPerson} performs the act on {Person}
{ThirdPerson}	Party	–	Session	a third party
{VictimAllowsThirdToPerform}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}
{VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson}
{VictimPerformsOnThird}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson}

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit16) and {Actor} facilitates the acts and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} performs the act in front of a {ThirdPerson} or a {ThirdPerson} performs the act on {Person}) and (through {Actor}'s mediation or {Actor} grants an opportunity or {Actor} procures an opportunity)) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and (({Actor} instructs {Person} and for remuneration and ({Person} is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person})) or ({Actor} facilitates the acts and through {Actor}'s mediation))).

Assembled only from the variable surface forms (including the actor) and the computable structure carried in the XSD, not from the source column. It should read as the offence. This is the recoverability test: the law is reverse-derivable from the substrate.

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[PersonUnder18]	PersonAge, AgeLimit18	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para2Acts]	VictimPerformsOnThird, VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird, VictimAllowsThirdToPerform	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para2]	SexualActs, PersonUnder18, Instructs, ForRemuneration, Para2Acts, Facilitates, Mediation	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[FacilitatedActs]	MinorPerformsOnThird, MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird, ThirdPerformsOnMinor	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[FacilitationMeans]	Mediation, GrantsOpportunity, ProcuresOpportunity	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[PersonUnder16]	PersonAge, AgeLimit16	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para1]	SexualActs, PersonUnder16, Facilitates, FacilitatedActs, FacilitationMeans	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors]	Para1, Para2	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (PSM-P0)	[PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {AgeLimit16} ├─ {AgeLimit18} ├─ {Facilitates} ├─ {ForRemuneration} ├─ {GrantsOpportunity} ├─ {Instructs} ├─ {Mediation} ├─ {MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird} ├─ {MinorPerformsOnThird} ├─ {Person} ├─ {PersonAge} ├─ {ProcuresOpportunity} ├─ {ThirdPerformsOnMinor} ├─ {ThirdPerson} ├─ {VictimAllowsThirdToPerform} ├─ {VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird} ├─ {VictimPerformsOnThird} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18 ├─ [Para2Acts] = VictimPerformsOnThird is true or VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird is true or VictimAllowsThirdToPerform is true ├─ [Para2] = SexualActs is true and PersonUnder18 is true and ((Instructs is true and ForRemuneration is true and Para2Acts is true) or (Facilitates is true and Mediation is true)) ├─ [FacilitatedActs] = MinorPerformsOnThird is true or MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird is true or ThirdPerformsOnMinor is true ├─ [FacilitationMeans] = Mediation is true or GrantsOpportunity is true or ProcuresOpportunity is true ├─ [PersonUnder16] = PersonAge < AgeLimit16 ├─ [Para1] = SexualActs is true and PersonUnder16 is true and Facilitates is true and FacilitatedActs is true and FacilitationMeans is true ├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h) ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

No runtime re-entry. The operome is a single forward evaluation: inputs → act computable(s) → Tatbestand composite → prohibition verdict. Attempt and preparation, where the section provides for them, are separate operomes, not re-entries.

Circularity check

• [PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors] depends on [PersonUnder18], [Para2Acts], [Para2], [FacilitatedActs], [FacilitationMeans], [PersonUnder16], [Para1] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [PromotionOfSexualActsOfMinors]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{AgeLimit16}	Element/Datum: sixteen years.?	Number
Q3	Session	{AgeLimit18}	Element/Datum: eighteen years.?	Number
Q4	Session	{Facilitates}	Element/Datum: {Actor} facilitates the acts.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{ForRemuneration}	Element/Datum: for remuneration.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{GrantsOpportunity}	Element/Datum: {Actor} grants an opportunity.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{Instructs}	Element/Datum: {Actor} instructs {Person}.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{Mediation}	Element/Datum: through {Actor}'s mediation.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{MinorPerformsInFrontOfThird}	Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act in front of a {ThirdPerson}.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{MinorPerformsOnThird}	Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}.?	Boolean
Q11	Session	{Person}	Element/Datum: the minor (the protected person).?	Party
Q12	Session	{PersonAge}	Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.?	Number
Q13	Session	{ProcuresOpportunity}	Element/Datum: {Actor} procures an opportunity.?	Boolean
Q14	Session	{ThirdPerformsOnMinor}	Element/Datum: a {ThirdPerson} performs the act on {Person}.?	Boolean
Q15	Session	{ThirdPerson}	Element/Datum: a third party.?	Party
Q16	Session	{VictimAllowsThirdToPerform}	Element/Datum: {Person} is to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}.?	Boolean
Q17	Session	{VictimPerformsInFrontOfThird}	Element/Datum: {Person} is to perform the act in front of a {ThirdPerson}.?	Boolean
Q18	Session	{VictimPerformsOnThird}	Element/Datum: {Person} is to perform the act on a {ThirdPerson}.?	Boolean

Flags

Scope Paragraph 1 sentence 1, facilitating the acts of or on a person under sixteen by mediation or by granting or procuring an opportunity; paragraph 2, instructing a person under eighteen to perform remunerated acts involving a third party, or facilitating such acts by mediation. The carer proviso (paragraph 1, sentences 2 and 3) and the attempt in (3) struck per the marked-up source.

Translation note The draft English layer inverts the offence: it makes {Actor} the performer (“performs sexual acts on a person under the age of sixteen”), where the German (“Vorschub leistet”) makes {Actor} the facilitator of acts performed by or on the minor. The source column follows the German; the actor's conduct is {Facilitates} by [FacilitationMeans], over the three coordinated act objects in [FacilitatedActs].

Carer proviso struck The statutory carve-out for the person entitled to care, and its gross-violation counter-exception, were struck whole in the markup and are not encoded; the strike is recorded here so the omission is deliberate, not an oversight.

Two age thresholds [PersonUnder16] governs paragraph 1, [PersonUnder18] paragraph 2; limits as named-number variables, comparison in the computable.

Facilitation reused {Facilitates} and {Mediation} carry the same Merkmal in both paragraphs; paragraph 2's second modality is their conjunction.

Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.

Treatment §180 is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements per the §174 precedent.

§180a · Exploitation of prostitutes

ExploitationOfProstitutes · provenance StGB 180a · full section (1)-(2)

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) Any person who, on a commercial basis, maintains or manages an establishment in which persons engage in prostitution and in which they are kept in a state of personal or economic dependence shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (2) The same penalty shall apply to anyone who 1. provides a person under the age of eighteen with accommodation, commercial lodging or a commercial place of residence for the purpose of engaging in prostitution, or 2. encourages or exploits another person to whom they provide accommodation for the purpose of prostitution.

«if ExploitationOfProstitutes is true»(1) {Actor} who, {Commercially} on a commercial basis, «if {Maintains} is true»maintains «end if» «if {Manages} is true»or manages «end if» an {Establishment} «if {EngageInProstitution} is true»in which persons engage in prostitution «end if» and «if {KeptInDependence} is true»in which they are kept in a state of «if {PersonalDependence} is true»personal «end if» «if {EconomicDependence} is true»or economic «end if» dependence «end if», shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (2) The same penalty shall apply to {Actor} who 1. «if {Provides} is true»provides {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» with «if {Dwelling} is true»accommodation «end if» «if {CommercialLodging} is true», commercial lodging «end if» «if {CommercialResidence} is true»or a commercial place of residence «end if» «if {ForProstitution} is true»for the purpose of engaging in prostitution «end if» «end if», or 2. «if {Encourages} is true»encourages «end if» «if {Exploits} is true»or exploits «end if» {Person} «if {Provides} is true»to whom they provide «if {Dwelling} is true»accommodation «end if» «if {ForProstitution} is true»for the purpose of prostitution «end if» «end if». «end if»

Annexes

Computables

[PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18 [AccommodationType] = Dwelling is true or CommercialLodging is true or CommercialResidence is true [Leg1] = PersonUnder18 is true and Provides is true and AccommodationType is true and ForProstitution is true [Leg2] = Provides is true and Dwelling is true and ForProstitution is true and (Encourages is true or Exploits is true) [Para2] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true [DependenceType] = PersonalDependence is true or EconomicDependence is true [Para1] = Commercially is true and (Maintains is true or Manages is true) and EngageInProstitution is true and KeptInDependence is true and DependenceType is true [ExploitationOfProstitutes] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
EOP-R01	condition	None		Commercially is true
EOP-R02	act	Actor		Maintains is true
EOP-R03	act	Actor		Manages is true
EOP-R04	condition	None		EngageInProstitution is true
EOP-R05	condition	None		KeptInDependence is true
EOP-R06	condition	None		PersonalDependence is true
EOP-R07	condition	None		EconomicDependence is true
EOP-R08	act	Actor		Provides is true
EOP-R09	condition	None		Dwelling is true
EOP-R10	condition	None		CommercialLodging is true
EOP-R11	condition	None		CommercialResidence is true
EOP-R12	condition	None		ForProstitution is true
EOP-R13	act	Actor		Encourages is true
EOP-R14	act	Actor		Exploits is true
EOP-R90	condition	None	the person is under the age of eighteen	PersonUnder18 is true
EOP-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not ExploitationOfProstitutes

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
Any person who	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
on a commercial basis	Merkmal	{Commercially}	EOP-R01	is true
{Actor} maintains the {Establishment}	Merkmal	{Maintains}	EOP-R02	is true
{Actor} manages the {Establishment}	Merkmal	{Manages}	EOP-R03	is true
persons engage in prostitution in the {Establishment}	Merkmal	{EngageInProstitution}	EOP-R04	is true
those persons are kept in a state of dependence in the {Establishment}	Merkmal	{KeptInDependence}	EOP-R05	is true
personal dependence	Merkmal	{PersonalDependence}	EOP-R06	is true
economic dependence	Merkmal	{EconomicDependence}	EOP-R07	is true
{Actor} provides {Person}	Merkmal	{Provides}	EOP-R08	is true
accommodation	Merkmal	{Dwelling}	EOP-R09	is true
commercial lodging	Merkmal	{CommercialLodging}	EOP-R10	is true
a commercial place of residence	Merkmal	{CommercialResidence}	EOP-R11	is true
for the purpose of engaging in prostitution	Merkmal	{ForProstitution}	EOP-R12	is true
{Actor} encourages {Person} into prostitution	Merkmal	{Encourages}	EOP-R13	is true
{Actor} exploits {Person}	Merkmal	{Exploits}	EOP-R14	is true

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{AgeLimit18}	Number	–	Session	eighteen years
{CommercialLodging}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	commercial lodging
{CommercialResidence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	a commercial place of residence
{Commercially}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	on a commercial basis
{Dwelling}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	accommodation
{EconomicDependence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	economic dependence
{Encourages}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} encourages {Person} into prostitution
{EngageInProstitution}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	persons engage in prostitution in the {Establishment}
{Establishment}	Party	–	Session	an establishment
{Exploits}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} exploits {Person}
{ForProstitution}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of engaging in prostitution
{KeptInDependence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	those persons are kept in a state of dependence in the {Establishment}
{Maintains}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} maintains the {Establishment}
{Manages}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} manages the {Establishment}
{Person}	Party	–	Session	the other person
{PersonAge}	Number	–	Session	the age of {Person} in years
{PersonalDependence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	personal dependence
{Provides}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} provides {Person}

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: (on a commercial basis and ({Actor} maintains the {Establishment} or {Actor} manages the {Establishment}) and persons engage in prostitution in the {Establishment} and those persons are kept in a state of dependence in the {Establishment} and (personal dependence or economic dependence)) or (((PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and {Actor} provides {Person} and (accommodation or commercial lodging or a commercial place of residence) and for the purpose of engaging in prostitution) or ({Actor} provides {Person} and accommodation and for the purpose of engaging in prostitution and ({Actor} encourages {Person} into prostitution or {Actor} exploits {Person}))).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[PersonUnder18]	PersonAge, AgeLimit18	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[AccommodationType]	Dwelling, CommercialLodging, CommercialResidence	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg1]	PersonUnder18, Provides, AccommodationType, ForProstitution	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2]	Provides, Dwelling, ForProstitution, Encourages, Exploits	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para2]	Leg1, Leg2	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DependenceType]	PersonalDependence, EconomicDependence	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para1]	Commercially, Maintains, Manages, EngageInProstitution, KeptInDependence, DependenceType	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ExploitationOfProstitutes]	Para1, Para2	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (EOP-P0)	[ExploitationOfProstitutes]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {AgeLimit18} ├─ {CommercialLodging} ├─ {CommercialResidence} ├─ {Commercially} ├─ {Dwelling} ├─ {EconomicDependence} ├─ {Encourages} ├─ {EngageInProstitution} ├─ {Establishment} ├─ {Exploits} ├─ {ForProstitution} ├─ {KeptInDependence} ├─ {Maintains} ├─ {Manages} ├─ {Person} ├─ {PersonAge} ├─ {PersonalDependence} ├─ {Provides} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18 ├─ [AccommodationType] = Dwelling is true or CommercialLodging is true or CommercialResidence is true ├─ [Leg1] = PersonUnder18 is true and Provides is true and AccommodationType is true and ForProstitution is true ├─ [Leg2] = Provides is true and Dwelling is true and ForProstitution is true and (Encourages is true or Exploits is true) ├─ [Para2] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true ├─ [DependenceType] = PersonalDependence is true or EconomicDependence is true ├─ [Para1] = Commercially is true and (Maintains is true or Manages is true) and EngageInProstitution is true and KeptInDependence is true and DependenceType is true ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [ExploitationOfProstitutes] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [ExploitationOfProstitutes] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [ExploitationOfProstitutes] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [ExploitationOfProstitutes] depends on [PersonUnder18], [AccommodationType], [Leg1], [Leg2], [Para2], [DependenceType], [Para1]; none refer back to [ExploitationOfProstitutes]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{AgeLimit18}	Element/Datum: eighteen years.?	Number
Q3	Session	{CommercialLodging}	Element/Datum: commercial lodging.?	Boolean
Q4	Session	{CommercialResidence}	Element/Datum: a commercial place of residence.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{Commercially}	Element/Datum: on a commercial basis.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{Dwelling}	Element/Datum: accommodation.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{EconomicDependence}	Element/Datum: economic dependence.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{Encourages}	Element/Datum: {Actor} encourages {Person} into prostitution.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{EngageInProstitution}	Element/Datum: persons engage in prostitution in the {Establishment}.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{Establishment}	Element/Datum: an establishment.?	Party
Q11	Session	{Exploits}	Element/Datum: {Actor} exploits {Person}.?	Boolean
Q12	Session	{ForProstitution}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of engaging in prostitution.?	Boolean
Q13	Session	{KeptInDependence}	Element/Datum: those persons are kept in a state of dependence in the {Establishment}.?	Boolean
Q14	Session	{Maintains}	Element/Datum: {Actor} maintains the {Establishment}.?	Boolean
Q15	Session	{Manages}	Element/Datum: {Actor} manages the {Establishment}.?	Boolean
Q16	Session	{Person}	Element/Datum: the other person.?	Party
Q17	Session	{PersonAge}	Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.?	Number
Q18	Session	{PersonalDependence}	Element/Datum: personal dependence.?	Boolean
Q19	Session	{Provides}	Element/Datum: {Actor} provides {Person}.?	Boolean

Flags

Whole section Paragraph 1, the commercial establishment kept in dependence; paragraph 2, the under-eighteen accommodation variant and the encourage-or-exploit variant for persons housed for prostitution. No attempt provision; nothing further struck beyond the penalties.

Ten-rule build {KeptInDependence} spans the coordinated dependence objects {PersonalDependence} and {EconomicDependence} ([DependenceType]); {Provides} spans the three coordinated accommodation objects ([AccommodationType]); {Commercially} is an inline qualifier variable (rules 1, 2, 4, 10).

Accommodation reused {Provides}, {Dwelling} and {ForProstitution} carry the same Merkmal in both legs of paragraph 2; leg 2 narrows to the dwelling alternative, as the German does (Wohnung).

No sexual-act term §180a turns on prostitution and dependence, not on the §184h term; no [SexualActs] reference arises.

Strikes The penalty in (1) and “The same penalty shall apply” in (2) (“Ebenso wird bestraft”) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §180a is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements; exploitation in fact and the state of dependence are evaluative at the margin and escalate in application.

§181a · Pimping

Pimping · provenance StGB 181a · (1)-(2) encoded, (3) struck

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) A person shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of six months to five years if they 1. exploits another person who is engaged in prostitution, or 2. for the sake of financial gain, supervises another person in the practice of prostitution, determines the place, time, extent or other circumstances of the practice of prostitution, or takes measures intended to prevent them from giving up prostitution, and, in that regard, maintains a relationship with that person that goes beyond the individual instance. (2) A person who impairs the personal or economic independence of another person by commercially promoting that person’s engagement in prostitution through the arrangement of sexual intercourse, and in doing so maintains a relationship with that person that extends beyond the individual instance, shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or a fine. (3) In accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2, a person who commits the acts referred to in paragraph 1(1) and (2) or the promotion referred to in paragraph 2 against their spouse or civil partner shall also be punished.

«if Pimping is true»(1) {Actor} shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of six months to five years if they 1. «if {Exploits} is true»exploits {Person} «end if» «if {EngagesInProstitution} is true»who is engaged in prostitution «end if», or 2. {ForFinancialGain} for the sake of financial gain, «if {Supervises} is true»supervises {Person} in the practice of prostitution «end if», «if {Determines} is true»determines the «if {Place} is true»place «end if» «if {TimeOfPractice} is true», time «end if» «if {Extent} is true», extent «end if» «if {OtherCircumstances} is true»or other circumstances «end if» of the practice of prostitution «end if», or «if {TakesMeasures} is true»takes measures intended to prevent them from giving up prostitution «end if», and, in that regard, «if {MaintainsRelationship} is true»maintains a relationship with {Person} «end if» «if {BeyondIndividualInstance} is true»that goes beyond the individual instance «end if». (2) {Actor} who «if {Impairs} is true»impairs the «if {PersonalIndependence} is true»personal «end if» «if {EconomicIndependence} is true»or economic «end if» independence of {Person} «end if» by {Commercially} commercially «if {Promotes} is true»promoting that person's engagement in prostitution «end if» «if {ArrangementOfIntercourse} is true»through the arrangement of sexual intercourse «end if», and in doing so «if {MaintainsRelationship} is true»maintains a relationship with {Person} «end if» «if {BeyondIndividualInstance} is true»that extends beyond the individual instance «end if», shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or a fine. (3) In accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2, a person who commits the acts referred to in paragraph 1(1) and (2) or the promotion referred to in paragraph 2 against their spouse or civil partner shall also be punished.«end if»

Annexes

Computables

[ImpairedIndependence] = PersonalIndependence is true or EconomicIndependence is true [RelationshipTail] = MaintainsRelationship is true and BeyondIndividualInstance is true [Para2] = Impairs is true and ImpairedIndependence is true and Commercially is true and Promotes is true and ArrangementOfIntercourse is true and RelationshipTail is true [Leg1] = Exploits is true and EngagesInProstitution is true [DeterminedCircumstances] = Place is true or TimeOfPractice is true or Extent is true or OtherCircumstances is true [Leg2Conduct] = Supervises is true or (Determines is true and DeterminedCircumstances is true) or TakesMeasures is true [Leg2] = ForFinancialGain is true and Leg2Conduct is true [Para1] = (Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true) and RelationshipTail is true [Pimping] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
PIM-R01	condition	None		ForFinancialGain is true
PIM-R02	act	Actor		Exploits is true
PIM-R03	condition	None		EngagesInProstitution is true
PIM-R04	act	Actor		Supervises is true
PIM-R05	act	Actor		Determines is true
PIM-R06	condition	None		Place is true
PIM-R07	condition	None		TimeOfPractice is true
PIM-R08	condition	None		Extent is true
PIM-R09	condition	None		OtherCircumstances is true
PIM-R10	act	Actor		TakesMeasures is true
PIM-R11	act	Actor		MaintainsRelationship is true
PIM-R12	condition	None		BeyondIndividualInstance is true
PIM-R13	act	Actor		Impairs is true
PIM-R14	condition	None		PersonalIndependence is true
PIM-R15	condition	None		EconomicIndependence is true
PIM-R16	condition	None		Commercially is true
PIM-R17	act	Actor		Promotes is true
PIM-R18	condition	None		ArrangementOfIntercourse is true
PIM-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not Pimping

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
A person ... if they	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
for the sake of financial gain	Merkmal	{ForFinancialGain}	PIM-R01	is true
{Actor} exploits {Person}	Merkmal	{Exploits}	PIM-R02	is true
{Person} is engaged in prostitution	Merkmal	{EngagesInProstitution}	PIM-R03	is true
{Actor} supervises {Person} in the practice of prostitution	Merkmal	{Supervises}	PIM-R04	is true
{Actor} determines circumstances of the practice of prostitution	Merkmal	{Determines}	PIM-R05	is true
the place	Merkmal	{Place}	PIM-R06	is true
the time	Merkmal	{TimeOfPractice}	PIM-R07	is true
the extent	Merkmal	{Extent}	PIM-R08	is true
other circumstances	Merkmal	{OtherCircumstances}	PIM-R09	is true
{Actor} takes measures intended to prevent {Person} from giving up prostitution	Merkmal	{TakesMeasures}	PIM-R10	is true
{Actor} maintains a relationship with {Person} in that regard	Merkmal	{MaintainsRelationship}	PIM-R11	is true
the relationship goes beyond the individual instance	Merkmal	{BeyondIndividualInstance}	PIM-R12	is true
{Actor} impairs the independence of {Person}	Merkmal	{Impairs}	PIM-R13	is true
the personal independence of {Person}	Merkmal	{PersonalIndependence}	PIM-R14	is true
the economic independence of {Person}	Merkmal	{EconomicIndependence}	PIM-R15	is true
on a commercial basis	Merkmal	{Commercially}	PIM-R16	is true
{Actor} promotes the engagement of {Person} in prostitution	Merkmal	{Promotes}	PIM-R17	is true
through the arrangement of sexual intercourse	Merkmal	{ArrangementOfIntercourse}	PIM-R18	is true
(3) spouse and civil-partner extension	extension	— excluded —	—	struck

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{ArrangementOfIntercourse}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	through the arrangement of sexual intercourse
{BeyondIndividualInstance}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the relationship goes beyond the individual instance
{Commercially}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	on a commercial basis
{Determines}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} determines circumstances of the practice of prostitution
{EconomicIndependence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the economic independence of {Person}
{EngagesInProstitution}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is engaged in prostitution
{Exploits}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} exploits {Person}
{Extent}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the extent
{ForFinancialGain}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the sake of financial gain
{Impairs}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} impairs the independence of {Person}
{MaintainsRelationship}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} maintains a relationship with {Person} in that regard
{OtherCircumstances}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	other circumstances
{Person}	Party	–	Session	the other person
{PersonalIndependence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the personal independence of {Person}
{Place}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the place
{Promotes}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} promotes the engagement of {Person} in prostitution
{Supervises}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} supervises {Person} in the practice of prostitution
{TakesMeasures}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} takes measures intended to prevent {Person} from giving up prostitution
{TimeOfPractice}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the time

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: ((({Actor} exploits {Person} and {Person} is engaged in prostitution) or (for the sake of financial gain and ({Actor} supervises {Person} in the practice of prostitution or ({Actor} determines circumstances of the practice of prostitution and (the place or the time or the extent or other circumstances)) or {Actor} takes measures intended to prevent {Person} from giving up prostitution))) and ({Actor} maintains a relationship with {Person} in that regard and the relationship goes beyond the individual instance)) or ({Actor} impairs the independence of {Person} and (the personal independence of {Person} or the economic independence of {Person}) and on a commercial basis and {Actor} promotes the engagement of {Person} in prostitution and through the arrangement of sexual intercourse and ({Actor} maintains a relationship with {Person} in that regard and the relationship goes beyond the individual instance)).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[ImpairedIndependence]	PersonalIndependence, EconomicIndependence	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[RelationshipTail]	MaintainsRelationship, BeyondIndividualInstance	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para2]	Impairs, ImpairedIndependence, Commercially, Promotes, ArrangementOfIntercourse, RelationshipTail	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg1]	Exploits, EngagesInProstitution	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DeterminedCircumstances]	Place, TimeOfPractice, Extent, OtherCircumstances	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2Conduct]	Supervises, Determines, DeterminedCircumstances, TakesMeasures	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2]	ForFinancialGain, Leg2Conduct	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para1]	Leg1, Leg2, RelationshipTail	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Pimping]	Para1, Para2	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (PIM-P0)	[Pimping]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {ArrangementOfIntercourse} ├─ {BeyondIndividualInstance} ├─ {Commercially} ├─ {Determines} ├─ {EconomicIndependence} ├─ {EngagesInProstitution} ├─ {Exploits} ├─ {Extent} ├─ {ForFinancialGain} ├─ {Impairs} ├─ {MaintainsRelationship} ├─ {OtherCircumstances} ├─ {Person} ├─ {PersonalIndependence} ├─ {Place} ├─ {Promotes} ├─ {Supervises} ├─ {TakesMeasures} ├─ {TimeOfPractice} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [ImpairedIndependence] = PersonalIndependence is true or EconomicIndependence is true ├─ [RelationshipTail] = MaintainsRelationship is true and BeyondIndividualInstance is true ├─ [Para2] = Impairs is true and ImpairedIndependence is true and Commercially is true and Promotes is true and ArrangementOfIntercourse is true and RelationshipTail is true ├─ [Leg1] = Exploits is true and EngagesInProstitution is true ├─ [DeterminedCircumstances] = Place is true or TimeOfPractice is true or Extent is true or OtherCircumstances is true ├─ [Leg2Conduct] = Supervises is true or (Determines is true and DeterminedCircumstances is true) or TakesMeasures is true ├─ [Leg2] = ForFinancialGain is true and Leg2Conduct is true ├─ [Para1] = (Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true) and RelationshipTail is true ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [Pimping] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [Pimping] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [Pimping] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [Pimping] depends on [ImpairedIndependence], [RelationshipTail], [Para2], [Leg1], [DeterminedCircumstances], [Leg2Conduct], [Leg2], [Para1]; none refer back to [Pimping]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{ArrangementOfIntercourse}	Element/Datum: through the arrangement of sexual intercourse.?	Boolean
Q3	Session	{BeyondIndividualInstance}	Element/Datum: the relationship goes beyond the individual instance.?	Boolean
Q4	Session	{Commercially}	Element/Datum: on a commercial basis.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{Determines}	Element/Datum: {Actor} determines circumstances of the practice of prostitution.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{EconomicIndependence}	Element/Datum: the economic independence of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{EngagesInProstitution}	Element/Datum: {Person} is engaged in prostitution.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{Exploits}	Element/Datum: {Actor} exploits {Person}.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{Extent}	Element/Datum: the extent.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{ForFinancialGain}	Element/Datum: for the sake of financial gain.?	Boolean
Q11	Session	{Impairs}	Element/Datum: {Actor} impairs the independence of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q12	Session	{MaintainsRelationship}	Element/Datum: {Actor} maintains a relationship with {Person} in that regard.?	Boolean
Q13	Session	{OtherCircumstances}	Element/Datum: other circumstances.?	Boolean
Q14	Session	{Person}	Element/Datum: the other person.?	Party
Q15	Session	{PersonalIndependence}	Element/Datum: the personal independence of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q16	Session	{Place}	Element/Datum: the place.?	Boolean
Q17	Session	{Promotes}	Element/Datum: {Actor} promotes the engagement of {Person} in prostitution.?	Boolean
Q18	Session	{Supervises}	Element/Datum: {Actor} supervises {Person} in the practice of prostitution.?	Boolean
Q19	Session	{TakesMeasures}	Element/Datum: {Actor} takes measures intended to prevent {Person} from giving up prostitution.?	Boolean
Q20	Session	{TimeOfPractice}	Element/Datum: the time.?	Boolean

Flags

Scope Paragraph 1, the exploitation leg and the financial-gain control leg, both conditioned on the continuing relationship; paragraph 2, the impairment-by-commercial-promotion variant. Paragraph 3 (the spouse and civil-partner extension) struck whole per the marked-up source.

Ten-rule build {Determines} spans the four coordinated circumstance objects ({Place}, {TimeOfPractice}, {Extent}, {OtherCircumstances}, disjunction in [DeterminedCircumstances]); {Impairs} spans {PersonalIndependence} and {EconomicIndependence} ([ImpairedIndependence]); {ForFinancialGain} and {Commercially} are inline qualifier variables (rules 1, 2, 4, 10).

Relationship tail shared “maintains a relationship that goes beyond the individual instance” conditions both paragraph 1 legs and paragraph 2; [RelationshipTail] = {MaintainsRelationship} and {BeyondIndividualInstance} is consumed by both (one variable per Merkmal). Its attachment to both legs of paragraph 1 follows the German sentence structure, where the clause follows the numbered list.

No sexual-act term §181a turns on prostitution, control and dependence; no §184h reference arises.

Strikes The penalties in (1) and (2) and the whole of (3) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §181a is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements; exploitation and impairment in fact are evaluative at the margin and escalate in application.

§182 · Sexual abuse of juveniles

SexualAbuseOfJuveniles · provenance StGB 182 · (1)-(2) encoded, (3)-(6) struck

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) Any person who abuses a person under the age of eighteen by exploiting a situation of distress 1. performs sexual acts on them or has them perform such acts on the actor, or 2. causes them to perform sexual acts on a third party or to allow a third party to perform sexual acts on them, shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or to a fine. (2) Similarly, a person over the age of eighteen who abuses a person under the age of eighteen by performing sexual acts on them or having them performed on themselves in return for payment shall be punished. (3) A person over the age of twenty-one who abuses a person under the age of sixteen by 1. performing sexual acts on them or having them performed on themselves, or 2. causing them to perform sexual acts on a third party or to allow a third party to perform sexual acts on them, and in doing so exploits the victim's lack of capacity for sexual self-determination towards them, shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (4) An attempt is punishable. (5) In the cases referred to in paragraph 3, the offence shall be prosecuted only upon application, unless the prosecuting authority considers intervention ex officio to be necessary on account of the particular public interest in prosecution. (6) In the cases referred to in paragraphs 1 to 3, the court may refrain from imposing a penalty under these provisions if, taking into account the conduct of the person against whom the offence is directed, the wrongfulness of the act is minor.

«if SexualAbuseOfJuveniles is true»(1) {Actor} who «if {Abuses} is true»abuses «end if» {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» by «if {Exploits} is true»exploiting «if {SituationOfDistress} is true»a situation of distress «end if» «end if» 1. «if {PerformsOnVictim} is true»performs [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {HasVictimPerformOnActor} is true»or has them perform such acts on {Actor} «end if», or 2. «if {Directs} is true»causes {Person} to «if {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} is true»perform [SexualActs] on a {ThirdPerson} «end if» «if {VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} is true»or to allow a {ThirdPerson} to perform [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «end if», shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or to a fine. (2) Similarly, {Actor} «if [ActorOver18] is true»over the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» who «if {Abuses} is true»abuses «end if» {Person} «if [PersonUnder18] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit18} «end if» by «if {PerformsOnVictim} is true»performing [SexualActs] on {Person} «end if» «if {HasVictimPerformOnActor} is true»or having them performed on {Actor} «end if» «if {ForRemuneration} is true»in return for payment «end if» shall be punished. (3) A person over the age of twenty-one who abuses a person under the age of sixteen by 1. performing sexual acts on them or having them performed on themselves, or 2. causing them to perform sexual acts on a third party or to allow a third party to perform sexual acts on them, and in doing so exploits the victim's lack of capacity for sexual self-determination towards them, shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine. (4) An attempt is punishable. (5) In the cases referred to in paragraph 3, the offence shall be prosecuted only upon application, unless the prosecuting authority considers intervention ex officio to be necessary on account of the particular public interest in prosecution. (6) In the cases referred to in paragraphs 1 to 3, the court may refrain from imposing a penalty under these provisions if, taking into account the conduct of the person against whom the offence is directed, the wrongfulness of the act is minor.«end if»

Annexes

Computables

[ActorOver18] = ActorAge > AgeLimit18 [PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18 [Leg1Conduct] = PerformsOnVictim is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true [Para2] = SexualActs is true and ActorOver18 is true and PersonUnder18 is true and Abuses is true and ForRemuneration is true and Leg1Conduct is true [Leg2Conduct] = Directs is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true) [Para1] = SexualActs is true and PersonUnder18 is true and Abuses is true and Exploits is true and SituationOfDistress is true and (Leg1Conduct is true or Leg2Conduct is true) [SexualAbuseOfJuveniles] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true

[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
SAJ-R01	act	Actor		Abuses is true
SAJ-R02	act	Actor		Exploits is true
SAJ-R03	condition	None		SituationOfDistress is true
SAJ-R04	act	Actor		PerformsOnVictim is true
SAJ-R05	act	Actor		HasVictimPerformOnActor is true
SAJ-R06	act	Actor		Directs is true
SAJ-R07	condition	None		VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true
SAJ-R08	condition	None		VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true
SAJ-R09	condition	None		ForRemuneration is true
SAJ-R90	condition	None	the person is under the age of eighteen	PersonUnder18 is true
SAJ-R91	condition	None	the actor is over the age of eighteen	ActorOver18 is true
SAJ-R92	condition	None	the act is a sexual act within section 184h	SexualActs is true
SAJ-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not SexualAbuseOfJuveniles

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
Any person who	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
{Actor} abuses {Person}	Merkmal	{Abuses}	SAJ-R01	is true
{Actor} exploits	Merkmal	{Exploits}	SAJ-R02	is true
a situation of distress	Merkmal	{SituationOfDistress}	SAJ-R03	is true
{Actor} performs the act on {Person}	Merkmal	{PerformsOnVictim}	SAJ-R04	is true
{Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}	Merkmal	{HasVictimPerformOnActor}	SAJ-R05	is true
{Actor} directs {Person}	Merkmal	{Directs}	SAJ-R06	is true
{Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}	Merkmal	{VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson}	SAJ-R07	is true
{Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}	Merkmal	{VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform}	SAJ-R08	is true
in return for payment	Merkmal	{ForRemuneration}	SAJ-R09	is true
(3)-(6) over-21 variant, attempt, application requirement, judicial discretion	grading / procedure / judicial	— excluded —	—	struck

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Abuses}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} abuses {Person}
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{ActorAge}	Number	–	Session	the age of {Actor} in years
{AgeLimit18}	Number	–	Session	eighteen years
{Directs}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} directs {Person}
{Exploits}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} exploits
{ForRemuneration}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	in return for payment
{HasVictimPerformOnActor}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}
{PerformsOnVictim}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} performs the act on {Person}
{Person}	Party	–	Session	the protected person (the juvenile)
{PersonAge}	Number	–	Session	the age of {Person} in years
{SituationOfDistress}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	a situation of distress
{ThirdPerson}	Party	–	Session	a third party
{VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}
{VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and {Actor} abuses {Person} and {Actor} exploits and a situation of distress and (({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}) or ({Actor} directs {Person} and ({Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson} or {Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person})))) or (the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (ActorAge > AgeLimit18) and (PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and {Actor} abuses {Person} and in return for payment and ({Actor} performs the act on {Person} or {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor})).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[ActorOver18]	ActorAge, AgeLimit18	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[PersonUnder18]	PersonAge, AgeLimit18	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg1Conduct]	PerformsOnVictim, HasVictimPerformOnActor	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para2]	SexualActs, ActorOver18, PersonUnder18, Abuses, ForRemuneration, Leg1Conduct	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2Conduct]	Directs, VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson, VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para1]	SexualActs, PersonUnder18, Abuses, Exploits, SituationOfDistress, Leg1Conduct, Leg2Conduct	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[SexualAbuseOfJuveniles]	Para1, Para2	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (SAJ-P0)	[SexualAbuseOfJuveniles]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Abuses} ├─ {Actor} ├─ {ActorAge} ├─ {AgeLimit18} ├─ {Directs} ├─ {Exploits} ├─ {ForRemuneration} ├─ {HasVictimPerformOnActor} ├─ {PerformsOnVictim} ├─ {Person} ├─ {PersonAge} ├─ {SituationOfDistress} ├─ {ThirdPerson} ├─ {VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform} ├─ {VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [ActorOver18] = ActorAge > AgeLimit18 ├─ [PersonUnder18] = PersonAge < AgeLimit18 ├─ [Leg1Conduct] = PerformsOnVictim is true or HasVictimPerformOnActor is true ├─ [Para2] = SexualActs is true and ActorOver18 is true and PersonUnder18 is true and Abuses is true and ForRemuneration is true and Leg1Conduct is true ├─ [Leg2Conduct] = Directs is true and (VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson is true or VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform is true) ├─ [Para1] = SexualActs is true and PersonUnder18 is true and Abuses is true and Exploits is true and SituationOfDistress is true and (Leg1Conduct is true or Leg2Conduct is true) ├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h) ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [SexualAbuseOfJuveniles] = Para1 is true or Para2 is true ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [SexualAbuseOfJuveniles] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [SexualAbuseOfJuveniles] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [SexualAbuseOfJuveniles] depends on [ActorOver18], [PersonUnder18], [Leg1Conduct], [Para2], [Leg2Conduct], [Para1] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [SexualAbuseOfJuveniles]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Abuses}	Element/Datum: {Actor} abuses {Person}.?	Boolean
Q2	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q3	Session	{ActorAge}	Element/Datum: the age of {Actor} in years.?	Number
Q4	Session	{AgeLimit18}	Element/Datum: eighteen years.?	Number
Q5	Session	{Directs}	Element/Datum: {Actor} directs {Person}.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{Exploits}	Element/Datum: {Actor} exploits.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{ForRemuneration}	Element/Datum: in return for payment.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{HasVictimPerformOnActor}	Element/Datum: {Actor} has {Person} perform the act on {Actor}.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{PerformsOnVictim}	Element/Datum: {Actor} performs the act on {Person}.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{Person}	Element/Datum: the protected person (the juvenile).?	Party
Q11	Session	{PersonAge}	Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.?	Number
Q12	Session	{SituationOfDistress}	Element/Datum: a situation of distress.?	Boolean
Q13	Session	{ThirdPerson}	Element/Datum: a third party.?	Party
Q14	Session	{VictimAllowsThirdPersonToPerform}	Element/Datum: {Person} allows a {ThirdPerson} to perform the act on {Person}.?	Boolean
Q15	Session	{VictimPerformsOnThirdPerson}	Element/Datum: {Person} performs the act on a {ThirdPerson}.?	Boolean

Flags

Scope Paragraph 1, abuse of a person under eighteen by exploiting a situation of distress, with the direct and third-party conduct legs; paragraph 2, the over-eighteen remunerated variant. Paragraphs 3 to 6 (the over-twenty-one capacity variant, attempt, the application requirement and the judicial discretion) struck whole per the marked-up source.

Translation note The draft English layer of (1) leg 1 reads “or causes them to perform sexual acts on them” for “oder an sich von ihr vornehmen lässt”; as in §177, the German modality is having the acts performed by the person on the actor. The source column carries that reading and the markup binds the words to {HasVictimPerformOnActor}.

Actor age as threshold Paragraph 2 conditions on the actor's age: [ActorOver18] = {ActorAge} > {AgeLimit18}, the comparator carrying the statutory wording (“über achtzehn Jahren”) literally; whether “over” includes the eighteenth birthday itself is an interpretive question and escalates.

Conduct variables shared {Abuses}, {PerformsOnVictim} and {HasVictimPerformOnActor} carry the same Merkmal in both paragraphs (one variable per Merkmal); paragraph 2 adds {ForRemuneration} and drops the distress element.

Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) for every occurrence.

Strikes The penalty in (1), “Similarly” and “shall be punished” in (2) (“Ebenso wird ... bestraft”) and the whole of (3) to (6) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §182 is Human-awareness-tagged. Encoded on its objective elements; abuse and exploitation of distress in fact are evaluative at the margin and escalate in application.

§184a · Dissemination of violent or animal pornography

ViolentOrAnimalPornography · provenance StGB 184a · sentence 1 encoded, attempt struck

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

Any person who, in relation to pornographic material (Section 11(3)) depicting acts of violence or sexual acts involving humans and animals, 1. distributes or makes available to the public, or 2. produces, obtains, supplies, stocks, offers, advertises or undertakes to import or export such material for the purpose of using it within the meaning of point 1 or enabling another person to use it in that way. In the cases referred to in the first sentence, point 1, an attempt is punishable.

«if ViolentOrAnimalPornography is true»Shall be punished with imprisonment for up to three years or a fine {Actor} who, in relation to «if {PornographicContent} is true»pornographic material (Section 11(3)) «end if» «if {DepictsViolence} is true»depicting acts of violence «end if» «if {DepictsHumanAnimalActs} is true»or sexual acts involving humans and animals «end if», 1. «if {Disseminates} is true»distributes «end if» «if {MakesAvailableToPublic} is true»or makes available to the public «end if», or 2. «if {Produces} is true»produces «end if» «if {Obtains} is true», obtains «end if» «if {Supplies} is true», supplies «end if» «if {Stocks} is true», stocks «end if» «if {Offers} is true», offers «end if» «if {Advertises} is true», advertises «end if» «if {UndertakesToImport} is true»or undertakes to import «end if» «if {UndertakesToExport} is true»or export «end if» such {Content} «if {ForUseUnderPoint1} is true»for the purpose of using it within the meaning of point 1 «end if» «if {EnableAnotherUse} is true»or enabling another person to use it in that way «end if». In the cases referred to in the first sentence, point 1, an attempt is punishable.«end if»

Annexes

Computables

[Purpose] = ForUseUnderPoint1 is true or EnableAnotherUse is true [ContentSubject] = DepictsViolence is true or DepictsHumanAnimalActs is true [QualifyingContent] = PornographicContent is true and ContentSubject is true [TradeVerbs] = Produces is true or Obtains is true or Supplies is true or Stocks is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true or UndertakesToImport is true or UndertakesToExport is true [Leg2] = TradeVerbs is true and Purpose is true [Leg1] = Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true [ViolentOrAnimalPornography] = QualifyingContent is true and (Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true)

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
VAP-R01	condition	None		PornographicContent is true
VAP-R02	condition	None		DepictsViolence is true
VAP-R03	condition	None		DepictsHumanAnimalActs is true
VAP-R04	act	Actor		Disseminates is true
VAP-R05	act	Actor		MakesAvailableToPublic is true
VAP-R06	act	Actor		Produces is true
VAP-R07	act	Actor		Obtains is true
VAP-R08	act	Actor		Supplies is true
VAP-R09	act	Actor		Stocks is true
VAP-R10	act	Actor		Offers is true
VAP-R11	act	Actor		Advertises is true
VAP-R12	act	Actor		UndertakesToImport is true
VAP-R13	act	Actor		UndertakesToExport is true
VAP-R14	condition	None		ForUseUnderPoint1 is true
VAP-R15	condition	None		EnableAnotherUse is true
VAP-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not ViolentOrAnimalPornography

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
Any person who	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3)	Merkmal	{PornographicContent}	VAP-R01	is true
the content has acts of violence as its subject	Merkmal	{DepictsViolence}	VAP-R02	is true
the content has sexual acts of humans with animals as its subject	Merkmal	{DepictsHumanAnimalActs}	VAP-R03	is true
{Actor} distributes the {Content}	Merkmal	{Disseminates}	VAP-R04	is true
{Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public	Merkmal	{MakesAvailableToPublic}	VAP-R05	is true
{Actor} produces the {Content}	Merkmal	{Produces}	VAP-R06	is true
{Actor} obtains the {Content}	Merkmal	{Obtains}	VAP-R07	is true
{Actor} supplies the {Content}	Merkmal	{Supplies}	VAP-R08	is true
{Actor} stocks the {Content}	Merkmal	{Stocks}	VAP-R09	is true
{Actor} offers the {Content}	Merkmal	{Offers}	VAP-R10	is true
{Actor} advertises the {Content}	Merkmal	{Advertises}	VAP-R11	is true
{Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToImport}	VAP-R12	is true
{Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToExport}	VAP-R13	is true
for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1	Merkmal	{ForUseUnderPoint1}	VAP-R14	is true
for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way	Merkmal	{EnableAnotherUse}	VAP-R15	is true
attempt (sentence 2)	attempt	— excluded —	—	struck

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{Advertises}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} advertises the {Content}
{Content}	Party	–	Session	the pornographic content
{DepictsHumanAnimalActs}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has sexual acts of humans with animals as its subject
{DepictsViolence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has acts of violence as its subject
{Disseminates}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} distributes the {Content}
{EnableAnotherUse}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way
{ForUseUnderPoint1}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1
{MakesAvailableToPublic}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public
{Obtains}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} obtains the {Content}
{Offers}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} offers the {Content}
{PornographicContent}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3)
{Produces}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} produces the {Content}
{Stocks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} stocks the {Content}
{Supplies}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} supplies the {Content}
{UndertakesToExport}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}
{UndertakesToImport}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: (the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and (the content has acts of violence as its subject or the content has sexual acts of humans with animals as its subject)) and (({Actor} distributes the {Content} or {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public) or (({Actor} produces the {Content} or {Actor} obtains the {Content} or {Actor} supplies the {Content} or {Actor} stocks the {Content} or {Actor} offers the {Content} or {Actor} advertises the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to import the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}) and (for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1 or for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way))).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[Purpose]	ForUseUnderPoint1, EnableAnotherUse	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ContentSubject]	DepictsViolence, DepictsHumanAnimalActs	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[QualifyingContent]	PornographicContent, ContentSubject	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[TradeVerbs]	Produces, Obtains, Supplies, Stocks, Offers, Advertises, UndertakesToImport, UndertakesToExport	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2]	TradeVerbs, Purpose	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg1]	Disseminates, MakesAvailableToPublic	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ViolentOrAnimalPornography]	QualifyingContent, Leg1, Leg2	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (VAP-P0)	[ViolentOrAnimalPornography]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {Advertises} ├─ {Content} ├─ {DepictsHumanAnimalActs} ├─ {DepictsViolence} ├─ {Disseminates} ├─ {EnableAnotherUse} ├─ {ForUseUnderPoint1} ├─ {MakesAvailableToPublic} ├─ {Obtains} ├─ {Offers} ├─ {PornographicContent} ├─ {Produces} ├─ {Stocks} ├─ {Supplies} ├─ {UndertakesToExport} ├─ {UndertakesToImport} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [Purpose] = ForUseUnderPoint1 is true or EnableAnotherUse is true ├─ [ContentSubject] = DepictsViolence is true or DepictsHumanAnimalActs is true ├─ [QualifyingContent] = PornographicContent is true and ContentSubject is true ├─ [TradeVerbs] = Produces is true or Obtains is true or Supplies is true or Stocks is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true or UndertakesToImport is true or UndertakesToExport is true ├─ [Leg2] = TradeVerbs is true and Purpose is true ├─ [Leg1] = Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [ViolentOrAnimalPornography] = QualifyingContent is true and (Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true) ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [ViolentOrAnimalPornography] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [ViolentOrAnimalPornography] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [ViolentOrAnimalPornography] depends on [Purpose], [ContentSubject], [QualifyingContent], [TradeVerbs], [Leg2], [Leg1]; none refer back to [ViolentOrAnimalPornography]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{Advertises}	Element/Datum: {Actor} advertises the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q3	Session	{Content}	Element/Datum: the pornographic content.?	Party
Q4	Session	{DepictsHumanAnimalActs}	Element/Datum: the content has sexual acts of humans with animals as its subject.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{DepictsViolence}	Element/Datum: the content has acts of violence as its subject.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{Disseminates}	Element/Datum: {Actor} distributes the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{EnableAnotherUse}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{ForUseUnderPoint1}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{MakesAvailableToPublic}	Element/Datum: {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{Obtains}	Element/Datum: {Actor} obtains the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q11	Session	{Offers}	Element/Datum: {Actor} offers the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q12	Session	{PornographicContent}	Element/Datum: the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3).?	Boolean
Q13	Session	{Produces}	Element/Datum: {Actor} produces the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q14	Session	{Stocks}	Element/Datum: {Actor} stocks the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q15	Session	{Supplies}	Element/Datum: {Actor} supplies the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q16	Session	{UndertakesToExport}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q17	Session	{UndertakesToImport}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}.?	Boolean

Flags

Whole section Sentence 1, the dissemination leg and the trade leg over content depicting violence or human-animal sexual acts; the attempt (sentence 2) struck per the marked-up source.

Translation note The draft English layer of sentence 1 lacks the main clause (the German penalty clause carries it); the struck penalty is rendered at the head of the markup so the sentence reads, and the source column carries the text as published.

Ten-rule build The content qualification is {PornographicContent} with the coordinated subject objects {DepictsViolence} and {DepictsHumanAnimalActs} ([ContentSubject]); the eight trade verbs are each a rule, disjoined in [TradeVerbs]; “ein- oder auszuführen” splits into {UndertakesToImport} and {UndertakesToExport}; the purpose alternatives are coordinated in [Purpose] (rules 1, 2, 10).

Strikes The penalty and the attempt sentence struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §184a is Operomise-tagged: the offence turns on content properties, conduct verbs and purpose as written.

§184b · Dissemination, acquisition and possession of child pornography

ChildPornographyOffences · provenance StGB 184b · (1) s.1, (3), (5), (6) encoded · authors the child-pornography definition

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) A person shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of between six months and ten years if they 1. distributes or makes available to the public child pornography; pornographic material is considered child pornography (Section 11(3)) if it depicts: a) sexual acts by, on or in front of a person under the age of fourteen (child), b) the depiction of a child who is wholly or partially unclothed in a sexually suggestive posture, or c) the sexually provocative depiction of a child’s naked genitals or buttocks, 2. attempts to make child pornography depicting actual or realistic events accessible to another person or to procure possession thereof for that person, 3. produces child pornography depicting an actual event, or 4. produces, obtains, supplies, stocks, offers, advertises or attempts to import or export child pornography in order to use it within the meaning of point 1 or point 2 or to enable another person to use it in that way, provided that the act is not punishable under point 3. If, in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, first sentence, points 1 and 4, the child pornography does not depict actual or realistic events, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) If, in the cases referred to in the first sentence of paragraph 1, the offender acts on a commercial basis or as a member of a gang that has formed for the purpose of continuously committing such offences, and if, in the cases referred to in the first sentence of paragraph 1, points 1, 2 and 4, the material depicts actual or realistic events, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of not less than two years. (3) Any person who attempts to access child pornography that depicts actual or realistic events, or to acquire possession of such material, or who possesses such material, shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between three months and five years. (4) An attempt is punishable in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, sentence 1, points 1 and 3, and in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, sentence 2, in conjunction with sentence 1, point 1. (5) Paragraph 1, first sentence, point 2, and paragraph 3 shall not apply to acts which serve exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the following: 1. state tasks, 2. tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority, or 3. official or professional duties. (6) Paragraph 1, first sentence, points 1, 2 and 4, and the second sentence shall not apply to official acts carried out in the context of criminal investigations if 1. the act relates to child pornography that does not depict actual events and has not been produced using an image of a child or young person, and 2. clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or significantly impeded. (7) Objects to which a criminal offence under paragraph 1, first sentence, points 2 or 3, or paragraph 3 relates shall be seized. Section 74a shall apply.

«if ChildPornographyOffences is true»(1) {Actor} shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of between six months and ten years if they 1. «if {Disseminates} is true»distributes «end if» «if {MakesAvailableToPublic} is true»or makes available to the public «end if» «if [ChildPornography] is true»child pornography; pornographic material is considered child pornography if «if {PornographicContent} is true»it is pornographic content (Section 11(3)) «end if» and it depicts: a) [SexualActs] «if {ActsByChild} is true»by «end if» «if {ActsOnChild} is true», on «end if» «if {ActsInFrontOfChild} is true»or in front of «end if» {Person} «if [Child] is true»under the age of {AgeLimit14} (child) «end if», b) the depiction of «if [Child] is true»a child «end if» who is «if {WhollyUnclothed} is true»wholly «end if» «if {PartiallyUnclothed} is true»or partially «end if» unclothed «if {SuggestivePosture} is true»in a sexually suggestive posture «end if», or c) the {SexuallyProvocative} sexually provocative depiction of a child's «if {NakedGenitals} is true»naked genitals «end if» «if {NakedButtocks} is true»or buttocks «end if» «end if», 2. «if {UndertakesToMakeAccessible} is true»attempts to make «if [ChildPornography] is true»child pornography «end if» «if [RealOrRealistic] is true»depicting «if {DepictsActualEvents} is true»actual «end if» «if {DepictsRealisticEvents} is true»or realistic «end if» events «end if» accessible to another person «end if» «if {UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother} is true»or to procure possession thereof for that person «end if», 3. «if {Produces} is true»produces «end if» «if [ChildPornography] is true»child pornography «end if» «if {DepictsActualEvents} is true»depicting an actual event «end if», or 4. «if {Produces} is true»produces «end if» «if {Obtains} is true», obtains «end if» «if {Supplies} is true», supplies «end if» «if {Stocks} is true», stocks «end if» «if {Offers} is true», offers «end if» «if {Advertises} is true», advertises «end if» «if {UndertakesToImport} is true»or attempts to import «end if» «if {UndertakesToExport} is true»or export «end if» «if [ChildPornography] is true»child pornography «end if» «if {ForUseUnderPoint1} is true»in order to use it within the meaning of point 1 «end if» «if {ForUseUnderPoint2} is true»or point 2 «end if» «if {EnableAnotherUse} is true»or to enable another person to use it in that way «end if», «if {PunishableUnderPoint3} is false»provided that the act is not punishable under point 3 «end if». If, in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, first sentence, points 1 and 4, the child pornography does not depict actual or realistic events, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (2) If, in the cases referred to in the first sentence of paragraph 1, the offender acts on a commercial basis or as a member of a gang that has formed for the purpose of continuously committing such offences, and if, in the cases referred to in the first sentence of paragraph 1, points 1, 2 and 4, the material depicts actual or realistic events, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of not less than two years. (3) {Actor} who «if {UndertakesToAccess} is true»attempts to access «end if» «if [ChildPornography] is true»child pornography «end if» «if [RealOrRealistic] is true»that depicts «if {DepictsActualEvents} is true»actual «end if» «if {DepictsRealisticEvents} is true»or realistic «end if» events «end if», «if {UndertakesToAcquirePossession} is true»or to acquire possession of such material «end if», or «if {Possesses} is true»possesses such material «end if», shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of between three months and five years. (4) An attempt is punishable in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, sentence 1, points 1 and 3, and in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, sentence 2, in conjunction with sentence 1, point 1. (5) Paragraph 1, first sentence, point 2, and paragraph 3 shall not apply «if [Exemption5] is true»to acts «if {ServesExclusively} is true»which serve exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the following «end if»: 1. «if {StateTasks} is true»state tasks «end if», 2. «if {AgreementTasks} is true»tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority «end if», or 3. «if {OfficialDuties} is true»official «end if» «if {ProfessionalDuties} is true»or professional duties «end if» «end if». (6) Paragraph 1, first sentence, points 1, 2 and 4 and the second sentence shall not apply «if [Exemption6] is true»to «if {OfficialActInInvestigation} is true»official acts carried out in the context of criminal investigations «end if» if 1. the act relates to child pornography «if [NonRealContent] is true»that does not depict actual events and has not been produced using an image of «if {ProducedUsingChildImage} is true»a child «end if» «if {ProducedUsingYouthImage} is true»or young person «end if» «end if», and 2. clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be «if {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} is true»futile «end if» «if {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} is true»or significantly impeded «end if» «end if». (7) Objects to which a criminal offence under paragraph 1, first sentence, points 2 or 3, or paragraph 3 relates shall be seized. Section 74a shall apply.«end if»

Annexes

Computables

[NonRealContent] = DepictsActualEvents is false and ProducedUsingChildImage is false and ProducedUsingYouthImage is false [ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or AgreementTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true [Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14 [DepictionA] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and (ActsByChild is true or ActsOnChild is true or ActsInFrontOfChild is true) [DepictionB] = Child is true and (WhollyUnclothed is true or PartiallyUnclothed is true) and SuggestivePosture is true [DepictionC] = Child is true and SexuallyProvocative is true and (NakedGenitals is true or NakedButtocks is true) [ChildPornography] = PornographicContent is true and (DepictionA is true or DepictionB is true or DepictionC is true) [RealOrRealistic] = DepictsActualEvents is true or DepictsRealisticEvents is true [Para3] = ChildPornography is true and RealOrRealistic is true and (UndertakesToAccess is true or UndertakesToAcquirePossession is true or Possesses is true) [TradeVerbs] = Produces is true or Obtains is true or Supplies is true or Stocks is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true or UndertakesToImport is true or UndertakesToExport is true [Leg1] = ChildPornography is true and (Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true) [Leg2] = ChildPornography is true and RealOrRealistic is true and (UndertakesToMakeAccessible is true or UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother is true) [Leg3] = ChildPornography is true and DepictsActualEvents is true and Produces is true [Exemption5] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true [InvestigativeNecessity] = ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true or ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true [Exemption6] = OfficialActInInvestigation is true and NonRealContent is true and InvestigativeNecessity is true [Purpose4] = ForUseUnderPoint1 is true or ForUseUnderPoint2 is true or EnableAnotherUse is true [Leg4] = ChildPornography is true and TradeVerbs is true and Purpose4 is true and PunishableUnderPoint3 is false [ChildPornographyOffences] = (Leg1 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Leg2 is true and Exemption5 is false and Exemption6 is false) or Leg3 is true or (Leg4 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Para3 is true and Exemption5 is false)

[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
CPO-R01	condition	None		PornographicContent is true
CPO-R02	condition	None		ActsByChild is true
CPO-R03	condition	None		ActsOnChild is true
CPO-R04	condition	None		ActsInFrontOfChild is true
CPO-R05	condition	None		WhollyUnclothed is true
CPO-R06	condition	None		PartiallyUnclothed is true
CPO-R07	condition	None		SuggestivePosture is true
CPO-R08	condition	None		SexuallyProvocative is true
CPO-R09	condition	None		NakedGenitals is true
CPO-R10	condition	None		NakedButtocks is true
CPO-R11	act	Actor		Disseminates is true
CPO-R12	act	Actor		MakesAvailableToPublic is true
CPO-R13	condition	None		DepictsActualEvents is true
CPO-R14	condition	None		DepictsRealisticEvents is true
CPO-R15	act	Actor		UndertakesToMakeAccessible is true
CPO-R16	act	Actor		UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother is true
CPO-R17	act	Actor		Produces is true
CPO-R18	act	Actor		Obtains is true
CPO-R19	act	Actor		Supplies is true
CPO-R20	act	Actor		Stocks is true
CPO-R21	act	Actor		Offers is true
CPO-R22	act	Actor		Advertises is true
CPO-R23	act	Actor		UndertakesToImport is true
CPO-R24	act	Actor		UndertakesToExport is true
CPO-R25	condition	None		ForUseUnderPoint1 is true
CPO-R26	condition	None		ForUseUnderPoint2 is true
CPO-R27	condition	None		EnableAnotherUse is true
CPO-R28	condition	None		PunishableUnderPoint3 is true
CPO-R29	act	Actor		UndertakesToAccess is true
CPO-R30	act	Actor		UndertakesToAcquirePossession is true
CPO-R31	act	Actor		Possesses is true
CPO-R32	condition	None		ServesExclusively is true
CPO-R33	condition	None		StateTasks is true
CPO-R34	condition	None		AgreementTasks is true
CPO-R35	condition	None		OfficialDuties is true
CPO-R36	condition	None		ProfessionalDuties is true
CPO-R37	condition	None		OfficialActInInvestigation is true
CPO-R38	condition	None		ProducedUsingChildImage is true
CPO-R39	condition	None		ProducedUsingYouthImage is true
CPO-R40	condition	None		ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true
CPO-R41	condition	None		ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true
CPO-R90	condition	None	the person depicted is under the age of fourteen (a child)	Child is true
CPO-R91	condition	None	the act is a sexual act within section 184h	SexualActs is true
CPO-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not ChildPornographyOffences

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
A person ... if they	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3)	Merkmal	{PornographicContent}	CPO-R01	is true
the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person}	Merkmal	{ActsByChild}	CPO-R02	is true
the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person}	Merkmal	{ActsOnChild}	CPO-R03	is true
the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person}	Merkmal	{ActsInFrontOfChild}	CPO-R04	is true
{Person} is depicted wholly unclothed	Merkmal	{WhollyUnclothed}	CPO-R05	is true
{Person} is depicted partially unclothed	Merkmal	{PartiallyUnclothed}	CPO-R06	is true
the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture	Merkmal	{SuggestivePosture}	CPO-R07	is true
the depiction is sexually provocative	Merkmal	{SexuallyProvocative}	CPO-R08	is true
the naked genitals of {Person}	Merkmal	{NakedGenitals}	CPO-R09	is true
the naked buttocks of {Person}	Merkmal	{NakedButtocks}	CPO-R10	is true
{Actor} distributes the {Content}	Merkmal	{Disseminates}	CPO-R11	is true
{Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public	Merkmal	{MakesAvailableToPublic}	CPO-R12	is true
the content depicts actual events	Merkmal	{DepictsActualEvents}	CPO-R13	is true
the content depicts realistic events	Merkmal	{DepictsRealisticEvents}	CPO-R14	is true
{Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person	Merkmal	{UndertakesToMakeAccessible}	CPO-R15	is true
{Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother}	CPO-R16	is true
{Actor} produces the {Content}	Merkmal	{Produces}	CPO-R17	is true
{Actor} obtains the {Content}	Merkmal	{Obtains}	CPO-R18	is true
{Actor} supplies the {Content}	Merkmal	{Supplies}	CPO-R19	is true
{Actor} stocks the {Content}	Merkmal	{Stocks}	CPO-R20	is true
{Actor} offers the {Content}	Merkmal	{Offers}	CPO-R21	is true
{Actor} advertises the {Content}	Merkmal	{Advertises}	CPO-R22	is true
{Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToImport}	CPO-R23	is true
{Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToExport}	CPO-R24	is true
for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1	Merkmal	{ForUseUnderPoint1}	CPO-R25	is true
for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2	Merkmal	{ForUseUnderPoint2}	CPO-R26	is true
for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way	Merkmal	{EnableAnotherUse}	CPO-R27	is true
the act is punishable under point 3	Merkmal	{PunishableUnderPoint3}	CPO-R28	is true
{Actor} undertakes to access the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToAccess}	CPO-R29	is true
{Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToAcquirePossession}	CPO-R30	is true
{Actor} possesses the {Content}	Merkmal	{Possesses}	CPO-R31	is true
the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties	Merkmal	{ServesExclusively}	CPO-R32	is true
state tasks	Merkmal	{StateTasks}	CPO-R33	is true
tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority	Merkmal	{AgreementTasks}	CPO-R34	is true
official duties	Merkmal	{OfficialDuties}	CPO-R35	is true
professional duties	Merkmal	{ProfessionalDuties}	CPO-R36	is true
the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations	Merkmal	{OfficialActInInvestigation}	CPO-R37	is true
the content has been produced using an image of a child	Merkmal	{ProducedUsingChildImage}	CPO-R38	is true
the content has been produced using an image of a young person	Merkmal	{ProducedUsingYouthImage}	CPO-R39	is true
clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile	Merkmal	{ClarificationOtherwiseFutile}	CPO-R40	is true
clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded	Merkmal	{ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}	CPO-R41	is true
(1) s.2 lower range; (2) aggravation; (4) attempt; (7) seizure	grading / consequences	— excluded —	—	struck

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{ActsByChild}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person}
{ActsInFrontOfChild}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person}
{ActsOnChild}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person}
{Advertises}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} advertises the {Content}
{AgeLimit14}	Number	–	Session	fourteen years
{AgreementTasks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority
{ClarificationOtherwiseFutile}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile
{ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded
{DepictsActualEvents}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content depicts actual events
{DepictsRealisticEvents}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content depicts realistic events
{Disseminates}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} distributes the {Content}
{EnableAnotherUse}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way
{ForUseUnderPoint1}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1
{ForUseUnderPoint2}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2
{MakesAvailableToPublic}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public
{NakedButtocks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the naked buttocks of {Person}
{NakedGenitals}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the naked genitals of {Person}
{Obtains}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} obtains the {Content}
{Offers}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} offers the {Content}
{OfficialActInInvestigation}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations
{OfficialDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	official duties
{PartiallyUnclothed}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is depicted partially unclothed
{Person}	Party	–	Session	the child depicted
{PersonAge}	Number	–	Session	the age of {Person} in years
{PornographicContent}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3)
{Possesses}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} possesses the {Content}
{ProducedUsingChildImage}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has been produced using an image of a child
{ProducedUsingYouthImage}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has been produced using an image of a young person
{Produces}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} produces the {Content}
{ProfessionalDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	professional duties
{PunishableUnderPoint3}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act is punishable under point 3
{ServesExclusively}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties
{SexuallyProvocative}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the depiction is sexually provocative
{StateTasks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	state tasks
{Stocks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} stocks the {Content}
{SuggestivePosture}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture
{Supplies}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} supplies the {Content}
{UndertakesToAccess}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to access the {Content}
{UndertakesToAcquirePossession}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content}
{UndertakesToExport}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}
{UndertakesToImport}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}
{UndertakesToMakeAccessible}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person
{UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content}
{WhollyUnclothed}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is depicted wholly unclothed

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and ({Actor} distributes the {Content} or {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public)) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and (not the content depicts actual events and not the content has been produced using an image of a child and not the content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))) or (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and (the content depicts actual events or the content depicts realistic events) and ({Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person or {Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content})) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state tasks or tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority or official duties or professional duties)) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and (not the content depicts actual events and not the content has been produced using an image of a child and not the content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))) or ((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and the content depicts actual events and {Actor} produces the {Content}) or (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and ({Actor} produces the {Content} or {Actor} obtains the {Content} or {Actor} supplies the {Content} or {Actor} stocks the {Content} or {Actor} offers the {Content} or {Actor} advertises the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to import the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}) and (for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1 or for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2 or for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way) and not the act is punishable under point 3) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and (not the content depicts actual events and not the content has been produced using an image of a child and not the content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))) or (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge < AgeLimit14) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and (the content depicts actual events or the content depicts realistic events) and ({Actor} undertakes to access the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content} or {Actor} possesses the {Content})) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state tasks or tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority or official duties or professional duties))).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[NonRealContent]	DepictsActualEvents, ProducedUsingChildImage, ProducedUsingYouthImage	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ExemptDuty]	StateTasks, AgreementTasks, OfficialDuties, ProfessionalDuties	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Child]	PersonAge, AgeLimit14	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DepictionA]	SexualActs, Child, ActsByChild, ActsOnChild, ActsInFrontOfChild	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DepictionB]	Child, WhollyUnclothed, PartiallyUnclothed, SuggestivePosture	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DepictionC]	Child, SexuallyProvocative, NakedGenitals, NakedButtocks	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ChildPornography]	PornographicContent, DepictionA, DepictionB, DepictionC	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[RealOrRealistic]	DepictsActualEvents, DepictsRealisticEvents	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para3]	ChildPornography, RealOrRealistic, UndertakesToAccess, UndertakesToAcquirePossession, Possesses	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[TradeVerbs]	Produces, Obtains, Supplies, Stocks, Offers, Advertises, UndertakesToImport, UndertakesToExport	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg1]	ChildPornography, Disseminates, MakesAvailableToPublic	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2]	ChildPornography, RealOrRealistic, UndertakesToMakeAccessible, UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg3]	ChildPornography, DepictsActualEvents, Produces	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Exemption5]	ServesExclusively, ExemptDuty	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[InvestigativeNecessity]	ClarificationOtherwiseFutile, ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Exemption6]	OfficialActInInvestigation, NonRealContent, InvestigativeNecessity	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Purpose4]	ForUseUnderPoint1, ForUseUnderPoint2, EnableAnotherUse	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg4]	ChildPornography, TradeVerbs, Purpose4, PunishableUnderPoint3	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ChildPornographyOffences]	Leg1, Exemption6, Leg2, Exemption5, Exemption6, Leg3, Leg4, Exemption6, Para3, Exemption5	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (CPO-P0)	[ChildPornographyOffences]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {ActsByChild} ├─ {ActsInFrontOfChild} ├─ {ActsOnChild} ├─ {Advertises} ├─ {AgeLimit14} ├─ {AgreementTasks} ├─ {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} ├─ {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} ├─ {DepictsActualEvents} ├─ {DepictsRealisticEvents} ├─ {Disseminates} ├─ {EnableAnotherUse} ├─ {ForUseUnderPoint1} ├─ {ForUseUnderPoint2} ├─ {MakesAvailableToPublic} ├─ {NakedButtocks} ├─ {NakedGenitals} ├─ {Obtains} ├─ {Offers} ├─ {OfficialActInInvestigation} ├─ {OfficialDuties} ├─ {PartiallyUnclothed} ├─ {Person} ├─ {PersonAge} ├─ {PornographicContent} ├─ {Possesses} ├─ {ProducedUsingChildImage} ├─ {ProducedUsingYouthImage} ├─ {Produces} ├─ {ProfessionalDuties} ├─ {PunishableUnderPoint3} ├─ {ServesExclusively} ├─ {SexuallyProvocative} ├─ {StateTasks} ├─ {Stocks} ├─ {SuggestivePosture} ├─ {Supplies} ├─ {UndertakesToAccess} ├─ {UndertakesToAcquirePossession} ├─ {UndertakesToExport} ├─ {UndertakesToImport} ├─ {UndertakesToMakeAccessible} ├─ {UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother} ├─ {WhollyUnclothed} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [NonRealContent] = DepictsActualEvents is false and ProducedUsingChildImage is false and ProducedUsingYouthImage is false ├─ [ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or AgreementTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true ├─ [Child] = PersonAge < AgeLimit14 ├─ [DepictionA] = SexualActs is true and Child is true and (ActsByChild is true or ActsOnChild is true or ActsInFrontOfChild is true) ├─ [DepictionB] = Child is true and (WhollyUnclothed is true or PartiallyUnclothed is true) and SuggestivePosture is true ├─ [DepictionC] = Child is true and SexuallyProvocative is true and (NakedGenitals is true or NakedButtocks is true) ├─ [ChildPornography] = PornographicContent is true and (DepictionA is true or DepictionB is true or DepictionC is true) ├─ [RealOrRealistic] = DepictsActualEvents is true or DepictsRealisticEvents is true ├─ [Para3] = ChildPornography is true and RealOrRealistic is true and (UndertakesToAccess is true or UndertakesToAcquirePossession is true or Possesses is true) ├─ [TradeVerbs] = Produces is true or Obtains is true or Supplies is true or Stocks is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true or UndertakesToImport is true or UndertakesToExport is true ├─ [Leg1] = ChildPornography is true and (Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true) ├─ [Leg2] = ChildPornography is true and RealOrRealistic is true and (UndertakesToMakeAccessible is true or UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother is true) ├─ [Leg3] = ChildPornography is true and DepictsActualEvents is true and Produces is true ├─ [Exemption5] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true ├─ [InvestigativeNecessity] = ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true or ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true ├─ [Exemption6] = OfficialActInInvestigation is true and NonRealContent is true and InvestigativeNecessity is true ├─ [Purpose4] = ForUseUnderPoint1 is true or ForUseUnderPoint2 is true or EnableAnotherUse is true ├─ [Leg4] = ChildPornography is true and TradeVerbs is true and Purpose4 is true and PunishableUnderPoint3 is false ├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h) ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [ChildPornographyOffences] = (Leg1 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Leg2 is true and Exemption5 is false and Exemption6 is false) or Leg3 is true or (Leg4 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Para3 is true and Exemption5 is false) ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [ChildPornographyOffences] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [ChildPornographyOffences] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [ChildPornographyOffences] depends on [NonRealContent], [ExemptDuty], [Child], [DepictionA], [DepictionB], [DepictionC], [ChildPornography], [RealOrRealistic], [Para3], [TradeVerbs], [Leg1], [Leg2], [Leg3], [Exemption5], [InvestigativeNecessity], [Exemption6], [Purpose4], [Leg4] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [ChildPornographyOffences]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{ActsByChild}	Element/Datum: the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person}.?	Boolean
Q3	Session	{ActsInFrontOfChild}	Element/Datum: the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q4	Session	{ActsOnChild}	Element/Datum: the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person}.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{Advertises}	Element/Datum: {Actor} advertises the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{AgeLimit14}	Element/Datum: fourteen years.?	Number
Q7	Session	{AgreementTasks}	Element/Datum: tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{ClarificationOtherwiseFutile}	Element/Datum: clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}	Element/Datum: clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{DepictsActualEvents}	Element/Datum: the content depicts actual events.?	Boolean
Q11	Session	{DepictsRealisticEvents}	Element/Datum: the content depicts realistic events.?	Boolean
Q12	Session	{Disseminates}	Element/Datum: {Actor} distributes the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q13	Session	{EnableAnotherUse}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way.?	Boolean
Q14	Session	{ForUseUnderPoint1}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1.?	Boolean
Q15	Session	{ForUseUnderPoint2}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2.?	Boolean
Q16	Session	{MakesAvailableToPublic}	Element/Datum: {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public.?	Boolean
Q17	Session	{NakedButtocks}	Element/Datum: the naked buttocks of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q18	Session	{NakedGenitals}	Element/Datum: the naked genitals of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q19	Session	{Obtains}	Element/Datum: {Actor} obtains the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q20	Session	{Offers}	Element/Datum: {Actor} offers the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q21	Session	{OfficialActInInvestigation}	Element/Datum: the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations.?	Boolean
Q22	Session	{OfficialDuties}	Element/Datum: official duties.?	Boolean
Q23	Session	{PartiallyUnclothed}	Element/Datum: {Person} is depicted partially unclothed.?	Boolean
Q24	Session	{Person}	Element/Datum: the child depicted.?	Party
Q25	Session	{PersonAge}	Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.?	Number
Q26	Session	{PornographicContent}	Element/Datum: the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3).?	Boolean
Q27	Session	{Possesses}	Element/Datum: {Actor} possesses the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q28	Session	{ProducedUsingChildImage}	Element/Datum: the content has been produced using an image of a child.?	Boolean
Q29	Session	{ProducedUsingYouthImage}	Element/Datum: the content has been produced using an image of a young person.?	Boolean
Q30	Session	{Produces}	Element/Datum: {Actor} produces the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q31	Session	{ProfessionalDuties}	Element/Datum: professional duties.?	Boolean
Q32	Session	{PunishableUnderPoint3}	Element/Datum: the act is punishable under point 3.?	Boolean
Q33	Session	{ServesExclusively}	Element/Datum: the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties.?	Boolean
Q34	Session	{SexuallyProvocative}	Element/Datum: the depiction is sexually provocative.?	Boolean
Q35	Session	{StateTasks}	Element/Datum: state tasks.?	Boolean
Q36	Session	{Stocks}	Element/Datum: {Actor} stocks the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q37	Session	{SuggestivePosture}	Element/Datum: the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture.?	Boolean
Q38	Session	{Supplies}	Element/Datum: {Actor} supplies the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q39	Session	{UndertakesToAccess}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to access the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q40	Session	{UndertakesToAcquirePossession}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q41	Session	{UndertakesToExport}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q42	Session	{UndertakesToImport}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q43	Session	{UndertakesToMakeAccessible}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person.?	Boolean
Q44	Session	{UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q45	Session	{WhollyUnclothed}	Element/Datum: {Person} is depicted wholly unclothed.?	Boolean

Flags

Scope Paragraph 1 sentence 1, the four offence legs; paragraph 3, the access and possession offence; paragraphs 5 and 6, the two statutory exemptions, encoded live. Struck per the marked-up source: paragraph 1 sentence 2 (the lower range for non-real content), paragraph 2 (the commercial and gang aggravation), paragraph 4 (attempt) and paragraph 7 (seizure).

Child pornography definition authored here §184b(1)(1) defines child pornography: [ChildPornography] = {PornographicContent} and ([DepictionA] or [DepictionB] or [DepictionC]). Depiction a is [SexualActs] by, on or in front of a person under fourteen ({ActsByChild}, {ActsOnChild}, {ActsInFrontOfChild}; the child threshold as [Child] = {PersonAge} < {AgeLimit14}); depiction b is the wholly-or-partially-unclothed child in a sexually suggestive posture; depiction c the sexually provocative depiction of naked genitals or buttocks, with {SexuallyProvocative} as an inline qualifier. §176e and §184e consume this definition by name.

Unternehmen carried as attempt-language The German “es unternimmt” (a term of art under §11(1)(6): the undertaking counts as the completed act) appears in the English as “attempts to”; encoded as the {UndertakesTo...} verbs, so the substrate carries the completed-by-undertaking reading, recorded here.

Exemptions scoped per leg (rule 8) [Exemption5] (state tasks, agreement tasks, official or professional duties) negates leg 2 and paragraph 3, exactly as (5) states. [Exemption6] (investigative official acts over content that is neither actual nor produced from a real child's or young person's image, where clarification would otherwise be futile or significantly impeded) negates legs 1, 2 and 4. The composite applies each as “and not” on the named legs only; leg 3 (production of actual-event content) is exempted by neither.

Subsidiarity of leg 4 “provided that the act is not punishable under point 3” is {PunishableUnderPoint3} is false inside [Leg4] (rule 12).

Sexual act [SexualActs] (§184h, by name) inside depiction a.

Strikes Penalties throughout, (1) sentence 2, (2), (4), (6)'s reference to the struck second sentence, and (7) struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §184b is Operomise-tagged: the offence turns on content properties, conduct verbs, purposes and the two exemptions, all encodable as written.

§184c · Dissemination, acquisition and possession of youth pornography

YouthPornographyOffences · provenance StGB 184c · (1), (3), (6) encoded · authors the youth-pornography definition

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) Any person who 1. distributes youth pornography or makes it available to the public; pornographic material is deemed to be youth pornography (Section 11(3)) if it depicts: a) sexual acts by, on or in front of a person who is fourteen but not yet eighteen years old, b) the depiction of a person who is fourteen but not yet eighteen years old, wholly or partially unclothed, in a sexually suggestive posture, or c) the sexually provocative depiction of the naked genitals or buttocks of a person who is fourteen but not yet eighteen years old, 2. attempts to make youth pornography depicting actual or realistic events accessible to another person or to procure possession thereof for that person, 3. produces youth pornography depicting an actual event, or 4. produces, obtains, supplies, stocks, offers, advertises or undertakes to import or export youth pornography for the purpose of using it within the meaning of point 1 or 2 or enabling another person to use it in that way, in so far as the act is not punishable under point 3. (2) If, in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, the offender acts on a commercial basis or as a member of a gang that has formed to commit such offences on a continuous basis, and if, in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, points 1, 2 and 4, the content depicts an actual or realistic event, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (3) Any person who attempts to access youth pornography that depicts actual events, or to acquire possession of such material, or who possesses such material, shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of up to two years or a fine. (4) Paragraph 1(3), including in conjunction with paragraph 5, and paragraph 3 shall not apply to acts committed by persons in relation to youth pornography which they have produced exclusively for personal use with the consent of the persons depicted. (5) An attempt is punishable; this does not apply to offences under paragraph 1, points 2 and 4, and paragraph 3. (6) Section 184b(5) to (7) shall apply mutatis mutandis.

«if YouthPornographyOffences is true»(1) {Actor} who 1. «if {Disseminates} is true»distributes «end if» «if [YouthPornography] is true»youth pornography; pornographic material is deemed to be youth pornography if «if {PornographicContent} is true»it is pornographic content (Section 11(3)) «end if» and it depicts: a) [SexualActs] «if {ActsByYouth} is true»by «end if» «if {ActsOnYouth} is true», on «end if» «if {ActsInFrontOfYouth} is true»or in front of «end if» {Person} «if [Youth] is true»who is {AgeLimit14} but not yet {AgeLimit18} years old «end if», b) the depiction of «if [Youth] is true»such a person «end if» who is «if {WhollyUnclothed} is true»wholly «end if» «if {PartiallyUnclothed} is true»or partially «end if» unclothed «if {SuggestivePosture} is true»in a sexually suggestive posture «end if», or c) the {SexuallyProvocative} sexually provocative depiction of the «if {NakedGenitals} is true»naked genitals «end if» «if {NakedButtocks} is true»or buttocks «end if» of «if [Youth] is true»such a person «end if» «end if» «if {MakesAvailableToPublic} is true»or makes it available to the public «end if», 2. «if {UndertakesToMakeAccessible} is true»attempts to make «if [YouthPornography] is true»youth pornography «end if» «if [RealOrRealistic] is true»depicting «if {DepictsActualEvents} is true»actual «end if» «if {DepictsRealisticEvents} is true»or realistic «end if» events «end if» accessible to another person «end if» «if {UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother} is true»or to procure possession thereof for that person «end if», 3. «if {Produces} is true»produces «end if» «if [YouthPornography] is true»youth pornography «end if» «if {DepictsActualEvents} is true»depicting an actual event «end if», or 4. «if {Produces} is true»produces «end if» «if {Obtains} is true», obtains «end if» «if {Supplies} is true», supplies «end if» «if {Stocks} is true», stocks «end if» «if {Offers} is true», offers «end if» «if {Advertises} is true», advertises «end if» «if {UndertakesToImport} is true»or undertakes to import «end if» «if {UndertakesToExport} is true»or export «end if» «if [YouthPornography] is true»youth pornography «end if» «if {ForUseUnderPoint1} is true»for the purpose of using it within the meaning of point 1 «end if» «if {ForUseUnderPoint2} is true»or 2 «end if» «if {EnableAnotherUse} is true»or enabling another person to use it in that way «end if», «if {PunishableUnderPoint3} is false»in so far as the act is not punishable under point 3 «end if». (2) If, in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, the offender acts on a commercial basis or as a member of a gang that has formed to commit such offences on a continuous basis, and if, in the cases referred to in paragraph 1, points 1, 2 and 4, the content depicts an actual or realistic event, the penalty shall be imprisonment for a term of three months to five years. (3) {Actor} who «if {UndertakesToAccess} is true»attempts to access «end if» «if [YouthPornography] is true»youth pornography «end if» «if {DepictsActualEvents} is true»that depicts actual events «end if», «if {UndertakesToAcquirePossession} is true»or to acquire possession of such material «end if», or «if {Possesses} is true»possesses such material «end if», shall be liable to a term of imprisonment of up to two years or a fine. (4) Paragraph 1(3), including in conjunction with paragraph 5, and paragraph 3 shall not apply to acts committed by persons in relation to youth pornography which they have produced exclusively for personal use with the consent of the persons depicted. (5) An attempt is punishable; this does not apply to offences under paragraph 1, points 2 and 4, and paragraph 3. (6) Section 184b(5) to (7) shall apply mutatis mutandis: paragraph 1 point 2 and paragraph 3 shall not apply «if [Exemption5] is true»to acts «if {ServesExclusively} is true»which serve exclusively the lawful fulfilment of «end if» 1. «if {StateTasks} is true»state tasks «end if», 2. «if {AgreementTasks} is true»tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority «end if», or 3. «if {OfficialDuties} is true»official «end if» «if {ProfessionalDuties} is true»or professional duties «end if» «end if»; and paragraph 1 points 1, 2 and 4 shall not apply «if [Exemption6] is true»to «if {OfficialActInInvestigation} is true»official acts carried out in the context of criminal investigations «end if» if the act relates to content «if [NonRealContent] is true»that does not depict actual events and has not been produced using an image of «if {ProducedUsingChildImage} is true»a child «end if» «if {ProducedUsingYouthImage} is true»or young person «end if» «end if» and clarifying the facts would otherwise be «if {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} is true»futile «end if» «if {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} is true»or significantly impeded «end if» «end if». «end if»

Annexes

Computables

[Youth] = PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18 [DepictionC] = Youth is true and SexuallyProvocative is true and (NakedGenitals is true or NakedButtocks is true) [DepictionA] = SexualActs is true and Youth is true and (ActsByYouth is true or ActsOnYouth is true or ActsInFrontOfYouth is true) [DepictionB] = Youth is true and (WhollyUnclothed is true or PartiallyUnclothed is true) and SuggestivePosture is true [YouthPornography] = PornographicContent is true and (DepictionA is true or DepictionB is true or DepictionC is true) [Leg3] = YouthPornography is true and DepictsActualEvents is true and Produces is true [RealOrRealistic] = DepictsActualEvents is true or DepictsRealisticEvents is true [TradeVerbs] = Produces is true or Obtains is true or Supplies is true or Stocks is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true or UndertakesToImport is true or UndertakesToExport is true [Purpose4] = ForUseUnderPoint1 is true or ForUseUnderPoint2 is true or EnableAnotherUse is true [Leg4] = YouthPornography is true and TradeVerbs is true and Purpose4 is true and PunishableUnderPoint3 is false [Leg1] = YouthPornography is true and (Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true) [NonRealContent] = DepictsActualEvents is false and ProducedUsingChildImage is false and ProducedUsingYouthImage is false [Leg2] = YouthPornography is true and RealOrRealistic is true and (UndertakesToMakeAccessible is true or UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother is true) [Para3] = YouthPornography is true and DepictsActualEvents is true and (UndertakesToAccess is true or UndertakesToAcquirePossession is true or Possesses is true) [ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or AgreementTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true [Exemption5] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true [InvestigativeNecessity] = ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true or ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true [Exemption6] = OfficialActInInvestigation is true and NonRealContent is true and InvestigativeNecessity is true [YouthPornographyOffences] = (Leg1 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Leg2 is true and Exemption5 is false and Exemption6 is false) or Leg3 is true or (Leg4 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Para3 is true and Exemption5 is false)

[SexualActs] — referenced by canonical name; defined in the sexual-act term in §184h. Not expanded here (cross-operome composition by name).

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
YPO-R01	condition	None		PornographicContent is true
YPO-R02	condition	None		ActsByYouth is true
YPO-R03	condition	None		ActsOnYouth is true
YPO-R04	condition	None		ActsInFrontOfYouth is true
YPO-R05	condition	None		WhollyUnclothed is true
YPO-R06	condition	None		PartiallyUnclothed is true
YPO-R07	condition	None		SuggestivePosture is true
YPO-R08	condition	None		SexuallyProvocative is true
YPO-R09	condition	None		NakedGenitals is true
YPO-R10	condition	None		NakedButtocks is true
YPO-R11	act	Actor		Disseminates is true
YPO-R12	act	Actor		MakesAvailableToPublic is true
YPO-R13	condition	None		DepictsActualEvents is true
YPO-R14	condition	None		DepictsRealisticEvents is true
YPO-R15	act	Actor		UndertakesToMakeAccessible is true
YPO-R16	act	Actor		UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother is true
YPO-R17	act	Actor		Produces is true
YPO-R18	act	Actor		Obtains is true
YPO-R19	act	Actor		Supplies is true
YPO-R20	act	Actor		Stocks is true
YPO-R21	act	Actor		Offers is true
YPO-R22	act	Actor		Advertises is true
YPO-R23	act	Actor		UndertakesToImport is true
YPO-R24	act	Actor		UndertakesToExport is true
YPO-R25	condition	None		ForUseUnderPoint1 is true
YPO-R26	condition	None		ForUseUnderPoint2 is true
YPO-R27	condition	None		EnableAnotherUse is true
YPO-R28	condition	None		PunishableUnderPoint3 is true
YPO-R29	act	Actor		UndertakesToAccess is true
YPO-R30	act	Actor		UndertakesToAcquirePossession is true
YPO-R31	act	Actor		Possesses is true
YPO-R32	condition	None		ServesExclusively is true
YPO-R33	condition	None		StateTasks is true
YPO-R34	condition	None		AgreementTasks is true
YPO-R35	condition	None		OfficialDuties is true
YPO-R36	condition	None		ProfessionalDuties is true
YPO-R37	condition	None		OfficialActInInvestigation is true
YPO-R38	condition	None		ProducedUsingChildImage is true
YPO-R39	condition	None		ProducedUsingYouthImage is true
YPO-R40	condition	None		ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true
YPO-R41	condition	None		ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true
YPO-R90	condition	None	the person depicted is fourteen but not yet eighteen years old	Youth is true
YPO-R91	condition	None	the act is a sexual act within section 184h	SexualActs is true
YPO-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not YouthPornographyOffences

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
Any person who	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3)	Merkmal	{PornographicContent}	YPO-R01	is true
the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person}	Merkmal	{ActsByYouth}	YPO-R02	is true
the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person}	Merkmal	{ActsOnYouth}	YPO-R03	is true
the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person}	Merkmal	{ActsInFrontOfYouth}	YPO-R04	is true
{Person} is depicted wholly unclothed	Merkmal	{WhollyUnclothed}	YPO-R05	is true
{Person} is depicted partially unclothed	Merkmal	{PartiallyUnclothed}	YPO-R06	is true
the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture	Merkmal	{SuggestivePosture}	YPO-R07	is true
the depiction is sexually provocative	Merkmal	{SexuallyProvocative}	YPO-R08	is true
the naked genitals of {Person}	Merkmal	{NakedGenitals}	YPO-R09	is true
the naked buttocks of {Person}	Merkmal	{NakedButtocks}	YPO-R10	is true
{Actor} distributes the {Content}	Merkmal	{Disseminates}	YPO-R11	is true
{Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public	Merkmal	{MakesAvailableToPublic}	YPO-R12	is true
the content depicts actual events	Merkmal	{DepictsActualEvents}	YPO-R13	is true
the content depicts realistic events	Merkmal	{DepictsRealisticEvents}	YPO-R14	is true
{Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person	Merkmal	{UndertakesToMakeAccessible}	YPO-R15	is true
{Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother}	YPO-R16	is true
{Actor} produces the {Content}	Merkmal	{Produces}	YPO-R17	is true
{Actor} obtains the {Content}	Merkmal	{Obtains}	YPO-R18	is true
{Actor} supplies the {Content}	Merkmal	{Supplies}	YPO-R19	is true
{Actor} stocks the {Content}	Merkmal	{Stocks}	YPO-R20	is true
{Actor} offers the {Content}	Merkmal	{Offers}	YPO-R21	is true
{Actor} advertises the {Content}	Merkmal	{Advertises}	YPO-R22	is true
{Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToImport}	YPO-R23	is true
{Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToExport}	YPO-R24	is true
for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1	Merkmal	{ForUseUnderPoint1}	YPO-R25	is true
for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2	Merkmal	{ForUseUnderPoint2}	YPO-R26	is true
for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way	Merkmal	{EnableAnotherUse}	YPO-R27	is true
the act is punishable under point 3	Merkmal	{PunishableUnderPoint3}	YPO-R28	is true
{Actor} undertakes to access the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToAccess}	YPO-R29	is true
{Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content}	Merkmal	{UndertakesToAcquirePossession}	YPO-R30	is true
{Actor} possesses the {Content}	Merkmal	{Possesses}	YPO-R31	is true
the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties	Merkmal	{ServesExclusively}	YPO-R32	is true
state tasks	Merkmal	{StateTasks}	YPO-R33	is true
tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority	Merkmal	{AgreementTasks}	YPO-R34	is true
official duties	Merkmal	{OfficialDuties}	YPO-R35	is true
professional duties	Merkmal	{ProfessionalDuties}	YPO-R36	is true
the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations	Merkmal	{OfficialActInInvestigation}	YPO-R37	is true
the content has been produced using an image of a child	Merkmal	{ProducedUsingChildImage}	YPO-R38	is true
the content has been produced using an image of a young person	Merkmal	{ProducedUsingYouthImage}	YPO-R39	is true
clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile	Merkmal	{ClarificationOtherwiseFutile}	YPO-R40	is true
clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded	Merkmal	{ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}	YPO-R41	is true
(2) aggravation; (4) personal-use consent exemption; (5) attempt	grading / carve-out / attempt	— excluded —	—	struck

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{ActsByYouth}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person}
{ActsInFrontOfYouth}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person}
{ActsOnYouth}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person}
{Advertises}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} advertises the {Content}
{AgeLimit14}	Number	–	Session	fourteen years
{AgeLimit18}	Number	–	Session	eighteen years
{AgreementTasks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority
{ClarificationOtherwiseFutile}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile
{ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded
{DepictsActualEvents}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content depicts actual events
{DepictsRealisticEvents}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content depicts realistic events
{Disseminates}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} distributes the {Content}
{EnableAnotherUse}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way
{ForUseUnderPoint1}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1
{ForUseUnderPoint2}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2
{MakesAvailableToPublic}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public
{NakedButtocks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the naked buttocks of {Person}
{NakedGenitals}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the naked genitals of {Person}
{Obtains}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} obtains the {Content}
{Offers}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} offers the {Content}
{OfficialActInInvestigation}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations
{OfficialDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	official duties
{PartiallyUnclothed}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is depicted partially unclothed
{Person}	Party	–	Session	the young person depicted
{PersonAge}	Number	–	Session	the age of {Person} in years
{PornographicContent}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3)
{Possesses}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} possesses the {Content}
{ProducedUsingChildImage}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has been produced using an image of a child
{ProducedUsingYouthImage}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the content has been produced using an image of a young person
{Produces}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} produces the {Content}
{ProfessionalDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	professional duties
{PunishableUnderPoint3}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act is punishable under point 3
{ServesExclusively}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties
{SexuallyProvocative}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the depiction is sexually provocative
{StateTasks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	state tasks
{Stocks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} stocks the {Content}
{SuggestivePosture}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture
{Supplies}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} supplies the {Content}
{UndertakesToAccess}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to access the {Content}
{UndertakesToAcquirePossession}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content}
{UndertakesToExport}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}
{UndertakesToImport}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}
{UndertakesToMakeAccessible}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person
{UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content}
{WhollyUnclothed}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Person} is depicted wholly unclothed

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and ({Actor} distributes the {Content} or {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public)) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and (not the content depicts actual events and not the content has been produced using an image of a child and not the content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))) or (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and (the content depicts actual events or the content depicts realistic events) and ({Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person or {Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content})) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state tasks or tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority or official duties or professional duties)) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and (not the content depicts actual events and not the content has been produced using an image of a child and not the content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))) or ((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and the content depicts actual events and {Actor} produces the {Content}) or (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and ({Actor} produces the {Content} or {Actor} obtains the {Content} or {Actor} supplies the {Content} or {Actor} stocks the {Content} or {Actor} offers the {Content} or {Actor} advertises the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to import the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}) and (for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1 or for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2 or for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way) and not the act is punishable under point 3) and it is not the case that (the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations and (not the content depicts actual events and not the content has been produced using an image of a child and not the content has been produced using an image of a young person) and (clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile or clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded))) or (((the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3) and ((the act is a sexual act within the meaning of §184h and (PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and (the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person} or the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person})) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and ({Person} is depicted wholly unclothed or {Person} is depicted partially unclothed) and the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture) or ((PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18) and the depiction is sexually provocative and (the naked genitals of {Person} or the naked buttocks of {Person})))) and the content depicts actual events and ({Actor} undertakes to access the {Content} or {Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content} or {Actor} possesses the {Content})) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state tasks or tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority or official duties or professional duties))).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[Youth]	PersonAge, AgeLimit14, PersonAge, AgeLimit18	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DepictionC]	Youth, SexuallyProvocative, NakedGenitals, NakedButtocks	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DepictionA]	SexualActs, Youth, ActsByYouth, ActsOnYouth, ActsInFrontOfYouth	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[DepictionB]	Youth, WhollyUnclothed, PartiallyUnclothed, SuggestivePosture	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[YouthPornography]	PornographicContent, DepictionA, DepictionB, DepictionC	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg3]	YouthPornography, DepictsActualEvents, Produces	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[RealOrRealistic]	DepictsActualEvents, DepictsRealisticEvents	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[TradeVerbs]	Produces, Obtains, Supplies, Stocks, Offers, Advertises, UndertakesToImport, UndertakesToExport	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Purpose4]	ForUseUnderPoint1, ForUseUnderPoint2, EnableAnotherUse	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg4]	YouthPornography, TradeVerbs, Purpose4, PunishableUnderPoint3	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg1]	YouthPornography, Disseminates, MakesAvailableToPublic	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[NonRealContent]	DepictsActualEvents, ProducedUsingChildImage, ProducedUsingYouthImage	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2]	YouthPornography, RealOrRealistic, UndertakesToMakeAccessible, UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para3]	YouthPornography, DepictsActualEvents, UndertakesToAccess, UndertakesToAcquirePossession, Possesses	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ExemptDuty]	StateTasks, AgreementTasks, OfficialDuties, ProfessionalDuties	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Exemption5]	ServesExclusively, ExemptDuty	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[InvestigativeNecessity]	ClarificationOtherwiseFutile, ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Exemption6]	OfficialActInInvestigation, NonRealContent, InvestigativeNecessity	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[YouthPornographyOffences]	Leg1, Exemption6, Leg2, Exemption5, Exemption6, Leg3, Leg4, Exemption6, Para3, Exemption5	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (YPO-P0)	[YouthPornographyOffences]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {ActsByYouth} ├─ {ActsInFrontOfYouth} ├─ {ActsOnYouth} ├─ {Advertises} ├─ {AgeLimit14} ├─ {AgeLimit18} ├─ {AgreementTasks} ├─ {ClarificationOtherwiseFutile} ├─ {ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded} ├─ {DepictsActualEvents} ├─ {DepictsRealisticEvents} ├─ {Disseminates} ├─ {EnableAnotherUse} ├─ {ForUseUnderPoint1} ├─ {ForUseUnderPoint2} ├─ {MakesAvailableToPublic} ├─ {NakedButtocks} ├─ {NakedGenitals} ├─ {Obtains} ├─ {Offers} ├─ {OfficialActInInvestigation} ├─ {OfficialDuties} ├─ {PartiallyUnclothed} ├─ {Person} ├─ {PersonAge} ├─ {PornographicContent} ├─ {Possesses} ├─ {ProducedUsingChildImage} ├─ {ProducedUsingYouthImage} ├─ {Produces} ├─ {ProfessionalDuties} ├─ {PunishableUnderPoint3} ├─ {ServesExclusively} ├─ {SexuallyProvocative} ├─ {StateTasks} ├─ {Stocks} ├─ {SuggestivePosture} ├─ {Supplies} ├─ {UndertakesToAccess} ├─ {UndertakesToAcquirePossession} ├─ {UndertakesToExport} ├─ {UndertakesToImport} ├─ {UndertakesToMakeAccessible} ├─ {UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother} ├─ {WhollyUnclothed} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [Youth] = PersonAge >= AgeLimit14 and PersonAge < AgeLimit18 ├─ [DepictionC] = Youth is true and SexuallyProvocative is true and (NakedGenitals is true or NakedButtocks is true) ├─ [DepictionA] = SexualActs is true and Youth is true and (ActsByYouth is true or ActsOnYouth is true or ActsInFrontOfYouth is true) ├─ [DepictionB] = Youth is true and (WhollyUnclothed is true or PartiallyUnclothed is true) and SuggestivePosture is true ├─ [YouthPornography] = PornographicContent is true and (DepictionA is true or DepictionB is true or DepictionC is true) ├─ [Leg3] = YouthPornography is true and DepictsActualEvents is true and Produces is true ├─ [RealOrRealistic] = DepictsActualEvents is true or DepictsRealisticEvents is true ├─ [TradeVerbs] = Produces is true or Obtains is true or Supplies is true or Stocks is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true or UndertakesToImport is true or UndertakesToExport is true ├─ [Purpose4] = ForUseUnderPoint1 is true or ForUseUnderPoint2 is true or EnableAnotherUse is true ├─ [Leg4] = YouthPornography is true and TradeVerbs is true and Purpose4 is true and PunishableUnderPoint3 is false ├─ [Leg1] = YouthPornography is true and (Disseminates is true or MakesAvailableToPublic is true) ├─ [NonRealContent] = DepictsActualEvents is false and ProducedUsingChildImage is false and ProducedUsingYouthImage is false ├─ [Leg2] = YouthPornography is true and RealOrRealistic is true and (UndertakesToMakeAccessible is true or UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother is true) ├─ [Para3] = YouthPornography is true and DepictsActualEvents is true and (UndertakesToAccess is true or UndertakesToAcquirePossession is true or Possesses is true) ├─ [ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or AgreementTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true ├─ [Exemption5] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true ├─ [InvestigativeNecessity] = ClarificationOtherwiseFutile is true or ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded is true ├─ [Exemption6] = OfficialActInInvestigation is true and NonRealContent is true and InvestigativeNecessity is true ├─ [SexualActs] composed by name (the sexual-act term in §184h) ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [YouthPornographyOffences] = (Leg1 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Leg2 is true and Exemption5 is false and Exemption6 is false) or Leg3 is true or (Leg4 is true and Exemption6 is false) or (Para3 is true and Exemption5 is false) ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [YouthPornographyOffences] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [YouthPornographyOffences] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [YouthPornographyOffences] depends on [Youth], [DepictionC], [DepictionA], [DepictionB], [YouthPornography], [Leg3], [RealOrRealistic], [TradeVerbs], [Purpose4], [Leg4], [Leg1], [NonRealContent], [Leg2], [Para3], [ExemptDuty], [Exemption5], [InvestigativeNecessity], [Exemption6] plus composed [SexualActs]; none refer back to [YouthPornographyOffences]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

• Composition by canonical name is acyclic: the composed operome is read once and does not reference this one back.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{ActsByYouth}	Element/Datum: the content has as its subject the act performed by {Person}.?	Boolean
Q3	Session	{ActsInFrontOfYouth}	Element/Datum: the content has as its subject the act performed in front of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q4	Session	{ActsOnYouth}	Element/Datum: the content has as its subject the act performed on {Person}.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{Advertises}	Element/Datum: {Actor} advertises the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{AgeLimit14}	Element/Datum: fourteen years.?	Number
Q7	Session	{AgeLimit18}	Element/Datum: eighteen years.?	Number
Q8	Session	{AgreementTasks}	Element/Datum: tasks arising from agreements with a competent state authority.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{ClarificationOtherwiseFutile}	Element/Datum: clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be futile.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{ClarificationSignificantlyImpeded}	Element/Datum: clarifying the facts of the case would otherwise be significantly impeded.?	Boolean
Q11	Session	{DepictsActualEvents}	Element/Datum: the content depicts actual events.?	Boolean
Q12	Session	{DepictsRealisticEvents}	Element/Datum: the content depicts realistic events.?	Boolean
Q13	Session	{Disseminates}	Element/Datum: {Actor} distributes the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q14	Session	{EnableAnotherUse}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of enabling another person to use the {Content} in that way.?	Boolean
Q15	Session	{ForUseUnderPoint1}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 1.?	Boolean
Q16	Session	{ForUseUnderPoint2}	Element/Datum: for the purpose of using the {Content} within the meaning of point 2.?	Boolean
Q17	Session	{MakesAvailableToPublic}	Element/Datum: {Actor} makes the {Content} available to the public.?	Boolean
Q18	Session	{NakedButtocks}	Element/Datum: the naked buttocks of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q19	Session	{NakedGenitals}	Element/Datum: the naked genitals of {Person}.?	Boolean
Q20	Session	{Obtains}	Element/Datum: {Actor} obtains the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q21	Session	{Offers}	Element/Datum: {Actor} offers the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q22	Session	{OfficialActInInvestigation}	Element/Datum: the act is an official act carried out in the context of criminal investigations.?	Boolean
Q23	Session	{OfficialDuties}	Element/Datum: official duties.?	Boolean
Q24	Session	{PartiallyUnclothed}	Element/Datum: {Person} is depicted partially unclothed.?	Boolean
Q25	Session	{Person}	Element/Datum: the young person depicted.?	Party
Q26	Session	{PersonAge}	Element/Datum: the age of {Person} in years.?	Number
Q27	Session	{PornographicContent}	Element/Datum: the content is pornographic content within the meaning of Section 11(3).?	Boolean
Q28	Session	{Possesses}	Element/Datum: {Actor} possesses the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q29	Session	{ProducedUsingChildImage}	Element/Datum: the content has been produced using an image of a child.?	Boolean
Q30	Session	{ProducedUsingYouthImage}	Element/Datum: the content has been produced using an image of a young person.?	Boolean
Q31	Session	{Produces}	Element/Datum: {Actor} produces the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q32	Session	{ProfessionalDuties}	Element/Datum: professional duties.?	Boolean
Q33	Session	{PunishableUnderPoint3}	Element/Datum: the act is punishable under point 3.?	Boolean
Q34	Session	{ServesExclusively}	Element/Datum: the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties.?	Boolean
Q35	Session	{SexuallyProvocative}	Element/Datum: the depiction is sexually provocative.?	Boolean
Q36	Session	{StateTasks}	Element/Datum: state tasks.?	Boolean
Q37	Session	{Stocks}	Element/Datum: {Actor} stocks the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q38	Session	{SuggestivePosture}	Element/Datum: the depiction shows a sexually suggestive posture.?	Boolean
Q39	Session	{Supplies}	Element/Datum: {Actor} supplies the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q40	Session	{UndertakesToAccess}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to access the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q41	Session	{UndertakesToAcquirePossession}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to acquire possession of the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q42	Session	{UndertakesToExport}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to export the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q43	Session	{UndertakesToImport}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to import the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q44	Session	{UndertakesToMakeAccessible}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to make the {Content} accessible to another person.?	Boolean
Q45	Session	{UndertakesToProcurePossessionForAnother}	Element/Datum: {Actor} undertakes to procure another person's possession of the {Content}.?	Boolean
Q46	Session	{WhollyUnclothed}	Element/Datum: {Person} is depicted wholly unclothed.?	Boolean

Flags

Scope Paragraph 1, the four offence legs over youth pornography; paragraph 3, the access and possession offence (actual events only); paragraph 6, the imported §184b exemptions, encoded live by restatement. Struck per the marked-up source: paragraph 2 (the commercial and gang aggravation), paragraph 4 (the personal-use consent exemption) and paragraph 5 (attempt).

Translation note The draft English layer renders “jugendpornographischer Inhalt” as “child pornography” throughout §184c, which is wrong in substance: this section governs youth pornography, defined over a person who is fourteen but not yet eighteen years old. The source column is rendered as “youth pornography” and to the German age formula at every occurrence.

Youth pornography definition authored here [YouthPornography] = {PornographicContent} and ([DepictionA] or [DepictionB] or [DepictionC]), the three depictions mirroring §184b(1)(1) with [Youth] = {PersonAge} >= {AgeLimit14} and {PersonAge} < {AgeLimit18} (“vierzehn, aber noch nicht achtzehn Jahre alten Person” as a two-comparator computable). §184e consumes this definition by name.

Narrower content qualifications than §184b Leg 2 requires actual or realistic events; leg 3 and paragraph 3 require actual events only ([RealOrRealistic] versus {DepictsActualEvents}). This asymmetry is in the statute and is carried exactly.

Personal-use consent exemption struck (deliberate) Paragraph 4, the statutory exemption for content produced exclusively for personal use with the consent of the persons depicted, was struck whole in the markup and is not encoded; recorded so the omission reads as an editorial decision, not a build error.

Mutatis mutandis encoded by restatement (rule 8) “Section 184b(5) to (7) shall apply mutatis mutandis” is restated locally with the corresponding scope mapping: [Exemption5] negates paragraph 1 point 2 and paragraph 3; [Exemption6] negates paragraph 1 points 1, 2 and 4, per the §184b pattern. §184b(7) (seizure) is a consequence and does not compile; the reference to it is carried in the source only.

Subsidiarity of leg 4 “in so far as the act is not punishable under point 3” is {PunishableUnderPoint3} is false inside [Leg4] (rule 12).

Treatment §184c is Operomise-tagged.

§184e · Organisation of and attendance at child and youth pornography performances

PornographicPerformances · provenance StGB 184e · full section with imported exemption

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) Under Section 184b(1), a person who organises a child pornography performance shall also be punished. Under Section 184c(1), a person who organises a youth pornography performance shall also be punished. (2) Under Section 184b(3), a person who attends a child pornography performance shall also be punished. Under Section 184c(3), a person who attends a youth pornography performance shall also be punished. Section 184b(5)(1) and (3) shall apply mutatis mutandis.

«if PornographicPerformances is true»(1) Under Section 184b(1) shall also be punished {Actor} who «if {Organises} is true»organises «end if» «if {ChildPornographicPerformance} is true»a child pornography performance «end if». Under Section 184c(1) shall also be punished {Actor} who «if {Organises} is true»organises «end if» «if {YouthPornographicPerformance} is true»a youth pornography performance «end if». (2) Under Section 184b(3) shall also be punished {Actor} who «if {Attends} is true»attends «end if» «if {ChildPornographicPerformance} is true»a child pornography performance «end if». Under Section 184c(3) shall also be punished {Actor} who «if {Attends} is true»attends «end if» «if {YouthPornographicPerformance} is true»a youth pornography performance «end if». «if [Exemption] is true»Section 184b(5)(1) and (3) shall apply mutatis mutandis: the act «if {ServesExclusively} is true»serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of «end if» «if {StateTasks} is true»state tasks «end if» «if {OfficialDuties} is true»or official «end if» «if {ProfessionalDuties} is true»or professional duties «end if» «end if». «end if»

Annexes

Computables

[ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true [QualifyingPerformance] = ChildPornographicPerformance is true or YouthPornographicPerformance is true [Para1] = Organises is true and QualifyingPerformance is true [Para2] = Attends is true and QualifyingPerformance is true [Exemption] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true [PornographicPerformances] = Para1 is true or (Para2 is true and Exemption is false)

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
PPF-R01	condition	None		ChildPornographicPerformance is true
PPF-R02	condition	None		YouthPornographicPerformance is true
PPF-R03	act	Actor		Organises is true
PPF-R04	act	Actor		Attends is true
PPF-R05	condition	None		ServesExclusively is true
PPF-R06	condition	None		StateTasks is true
PPF-R07	condition	None		OfficialDuties is true
PPF-R08	condition	None		ProfessionalDuties is true
PPF-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not PornographicPerformances

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
A person who	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
the performance is a child pornographic performance	Merkmal	{ChildPornographicPerformance}	PPF-R01	is true
the performance is a youth pornographic performance	Merkmal	{YouthPornographicPerformance}	PPF-R02	is true
{Actor} organises the performance	Merkmal	{Organises}	PPF-R03	is true
{Actor} attends the performance	Merkmal	{Attends}	PPF-R04	is true
the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties	Merkmal	{ServesExclusively}	PPF-R05	is true
state tasks	Merkmal	{StateTasks}	PPF-R06	is true
official duties	Merkmal	{OfficialDuties}	PPF-R07	is true
professional duties	Merkmal	{ProfessionalDuties}	PPF-R08	is true

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{Attends}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} attends the performance
{ChildPornographicPerformance}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the performance is a child pornographic performance
{OfficialDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	official duties
{Organises}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} organises the performance
{ProfessionalDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	professional duties
{ServesExclusively}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties
{StateTasks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	state tasks
{YouthPornographicPerformance}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the performance is a youth pornographic performance

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: ({Actor} organises the performance and (the performance is a child pornographic performance or the performance is a youth pornographic performance)) or (({Actor} attends the performance and (the performance is a child pornographic performance or the performance is a youth pornographic performance)) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state tasks or official duties or professional duties))).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[ExemptDuty]	StateTasks, OfficialDuties, ProfessionalDuties	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[QualifyingPerformance]	ChildPornographicPerformance, YouthPornographicPerformance	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para1]	Organises, QualifyingPerformance	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para2]	Attends, QualifyingPerformance	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Exemption]	ServesExclusively, ExemptDuty	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[PornographicPerformances]	Para1, Para2, Exemption	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (PPF-P0)	[PornographicPerformances]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {Attends} ├─ {ChildPornographicPerformance} ├─ {OfficialDuties} ├─ {Organises} ├─ {ProfessionalDuties} ├─ {ServesExclusively} ├─ {StateTasks} ├─ {YouthPornographicPerformance} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true ├─ [QualifyingPerformance] = ChildPornographicPerformance is true or YouthPornographicPerformance is true ├─ [Para1] = Organises is true and QualifyingPerformance is true ├─ [Para2] = Attends is true and QualifyingPerformance is true ├─ [Exemption] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [PornographicPerformances] = Para1 is true or (Para2 is true and Exemption is false) ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [PornographicPerformances] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [PornographicPerformances] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [PornographicPerformances] depends on [ExemptDuty], [QualifyingPerformance], [Para1], [Para2], [Exemption]; none refer back to [PornographicPerformances]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{Attends}	Element/Datum: {Actor} attends the performance.?	Boolean
Q3	Session	{ChildPornographicPerformance}	Element/Datum: the performance is a child pornographic performance.?	Boolean
Q4	Session	{OfficialDuties}	Element/Datum: official duties.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{Organises}	Element/Datum: {Actor} organises the performance.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{ProfessionalDuties}	Element/Datum: professional duties.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{ServesExclusively}	Element/Datum: the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{StateTasks}	Element/Datum: state tasks.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{YouthPornographicPerformance}	Element/Datum: the performance is a youth pornographic performance.?	Boolean

Flags

Whole section Paragraph 1, organising a child or youth pornographic performance; paragraph 2, attending one; the imported §184b(5) points 1 and 3 exemption applied to attendance. The penalty references (“Under Section 184b(1) shall also be punished” and their three counterparts) struck per the marked-up source as sentencing references.

Mutatis mutandis encoded by restatement “Section 184b(5)(1) and (3) shall apply mutatis mutandis” is restated locally: [Exemption] = {ServesExclusively} and ({StateTasks} or {OfficialDuties} or {ProfessionalDuties}). Note the statute imports points 1 and 3 only; the agreement-tasks ground of §184b(5)(2) does not apply here. The exemption is applied to paragraph 2 (attendance), the conduct the referencing sentence governs; this scope mapping is the interpretive step the mutatis clause requires and is recorded here (rule 8).

Performance terms “kinderpornographische Darbietung” and “jugendpornographische Darbietung” are status predicates on the performance ({ChildPornographicPerformance}, {YouthPornographicPerformance}); the child and youth pornography definitions are authored in §184b(1)(1) and §184c(1)(1) respectively and resolve there by name.

Strikes The four penalty references struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §184e is Operomise-tagged.

§184h · Definition of a sexual act

SexualActs · provenance StGB 184h · consumed by name

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(§184h) For the purposes of this Act, sexual acts are only those which are of some significance in relation to the legal interest protected in each case.

«if SexualActs is true»a sexual act is one which «if {ActOfSomeSignificance} is true»is of some significance in relation to the legal interest protected in each case «end if»«end if»

Annexes

Computables

[SexualActs] = ActOfSomeSignificance is true

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
SAD-R01	condition	None	of some significance in relation to the legal interest protected in each case	ActOfSomeSignificance is true
SAD-D0	definition	None	the term is satisfied	SexualActs is true

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
a sexual act	term	[SexualActs]	—	applies where
of some significance	Merkmal	{ActOfSomeSignificance}	SAD-R01	is true

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{ActOfSomeSignificance}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act is of some significance in relation to the legal interest protected in each case

Reconstruction from the substrate

The term [SexualActs] applies where the act is of some significance in relation to the legal interest protected in each case.

A definition operome: it does not prohibit conduct but supplies a term consumed by name wherever a sexual act is an element. Assembled only from the variable surface forms and the computable structure in the XSD.

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[SexualActs]	ActOfSomeSignificance	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
definition (—)	[SexualActs]	re-derives	Defines the term; consumed by canonical name wherever a sexual act is an element of an offence.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {ActOfSomeSignificance} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [SexualActs] = ActOfSomeSignificance is true ↓ VERDICT (definition) ├─ [SexualActs] is true → the term is SATISFIED (consumed by name where a sexual act is an element) └─ [SexualActs] is false → the term is not satisfied

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [SexualActs] depends on ; none refer back to [SexualActs]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{ActOfSomeSignificance}	Element/Datum: the act is of some significance in relation to the legal interest protected in each case.?	Boolean

Flags

Definition, named by the term Authors [SexualActs], consumed by name wherever a sexual act is an element. Named by the term, not suffixed Definition (R11).

§184j · Offences from groups

GroupOffences · provenance StGB 184j · single sentence, subsidiarity encoded

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

Anyone who encourages a criminal offence by participating in a group of persons which besets another person for the commission of a criminal offence against that person shall be punished with imprisonment for up to two years or a fine if a member of the group commits an offence under Sections 177 or 184i and the offence is not punishable by a more severe penalty under other provisions.

«if GroupOffences is true»{Actor} who «if {EncouragesOffence} is true»encourages a criminal offence «end if» by «if {ParticipatesInGroup} is true»participating in a {Group} «end if» «if {GroupBesetsPerson} is true»which besets {Person} for the commission of a criminal offence against {Person} «end if» shall be punished with imprisonment for up to two years or a fine if «if {MemberCommits177} is true»a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 177 «end if» «if {MemberCommits184i} is true»or Section 184i «end if» and «if {MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere} is false»the offence is not punishable by a more severe penalty under other provisions «end if». «end if»

Annexes

Computables

[GroupOffence] = MemberCommits177 is true or MemberCommits184i is true [GroupOffences] = EncouragesOffence is true and ParticipatesInGroup is true and GroupBesetsPerson is true and GroupOffence is true and MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere is false

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
GRO-R01	act	Actor		EncouragesOffence is true
GRO-R02	act	Actor		ParticipatesInGroup is true
GRO-R03	condition	None		GroupBesetsPerson is true
GRO-R04	condition	None		MemberCommits177 is true
GRO-R05	condition	None		MemberCommits184i is true
GRO-R06	condition	None		MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere is true
GRO-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not GroupOffences

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
Anyone who	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
{Actor} encourages a criminal offence	Merkmal	{EncouragesOffence}	GRO-R01	is true
{Actor} participates in the {Group}	Merkmal	{ParticipatesInGroup}	GRO-R02	is true
the {Group} besets {Person} for the commission of a criminal offence against {Person}	Merkmal	{GroupBesetsPerson}	GRO-R03	is true
a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 177	Merkmal	{MemberCommits177}	GRO-R04	is true
a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 184i	Merkmal	{MemberCommits184i}	GRO-R05	is true
the act is punishable by a more severe penalty under other provisions	Merkmal	{MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere}	GRO-R06	is true

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{EncouragesOffence}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} encourages a criminal offence
{Group}	Party	–	Session	a group of persons
{GroupBesetsPerson}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the {Group} besets {Person} for the commission of a criminal offence against {Person}
{MemberCommits177}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 177
{MemberCommits184i}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 184i
{MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act is punishable by a more severe penalty under other provisions
{ParticipatesInGroup}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} participates in the {Group}
{Person}	Party	–	Session	the beset person

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: {Actor} encourages a criminal offence and {Actor} participates in the {Group} and the {Group} besets {Person} for the commission of a criminal offence against {Person} and (a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 177 or a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 184i) and not the act is punishable by a more severe penalty under other provisions.

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[GroupOffence]	MemberCommits177, MemberCommits184i	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[GroupOffences]	EncouragesOffence, ParticipatesInGroup, GroupBesetsPerson, GroupOffence, MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (GRO-P0)	[GroupOffences]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Actor} ├─ {EncouragesOffence} ├─ {Group} ├─ {GroupBesetsPerson} ├─ {MemberCommits177} ├─ {MemberCommits184i} ├─ {MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere} ├─ {ParticipatesInGroup} ├─ {Person} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [GroupOffence] = MemberCommits177 is true or MemberCommits184i is true ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [GroupOffences] = EncouragesOffence is true and ParticipatesInGroup is true and GroupBesetsPerson is true and GroupOffence is true and MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere is false ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [GroupOffences] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [GroupOffences] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [GroupOffences] depends on [GroupOffence]; none refer back to [GroupOffences]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q2	Session	{EncouragesOffence}	Element/Datum: {Actor} encourages a criminal offence.?	Boolean
Q3	Session	{Group}	Element/Datum: a group of persons.?	Party
Q4	Session	{GroupBesetsPerson}	Element/Datum: the {Group} besets {Person} for the commission of a criminal offence against {Person}.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{MemberCommits177}	Element/Datum: a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 177.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{MemberCommits184i}	Element/Datum: a member of the {Group} commits an offence under Section 184i.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere}	Element/Datum: the act is punishable by a more severe penalty under other provisions.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{ParticipatesInGroup}	Element/Datum: {Actor} participates in the {Group}.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{Person}	Element/Datum: the beset person.?	Party

Flags

Whole section The single-sentence group offence: encouraging an offence by participating in a group that besets a person, conditioned on a group member committing a §177 or §184i offence and on subsidiarity.

Translation note The draft English layer (“which pressures another person to commit a criminal offence against them”) inverts the German: “die eine andere Person zur Begehung einer Straftat an ihr bedrängt” means the group besets the person for the commission of an offence against her, by group members, not that the person is pressed into committing one. The source column carries that reading.

Subsidiarity as a negative condition “not punishable by a more severe penalty under other provisions” is encoded as {MoreSeverePenaltyElsewhere} is false in the composite, with the markup binding the statutory words to the is-false span (rules 8, 12).

Condition on a third party's act {MemberCommits177} and {MemberCommits184i} are objective conditions about a group member's completed offence, resolved by name against the §177 operome and, for §184i, against a provision outside the encoded corpus; the §184i leg therefore resolves only as an input until §184i is encoded.

Strikes The penalty struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §184j is Human-awareness-tagged; whether participation encouraged the offence in fact is evaluative and escalates.

§184l · Placing on the market, acquisition and possession of sex dolls with a child-like appearance

ChildLikeSexDollOffences · provenance StGB 184l · (1) s.1, (2), (4) encoded

Source (English, unofficial)

Operome markup - original text encoded

(1) A person shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or a fine if they 1. produces, offers or advertises a physical replica of a child or a part of a child’s body which, by its nature, is intended for the performance of sexual acts, or 2. trades in a replica as described in point 1, or transports it for this purpose within or through the territorial scope of this Act, or 3. without engaging in trade, sells, dispenses or otherwise places on the market a replica as described in point 1. Sentence 1 shall not apply if the offence is punishable by a more severe penalty under Section 184b. (2) A person who acquires, possesses or transports a replica as described in paragraph 1, sentence 1, point 1, within or through the territorial scope of this Act shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or a fine. Paragraph 1, sentence 2, shall apply mutatis mutandis. (3) In the cases referred to in paragraph 1, sentence 1, points 2 and 3, an attempt is punishable. (4) Paragraph 1, first sentence, point 3, and paragraph 2 shall not apply to acts carried out solely for the lawful performance of state functions or official or professional duties. (5) Objects to which the offence relates shall be confiscated. Section 74a shall apply.

«if ChildLikeSexDollOffences is true»(1) {Actor} shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or a fine if they 1. «if {Produces} is true»produces «end if» «if {Offers} is true», offers «end if» «if {Advertises} is true»or advertises «end if» «if [QualifyingReplica] is true»a physical {Replica} «if {ReplicaOfChild} is true»of a child «end if» «if {ReplicaOfChildBodyPart} is true»or a part of a child's body «end if» «if {IntendedForSexualActs} is true»which, by its nature, is intended for the performance of sexual acts «end if» «end if», or 2. «if {TradesIn} is true»trades in such a {Replica} «end if» «if {TransportsForTrade} is true»or transports it for this purpose within or through the territorial scope of this Act «end if», or 3. {NotTrading} without engaging in trade, «if {Sells} is true»sells «end if» «if {Dispenses} is true», dispenses «end if» «if {PlacesOnMarket} is true»or otherwise places on the market «end if» such a {Replica}. Sentence 1 shall not apply if the offence is punishable by a more severe penalty under Section 184b. (2) {Actor} who «if {Acquires} is true»acquires «end if» «if {Possesses} is true», possesses «end if» «if {Transports} is true»or transports within or through the territorial scope of this Act «end if» «if [QualifyingReplica] is true»such a {Replica} «end if» shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or a fine. Paragraph 1, sentence 2, shall apply mutatis mutandis. (3) In the cases referred to in paragraph 1, sentence 1, points 2 and 3, an attempt is punishable. (4) Paragraph 1, first sentence, point 3, and paragraph 2 shall not apply «if [Exemption4] is true»to acts «if {ServesExclusively} is true»carried out solely for the lawful performance of «end if» «if {StateTasks} is true»state functions «end if» «if {OfficialDuties} is true»or official «end if» «if {ProfessionalDuties} is true»or professional duties «end if» «end if». (5) Objects to which the offence relates shall be confiscated. Section 74a shall apply.«end if»

Annexes

Computables

[QualifyingReplica] = (ReplicaOfChild is true or ReplicaOfChildBodyPart is true) and IntendedForSexualActs is true [Leg1] = QualifyingReplica is true and (Produces is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true) [Para2] = QualifyingReplica is true and (Acquires is true or Possesses is true or Transports is true) [ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true [Exemption4] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true [Leg2] = QualifyingReplica is true and (TradesIn is true or TransportsForTrade is true) [Leg3] = QualifyingReplica is true and NotTrading is true and (Sells is true or Dispenses is true or PlacesOnMarket is true) [ChildLikeSexDollOffences] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or (Leg3 is true and Exemption4 is false) or (Para2 is true and Exemption4 is false)

Business rules

id	kind	actor	verb / predicate	body
SDO-R01	condition	None		ReplicaOfChild is true
SDO-R02	condition	None		ReplicaOfChildBodyPart is true
SDO-R03	condition	None		IntendedForSexualActs is true
SDO-R04	act	Actor		Produces is true
SDO-R05	act	Actor		Offers is true
SDO-R06	act	Actor		Advertises is true
SDO-R07	act	Actor		TradesIn is true
SDO-R08	act	Actor		TransportsForTrade is true
SDO-R09	condition	None		NotTrading is true
SDO-R10	act	Actor		Sells is true
SDO-R11	act	Actor		Dispenses is true
SDO-R12	act	Actor		PlacesOnMarket is true
SDO-R13	act	Actor		Acquires is true
SDO-R14	act	Actor		Possesses is true
SDO-R15	act	Actor		Transports is true
SDO-R16	condition	None		ServesExclusively is true
SDO-R17	condition	None		StateTasks is true
SDO-R18	condition	None		OfficialDuties is true
SDO-R19	condition	None		ProfessionalDuties is true
SDO-P0	prohibition	Actor	not realise	not ChildLikeSexDollOffences

Tatbestand dissected to the Merkmal

Source phrase	Doctrinal role	Primitive	Rule	Requires
A person ... if they	Tätersubjekt	{Actor}	—	in scope
the {Replica} is a replica of a child	Merkmal	{ReplicaOfChild}	SDO-R01	is true
the {Replica} is a replica of a part of a child's body	Merkmal	{ReplicaOfChildBodyPart}	SDO-R02	is true
the {Replica} is by its nature intended for the performance of sexual acts	Merkmal	{IntendedForSexualActs}	SDO-R03	is true
{Actor} produces the {Replica}	Merkmal	{Produces}	SDO-R04	is true
{Actor} offers the {Replica}	Merkmal	{Offers}	SDO-R05	is true
{Actor} advertises the {Replica}	Merkmal	{Advertises}	SDO-R06	is true
{Actor} trades in the {Replica}	Merkmal	{TradesIn}	SDO-R07	is true
{Actor} transports the {Replica} for this purpose through the territorial scope of this Act	Merkmal	{TransportsForTrade}	SDO-R08	is true
without engaging in trade	Merkmal	{NotTrading}	SDO-R09	is true
{Actor} sells the {Replica}	Merkmal	{Sells}	SDO-R10	is true
{Actor} dispenses the {Replica}	Merkmal	{Dispenses}	SDO-R11	is true
{Actor} otherwise places the {Replica} on the market	Merkmal	{PlacesOnMarket}	SDO-R12	is true
{Actor} acquires the {Replica}	Merkmal	{Acquires}	SDO-R13	is true
{Actor} possesses the {Replica}	Merkmal	{Possesses}	SDO-R14	is true
{Actor} transports the {Replica} through the territorial scope of this Act	Merkmal	{Transports}	SDO-R15	is true
the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties	Merkmal	{ServesExclusively}	SDO-R16	is true
state functions	Merkmal	{StateTasks}	SDO-R17	is true
official duties	Merkmal	{OfficialDuties}	SDO-R18	is true
professional duties	Merkmal	{ProfessionalDuties}	SDO-R19	is true
(1) s.2 subsidiarity to §184b; (3) attempt; (5) confiscation; footnote	subsidiarity / attempt / consequences	— excluded —	—	struck

Variables appendix

Variable	Input	Values	Cascade	Surface form (source words)
{Acquires}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} acquires the {Replica}
{Actor}	Reference	–	Session	any person (the actor)
{Advertises}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} advertises the {Replica}
{Dispenses}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} dispenses the {Replica}
{IntendedForSexualActs}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the {Replica} is by its nature intended for the performance of sexual acts
{NotTrading}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	without engaging in trade
{Offers}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} offers the {Replica}
{OfficialDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	official duties
{PlacesOnMarket}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} otherwise places the {Replica} on the market
{Possesses}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} possesses the {Replica}
{Produces}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} produces the {Replica}
{ProfessionalDuties}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	professional duties
{Replica}	Party	–	Session	the physical replica
{ReplicaOfChild}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the {Replica} is a replica of a child
{ReplicaOfChildBodyPart}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the {Replica} is a replica of a part of a child's body
{Sells}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} sells the {Replica}
{ServesExclusively}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties
{StateTasks}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	state functions
{TradesIn}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} trades in the {Replica}
{Transports}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} transports the {Replica} through the territorial scope of this Act
{TransportsForTrade}	Boolean	true / false / unknown	Session	{Actor} transports the {Replica} for this purpose through the territorial scope of this Act

Reconstruction from the substrate

Committed by any person (the actor) who: (((the {Replica} is a replica of a child or the {Replica} is a replica of a part of a child's body) and the {Replica} is by its nature intended for the performance of sexual acts) and ({Actor} produces the {Replica} or {Actor} offers the {Replica} or {Actor} advertises the {Replica})) or (((the {Replica} is a replica of a child or the {Replica} is a replica of a part of a child's body) and the {Replica} is by its nature intended for the performance of sexual acts) and ({Actor} trades in the {Replica} or {Actor} transports the {Replica} for this purpose through the territorial scope of this Act)) or ((((the {Replica} is a replica of a child or the {Replica} is a replica of a part of a child's body) and the {Replica} is by its nature intended for the performance of sexual acts) and without engaging in trade and ({Actor} sells the {Replica} or {Actor} dispenses the {Replica} or {Actor} otherwise places the {Replica} on the market)) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state functions or official duties or professional duties))) or ((((the {Replica} is a replica of a child or the {Replica} is a replica of a part of a child's body) and the {Replica} is by its nature intended for the performance of sexual acts) and ({Actor} acquires the {Replica} or {Actor} possesses the {Replica} or {Actor} transports the {Replica} through the territorial scope of this Act)) and it is not the case that (the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties and (state functions or official duties or professional duties))).

Dependent assessments (reactive invalidation)

Assessment	Depends on	Invalidation	Trigger effect
[QualifyingReplica]	ReplicaOfChild, ReplicaOfChildBodyPart, IntendedForSexualActs	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg1]	QualifyingReplica, Produces, Offers, Advertises	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Para2]	QualifyingReplica, Acquires, Possesses, Transports	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ExemptDuty]	StateTasks, OfficialDuties, ProfessionalDuties	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Exemption4]	ServesExclusively, ExemptDuty	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg2]	QualifyingReplica, TradesIn, TransportsForTrade	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[Leg3]	QualifyingReplica, NotTrading, Sells, Dispenses, PlacesOnMarket	false	Recomputes when any input changes; propagates into the composite.
[ChildLikeSexDollOffences]	Leg1, Leg2, Leg3, Exemption4, Para2, Exemption4	false	Final composite. Re-evaluates on any input change; cannot resolve true while any input is unknown.
prohibition (SDO-P0)	[ChildLikeSexDollOffences]	re-derives	The PrimeRule prohibition holds whenever the composite is true; re-derives on any change.

Decision tree

PHASE 1: gather inputs (Session) ├─ {Acquires} ├─ {Actor} ├─ {Advertises} ├─ {Dispenses} ├─ {IntendedForSexualActs} ├─ {NotTrading} ├─ {Offers} ├─ {OfficialDuties} ├─ {PlacesOnMarket} ├─ {Possesses} ├─ {Produces} ├─ {ProfessionalDuties} ├─ {Replica} ├─ {ReplicaOfChild} ├─ {ReplicaOfChildBodyPart} ├─ {Sells} ├─ {ServesExclusively} ├─ {StateTasks} ├─ {TradesIn} ├─ {Transports} ├─ {TransportsForTrade} ↓ PHASE 2: evaluate act / intermediate computables ├─ [QualifyingReplica] = (ReplicaOfChild is true or ReplicaOfChildBodyPart is true) and IntendedForSexualActs is true ├─ [Leg1] = QualifyingReplica is true and (Produces is true or Offers is true or Advertises is true) ├─ [Para2] = QualifyingReplica is true and (Acquires is true or Possesses is true or Transports is true) ├─ [ExemptDuty] = StateTasks is true or OfficialDuties is true or ProfessionalDuties is true ├─ [Exemption4] = ServesExclusively is true and ExemptDuty is true ├─ [Leg2] = QualifyingReplica is true and (TradesIn is true or TransportsForTrade is true) ├─ [Leg3] = QualifyingReplica is true and NotTrading is true and (Sells is true or Dispenses is true or PlacesOnMarket is true) ↓ PHASE 3: evaluate the objective conditions └─ [ChildLikeSexDollOffences] = Leg1 is true or Leg2 is true or (Leg3 is true and Exemption4 is false) or (Para2 is true and Exemption4 is false) ↓ VERDICT (PrimeRule) ├─ [ChildLikeSexDollOffences] is true → objective conditions realised → conduct PROHIBITED (subject to permissions / exceptions) └─ [ChildLikeSexDollOffences] is false → not realised

Recursion / re-entry notes

Circularity check

• [ChildLikeSexDollOffences] depends on [QualifyingReplica], [Leg1], [Para2], [ExemptDuty], [Exemption4], [Leg2], [Leg3]; none refer back to [ChildLikeSexDollOffences]. No definitional cycle.

• Each computable reduces to input Booleans; the graph is a DAG and topologically sortable. Tristate is monotone: any unknown input holds the composite at unknown rather than forcing a verdict.

Questionnaire

#	Cascade	Variable	Question / prompt	Input
Q1	Session	{Acquires}	Element/Datum: {Actor} acquires the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q2	Session	{Actor}	Who or what is the actor? Any natural person, legal person, or non-human system. Canonical home: PrimeRule.?	Reference
Q3	Session	{Advertises}	Element/Datum: {Actor} advertises the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q4	Session	{Dispenses}	Element/Datum: {Actor} dispenses the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q5	Session	{IntendedForSexualActs}	Element/Datum: the {Replica} is by its nature intended for the performance of sexual acts.?	Boolean
Q6	Session	{NotTrading}	Element/Datum: without engaging in trade.?	Boolean
Q7	Session	{Offers}	Element/Datum: {Actor} offers the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q8	Session	{OfficialDuties}	Element/Datum: official duties.?	Boolean
Q9	Session	{PlacesOnMarket}	Element/Datum: {Actor} otherwise places the {Replica} on the market.?	Boolean
Q10	Session	{Possesses}	Element/Datum: {Actor} possesses the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q11	Session	{Produces}	Element/Datum: {Actor} produces the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q12	Session	{ProfessionalDuties}	Element/Datum: professional duties.?	Boolean
Q13	Session	{Replica}	Element/Datum: the physical replica.?	Party
Q14	Session	{ReplicaOfChild}	Element/Datum: the {Replica} is a replica of a child.?	Boolean
Q15	Session	{ReplicaOfChildBodyPart}	Element/Datum: the {Replica} is a replica of a part of a child's body.?	Boolean
Q16	Session	{Sells}	Element/Datum: {Actor} sells the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q17	Session	{ServesExclusively}	Element/Datum: the act serves exclusively the lawful fulfilment of the referenced duties.?	Boolean
Q18	Session	{StateTasks}	Element/Datum: state functions.?	Boolean
Q19	Session	{TradesIn}	Element/Datum: {Actor} trades in the {Replica}.?	Boolean
Q20	Session	{Transports}	Element/Datum: {Actor} transports the {Replica} through the territorial scope of this Act.?	Boolean
Q21	Session	{TransportsForTrade}	Element/Datum: {Actor} transports the {Replica} for this purpose through the territorial scope of this Act.?	Boolean

Flags

Scope Paragraph 1 sentence 1, the three placing-on-the-market legs over the qualifying replica; paragraph 2, the acquisition, possession and transport offence; paragraph 4, the state-functions exemption, encoded live and scoped to paragraph 1 point 3 and paragraph 2 as the statute states. Struck per the marked-up source: paragraph 1 sentence 2 (subsidiarity to §184b), paragraph 3 (attempt), paragraph 5 (confiscation) and the notification footnote.

Replica definition authored here [QualifyingReplica] = ({ReplicaOfChild} or {ReplicaOfChildBodyPart}) and {IntendedForSexualActs}; the nature-intended element is an objective property of the object (“nach ihrer Beschaffenheit ... bestimmt”), not a mental element, and compiles. Points 2 and 3 and paragraph 2 consume the definition by reference (“a replica as described in point 1”).

Open question: live reference to struck text Paragraph 2's closing sentence, “Paragraph 1, sentence 2, shall apply mutatis mutandis”, is live in the markup, but the referenced sentence (the subsidiarity to §184b) is itself struck. The sentence is carried in the markup unencoded; if the strike of (1) sentence 2 stands, this reference has no compilable content and should on consistency grounds be struck as well. Confirm before external circulation.

Leg 3 qualifier “ohne Handel zu treiben” is the inline qualifier {NotTrading} gating the three market verbs {Sells} (veräußert), {Dispenses} (abgibt) and {PlacesOnMarket} (sonst in Verkehr bringt).

Exemption scoping (rule 8) [Exemption4] = {ServesExclusively} and ({StateTasks} or {OfficialDuties} or {ProfessionalDuties}) negates leg 3 and paragraph 2 only; legs 1 and 2 are not exempted, and the composite applies the negation per leg.

Strikes Penalties, (1) sentence 2, (3), (5) and the EU notification footnote struck in the markup only; the source column is clean.

Treatment §184l is Human-awareness-tagged; whether a replica has a child-like appearance is evaluative at the margin and escalates.

SynapseLayer operome extraction · Lisbon · 09 June 2026 · sections §180, §180a, §181a, §182, §184a, §184b, §184c, §184e, §184h, §184j, §184l